A Very Expensive Poison (35 page)

Read A Very Expensive Poison Online

Authors: Luke Harding

I wondered if she could envisage ever going back to Russia. ‘I very much miss my mother, who is now alone,’ she replied. In the summer of 2015, shortly after the inquiry wound up, her father died. ‘I couldn’t go to the funeral. I realised you had to pay the “price”. Unfortunately, the price is I cannot go to Russia.’ The current political reality, she said, meant that she didn’t ‘feel safe there’. The danger wasn’t only from the state: it was possible a ‘patriot’ might take matters into his own hands.

She said her conflict was never with her fellow Russians – or her Moscow friends, whom she misses. Rather it was with the regime. ‘I wish Russia to be a successful place, a happy country,’ she said. She saw herself as a real patriot, in contrast to the phoney ones inside the Kremlin who typically have secret property in the west and offshore bank accounts. ‘I want my son one day to go back to Russia, to do something in Russia, to be proud of Russia,’ she said.

Sir Robert’s report had brought to an end an almost ten-year saga of international intrigue and Cold War-style recrimination. At the end of it: vindication. Marina quoted from what Litvinenko had said in his dying declaration: that Putin might snuff out one man but not ‘the howls of protest from around the world’. ‘I believe what my husband Sasha said. You can of course silence one person. But you can’t silence the world.’

The Litvinenko inquiry website,
www.litvinenkoinquiry.org
, is an invaluable source of information about the Litvinenko case, much of it used in this book. For more than eight years, details of Scotland Yard’s murder investigation remained secret. Now the evidence is publicly available: witness statements, including Litvinenko’s; a forensic report into every location contaminated by polonium; testimony by expert scientists; police interviews with the two killers in Moscow. The website features transcripts of all thirty-four days of hearings at the High Court, and the evidence of sixty-two witnesses.

This was one of the UK’s most extensive murder inquiries. Many details are remarkable. The Met’s modelling department mapped radiation readings onto graphic 3D reconstructions of key locations. We can see for the first time the object used to murder Litvinenko. (The actual photo reveals an ordinary white ceramic teapot. The graphic version is a lurid purple; purple is the colour code used to illustrate deadly levels of alpha radiation.)

There is CCTV footage of Litvinenko arriving at the Millennium Hotel; it freezes the moment before he was poisoned. Plus phone logs that confirm Dmitry Kovtun, one of history’s more inept murderers, was looking for a cook to administer what he called ‘a very expensive
poison’. We get some of the official record: confidential e-grams from Britain’s ambassador in Moscow; a brush-off from the Home Office to Litvinenko’s solicitor, in the wake of death threats from Moscow. And Litvinenko’s own writings and interviews.

The evidence we are missing belongs to the UK government. This was presented in secret to Sir Robert Owen. It informed his final report, but wasn’t made public. I asked one former MI6 officer when the agency’s files on Litvinenko might be released. He replied: ‘Never.’ He added: ‘We haven’t declassified anything since the beginning of the service in 1909.’ These documents might compromise serving agents, he said.

Still, we live in an era of large data leaks: Edward Snowden, WikiLeaks, the banking secrets of the rich and powerful. I’m confident that the files will eventually find their way into daylight. (If anyone wants to hasten this process, please send me what you can in a brown envelope.) Inside Russia there are likely to be few written documents: state murder is a clandestine business; Stalin’s instruction to assassinate Trotsky was delivered orally. But when Putin’s reign in Russia ends, new details may emerge, including from inside the FSB itself.

Most of the quotations in this book come from two primary sources: my conversations with those involved, and their public evidence before the inquiry. I’m grateful to the following who agreed to be interviewed: Marina and Anatoly Litvinenko; Alex Goldfarb; Ben Emmerson; Yuli Dubov; Nikolai Glushkov; Viktor Suvorov; Vladimir Bukovsky; Akhmed Zakayev; Olga Kryshtanovskaya;
Professor Norman Dombey; Bill Browder; and others. One or two of my interlocutors didn’t want to be named.

In Moscow, I interviewed Andrei Lugovoi twice, in 2008 and 2010, and Dmitry Kovtun in 2008. In Italy, I interviewed Litvinenko’s father and siblings. Before their deaths I met Boris Nemtsov, in Sochi, and Boris Berezovsky, in London.

I give a fuller account of the harassment my family and I faced in Moscow in my 2011 book
Mafia State: How One Reporter Became an Enemy of the Brutal New Russia
(published in the US in 2012 as
Expelled
). Some details are retold here when they are relevant to Litvinenko’s story. Others are new: the fact that I inadvertently flew to Moscow on Lugovoi’s polonium plane, sitting a few rows away from his contaminated seat.

I’m grateful to my colleagues at the
Guardian
– especially Kath Viner, Paul Johnson and Jamie Wilson – for allowing me to combine book writing with international reporting. And to Laura Hassan and my wonderful publisher Guardian Faber. Most of all, thanks to my wife Phoebe Taplin, my first and best reader.

The author would like to thank:

 

Fiona Bacon, Louis Blom-Cooper, Robert Booth, Irina Borogan, Oliver Bullough, Barbara Caspar, Paula Chertok, Lindsay Davies, Lizzy Davies, Martin Dewhirst, Norman Dombey, Ben Emmerson, Michael Fleischer, David Godwin, Alex Goldfarb, Felicity Harding, John Harding, Laura Hassan, Henning Hoff, David Leigh, Anatoly Litvinenko, Marina Litvinenko, Robin Milner-Gulland, Peter Neyroud, Richard Norton-Taylor, Robert Service, Alex Shprintsen, Andrei Soldatov, Adam Straw, Phoebe Taplin, Andrei Terekhov, Elena Tsirlina, Cyril Tuschi, Federico Varese, Shaun Walker, Jamie Wilson.

