A Foreign Country (27 page)

‘The Gillespie’s not a patch on this,’ she joked. She spent the majority of her time alone, sitting in the room, reading a new biography of Virginia Woolf and working through the plan for Saturday morning.

‘It’ll be Miss Marple all over again,’ he had told her. ‘Put on a show like the one in Nice and we’ll put you up for a BAFTA.’

Spying is waiting.

On the Thursday evening, with Amelia still in London and Vincent still in Paris, Harold and Barbara had driven into Salisbury to watch a film, leaving Kell and Elsa alone in the house with nothing to do but reminisce about Nice and to work through the final details of the operation.

‘Amelia is going to try to persuade Vincent to go for a walk with her on Saturday morning. If the weather’s bad, she’ll suggest visiting a pub near Tisbury for lunch. Either way, we should have enough time to get into his room and soak his gear. There’s no mobile reception in the valley, so if we’re lucky, he might have switched off his phone and left it behind as well.’

‘This would be
very
lucky, I think,’ Elsa replied. She had three separate gold studs in her left ear and Kell kept staring at them, thinking of her other lives. ‘All I need is fifteen minutes with the laptop. I can copy over everything from his hard drive, then bring it back here for analysis. If he’s getting emails from his people, we can start to read them. If they are being careless, we might be able to trace where the messages are coming from.’

‘What do you mean “if they’re being careless”?’

‘Anybody serious wouldn’t email from the location where they are holding Amelia’s son. They would drive a few kilometres away, do it from there. People often keep a device for that purpose away from the base. But it can be a pain working like this and sometimes people get lazy.’

Kell thought of Marseille, of his own computer stripped down by Luc and handed back, complete with key-logger software and the tracking device. He had told Elsa about the attack in Cité Radieuse and she had touched the scar on his face, a tenderness which had surprised him. In Nice, he had been concerned that Elsa was playing him, most likely at Marquand’s request, but there was surely now no reason to doubt her.

‘You were a little dismissive with me the first time we met,’ she said.

‘I was working,’ he replied.

‘This is fine. I expected it. Jimmy told me that you could be … what is the word?’

‘Wonderful?’

A swipe of laughter. ‘No. Impatient. A little arrogant …’

‘Brusque.’

Elsa had never heard the word before. She tried it out, rolling it around, and decided that it was adequate enough as a description of Thomas Kell. ‘Brusque, yes. Then later on, much kinder to me. I liked our conversations.’

He was surprised by her flirting, but enjoyed it. She had a way of dismantling his professional veneer, of strolling into the more private rooms of his personality with what felt like the fearlessness of youth.

‘You did a fantastic job,’ he said, and meant it. The research Elsa had done into Malot’s background had unlocked the DGSE operation and led him to Christophe Delestre.

‘Let’s eat,’ she replied.

The day before, Harold had stocked up on ready-meals for the team at a supermarket in Salisbury. Opening the fridge at lunchtime, looking for something to eat, Elsa had dismissed the food as ‘disgraceful’ and duly set about making a batch of fresh pasta in the kitchen. Within half an hour, she had transformed the room into a bombsite of bowls and dough, flour hanging in the air like the dawn mists over the Chalke Valley. Now she cooked the pasta for Kell, who opened a bottle of wine from Shand’s cellar and sat at the kitchen table, watching as she chopped courgettes, frying them in garlic and olive oil.

‘You look like you know what you’re doing.’

‘I am Italian,’ she replied, happy to bask in the stereotype. ‘But in return for your supper, I want to hear all of Thomas Kell’s secrets.’

‘All of them?’

‘All of them.’

‘That may take a long time.’

He did not want to talk about his marriage; that was his only boundary. Not out of loyalty to Claire, but because the story of their relationship was a story of failure.

‘Start with why you left the Service.’

He had been drinking wine and stopped the glass against his lips, surprised that Elsa had broached the subject of his disgrace.

‘How did you know about that?’

He was not angry; indeed, he felt an odd sense of relief, finding that he wanted to speak candidly of what had happened.

‘People talk,’ she replied.

‘It’s a complicated situation. I’m not supposed to discuss it.’

Elsa had put a pan on to boil. She looked at him with a quick, mock contempt and threw salt into the water.

‘Nobody is going to hear us, Tom. We are alone in the house. Tell me.’

And so he told her. He told her about Kabul and he told her about Yassin.

‘After 9/11, I did a lot of work alongside the Americans. They were angry about what had been done to them. Understandably so. They were ashamed and they wanted revenge. I think that’s a fair assessment of their state of mind.’

‘Go on.’

‘Late 2001, I went into Afghanistan with a team from the Office. Joint operation with Langley. All of us had been caught off guard by what had happened in Washington and New York. We were playing catch-up, making things up as we went along.’

‘Sure.’ Elsa was watching the pan, her back to him, waiting for him to find his rhythm. She was wearing blue denim jeans and a white T-shirt. Kell stole a married man’s glance at her body, all the time falling into the trap of trusting her.

‘I made seven separate visits to Pakistan and Afghanistan over the next three years. In ’04, the CIA arrested a man who you may have heard of. Yassin Gharani. He’d been in Pakistan where he’d attended an al-Qaeda training camp in the north-west. He told the Yanks he was a British citizen, had the passport to prove it. He’d subsequently been moved to their operations centre in Kabul, which is where they started to interrogate him.’

‘Interrogate.’

‘Interview. Question. Cross-examine.’ Kell wasn’t sure whether he was giving Elsa an English lesson or whether she was one step ahead of him on the semantics. ‘He had not been mistreated, if that’s what you’re driving at. Langley was informed by MI5 that they had a file on Yassin. He’d been on a watch-list of terrorist suspects in the north-east of England. Not a flagged threat, not a target, no surveillance. But they knew about him, had been worried about him, they’d wondered where he’d gone.’

‘So it makes sense to everybody that a young man like this goes to Pakistan and trains to fight?’

‘It makes sense.’ Kell poured himself more wine and stood to refill Elsa’s glass. She had fried the courgettes and set them to one side in the pan and now slowly lowered the pasta into the water.

‘Thank you,’ she said, nodding at the glass. ‘The tagliatelle, it takes only a couple of minutes.’

Kell took two bowls from a dresser beside the kitchen door, retrieved spoons and forks from a drawer. He put the cutlery on the table in front of him, the bowls next to the stove so that Elsa could reach them. Then he picked up the story.

‘Now here’s Gharani, a twenty-one-year-old student from Leeds, pretending to be visiting friends in Lahore, but the Americans have photographic evidence that Yassin is a jihad tourist who just got taught how to fire a rocket-propelled grenade in Malakand. I told him he had to be careful. I told him that his best prospect lay in talking to his own government. If he was honest about what he had done, about the people he knew back home, then I could help him. If he wasn’t, if he decided to keep quiet and keep playing the innocent, then I couldn’t be responsible for what the Americans would do with him.’

‘I know this story,’ Elsa said. She tested the pasta, pulling a single strand from the water and pressing it between her fingers. She wrapped a tea towel around the handle of the pan, took it to the sink and poured the contents into a metal colander, steam fogging into her face. She reared back and said: ‘The CIA tortured him, yes?’

Kell felt a quick burst of irritation at her easy assumption of American guilt. He wondered if Elsa had worked on the case in some capacity or had merely read about it in the European press.

‘Let’s just say that the Yanks were tough on him,’ he said. ‘We all were.’

‘What does that mean?’

Kell shifted in his seat, choosing his words carefully.

‘It means that we were a long way from home. It means that we were trying to break up terrorist cells in the UK and US. We felt that Yassin knew things that would be useful to us and we ran out of patience with him when he wouldn’t talk.’ Kell found himself coughing. ‘Eventually certain individuals became aggressive.’ He composed himself, still protecting the identities of American colleagues who had stepped over the line. ‘Did I physically touch him? No. Did I push him around? No, absolutely not. Did I threaten to get to his family in Leeds? At no point.’

Elsa did not visibly react. Her face was still as she said:

‘So the interview was as they described it?’ It was as though she had stopped herself using the word ‘torture’, like somebody stepping around a puddle. ‘What happened, Tom?’

Kell looked up. She was no longer serving the food, as if the meal was being held in quarantine. She was not judging him. Not yet. But she wanted to hear his answer.

‘You’re asking a man you’re about to sit down and eat supper with if he water-boarded a suspect? If I pulled out a man’s fingernails?’

‘Did you?’

Kell felt all of the despair of his final weeks at Vauxhall Cross rushing up to confront him.

‘Do you think I would be capable of that?’

‘I think we are all of us capable of doing anything.’

Yet the tone of Elsa’s reply implied that she trusted Kell to have behaved within the law and within the boundaries of his own decency. He felt a great affection for her at this moment, because such an accommodation was more than Claire had ever been able to provide for him. At times in the preceding months, turned out of SIS in quiet disgrace, he had felt like a criminal; at others, like the only man in England capable of understanding the true nature of the threat from men like Yassin Gharani.

‘I did not torture him,’ he said. ‘SIS does not torture people. Officers from both services do not break the codes of conduct with which they are issued whenever they go into …’

‘You sound like a lawyer.’ Elsa opened a window, an airlock being cleared. ‘So what’s the problem?’

‘The problem is the relationship with the Americans, the problem is the press and the problem is the law. Somewhere between those three points you have spies trying to do their job with one hand tied behind their backs. The media in London took the line that Yassin was a British national, innocent until proven guilty, who was tortured by Bush and Cheney, then flown to Guantanamo and stripped of his dignity. Habeas corpus. They charged that MI6 turned a blind eye to what went on.’

‘What’s your view on that? Did you ask where they were taking Yassin? Were you concerned about his condition?’

Kell felt the flutter of guilt, the shame of his own moral neglect, yet the certainty that he would not now act differently. ‘No. And no.’

Elsa looked up and met his eyes. Kell remembered the cell in Kabul. He remembered the stink and the sweat of the room, the wretchedness on Yassin’s face, his own lust for information and his contempt for everything that Yassin stood for. Kell’s zeal had obscured even the slight possibility that the young man in front of him, starved of sleep and care, was anything other than a brainwashed jihadi.

‘What I did, what several intelligence officers did, what was wrong in the eyes of the law and in the eyes of the press, was to allow others to behave in a way that was not in keeping with our own values. They found words for what we were accused of doing. “Passive rendition”; “Outsourced torture”. This has always been the British way, they said, since imperial times. Get others to do your dirty work for you.’ Elsa placed two pieces of kitchen roll on the table as napkins. ‘Yassin was taken away.’ Kell gathered his thoughts as he drank a mouthful of wine. ‘The truth is – yes – I didn’t really care what happened to him. I didn’t think about what methods the Egyptians would use, what might go on in Cairo or Guantanamo. As far as I was concerned, here was a young British man whose sole purpose in life was to murder innocent civilians – in Washington, in Rome, in
Chalke Bissett
. I thought he was a coward and a fool, and the truth is I was glad to see him in custody. That was my sin. I forgot to care for a man who wanted to destroy everything that it was my job to protect.’

Elsa poured olive oil on to the pasta and stirred the courgettes and garlic into the long broad strands of tagliatelle. Kell could not interpret her mood nor sense where her opinion lay.

‘So you’re the fall guy?’ she asked and he knew that he must be careful not to moan or complain. The last thing he wanted was for this lovely girl to feel pity for him.

‘Somebody had to be,’ he said, and remembered how Truscott had cut him loose: authorizing an SIS presence at the Yassin interrogation from a desk in London thousands of miles away; then brazenly accusing Kell of acting beyond the law when, years later, it looked as though the Foreign Secretary was going to get cooked by the
Guardian
over rendition. Kell had been thrown on the mercy of the courts, given a suitably anonymous, Orwellian codename – ‘Witness X’ – and pitched out of the Service.

‘I’ll tell you this,’ he said, ‘and then I’ll stop talking. We are in a political and intelligence relationship with the Americans that goes deeper than anybody realizes and deeper than anyone is prepared to admit. If British spies see their American allies engaged in methods with which they disagree, what are they meant to do? Ring up Mummy and say they disapprove? Tell their line managers that they want to come home because they don’t feel comfortable about things? This is a
war
we are fighting. The Americans are our friends, whatever you thought of Bush and his chums, whatever your feelings on Guantanamo or Abu Ghraib.’