 

Photo credits

Page 1: (top) courtesy of Marina Litvinenko; (bottom) © Rex

Page 2: (top left and right) courtesy of Marina Litvinenko; (bottom) Litvinenko Inquiry,
www.litvinenko.org

Page 3: (all images)
www.litvinenko.org

Page 4: (top and bottom)
www.litvinenko.org

Page 5: (top and bottom) © Getty Images

Page 6: (top left) Berezovsky © Rex; (top right) Abramovich © Getty Images; (middle) Perepilichnny courtesy of the
Guardian
; (bottom left) Nemtsov
© Associated Press; (bottom right) Nemtsov © Getty Images

Page 7: (top) © EMPR/Barcroft; (bottom) © Reuters

Plate 8: (top and bottom) © Getty Images

All images used within the text are reproduced by kind permission of the Litvinenko Inquiry (
www.litvinenko.org
) apart from p. 280, CCTV still taken from the Organized Crime and Corruption Reporting Project (
www.occrp.org
) and p.
361
, author’s own

Index

(the initials AL refer to Alexander Litvinenko)

  1. Abeltsev, Sergei
    1
  2. Abramovich, Roman:
    1. Berezovsky vs
      1
      ;
      1. judgment in
        1
    2. Chelsea FC bought by
      1
    3. property portfolio of
      1
    4. and Putin
      1
    5. and Sibneft
      1
  3. Aeroflot
    1
  4. Akhmetov, Rinat
    1
  5. Aksyonov, Sergey
    1
    ,
    2
    ,
    3
  6. Akulov, Vitaly
    1
  7. Alexashenko, Sergei
    1
    ,
    2
  8. Andrade, Norberto
    1
    ,
    2
  9. Andropov, Yuri
    1
    ,
    2
    ,
    3
  10. Atlangeriev, Ruslan
    1
  11. Atomic Weapons Establishment
    1
    ,
    2
    ,
    3
    ,
    4
    ,
    5
  12. Attew, Dean
    1
    ,
    2
  13. Aulov, Nikolai
    1
  14. Avakov, Arsen
    1
  1. Balfour, Charles
    1
  2. Bandera, Stepan
    1
  3. Barsukov, Vladimir
    1
  4. Bastrykin, Alexander
    1
    ,
    2
    ,
    3
  5. Baturina, Elena
    1
  6. Bedford, Peter
    1
  7. Bell, Tim
    1
  8. Berezovsky, Boris
    1
    passim
    ,
    2
    1. vs
      Abramovich
      1
      ;
      1. judgment in
        1
    2. AL begins work for
      1
    3. AL ordered to kill
      1
    4. AL paid by
      1
    5. AL’s closeness to
      1
    6. AL’s cooling dealings with
      1
    7. and AL’s deathbed statement
      1
    8. and AL’s escape
      1
      ,
      2
      ,
      3
      ,
      4
    9. birthday party of
      1
    10. carelessness of
      1
    11. death of
      1
      ;
      1. and funeral
        1
        ;
      2. and inquest
        1
    12. failed biography of
      1
    13. FSB’s criminal inquiry into
      1
    14. Kremlin tries to destroy
      1
    15. Kremlin’s accusation against
      1
    16. open letter of, to Putin
      1
    17. political asylum for
      1
    18. and Putin
      1
      ,
      2
      ,
      3
      ,
      4
      ,
      5
    19. revolution plotted by
      1
    20. self-exile of
      1
    21. and T-shirt
      1
  9. Beria, Lavrenty
    1
    ,
    2
    ,
    3
  10. Berlusconi, Silvio
    1
  11. Beyrle, John
    1
  12. Bezler, Igor
    1
  13. Black, Stuart
    1
  14. Blair, Tony
    1
    ,
    2
    ,
    3
  15. Blowing Up Russia
    (Litvinenko)
    1
    ,
    2
    ,
    3
    ,
    4
  16. Bonnetti, Bruno
    1
  17. Borodai, Andrei
    1
  18. Bortnikov, Alexander
    1
  19. Brenton, Tony
    1
    ,
    2
  20. Brezhnev, Leonid
    1
  21. Brinkmann, Prof. Bernd
    1
  22. Browder, Bill
    1
    ,
    2
    ,
    3
    ,
    4
    ,
    5
  23. Brown, Gordon
    1
  24. Brown, CI Kevin
    1
  25. Bukovsky, Vladimir
    1
    ,
    2
    ,
    3
    ,
    4
    ,
    5
    1. and public inquiry,
      see under
      Litvinenko, Alexander
  26. Burgess, Bruce
    1
  27. Burgess, Guy
    1
  28. Burnazyan, Avetik
    1
  29. Bush, George W.
    1
    ,
    2
    ,
    3
  30. Butcher, Duane
    1
  31. Butyrka
    1
  1. C2
    1
    ,
    2
  2. Cameron, David
    1
    ,
    2
    ,
    3
    ,
    4
    ,
    5
    1. on AL’s murder
      1
    2. Browder’s letter to
      1
    3. Emmerson’s criticism of
      1
  3. Carlos the Jackal (Ilich Ramirez Sanchez)
    1
  4. Carrau, Juan
    1
  5. Cary, Dr Nathaniel
    1
  6. Chaika, Yuri
    1
  7. Chechnya
    1
    ,
    2
    ,
    3
    ,
    4
    ,
    5
    1. Yeltsin’s attacks on
      1
      ,
      2
      ,
      3
  8. Chelsea FC
    1
    ,
    2
  9. Cherkasov, Ivan
    1
  10. Chertok, Paula
    1
  11. Chirac, Jacques
    1
  12. Chitty, David
    1
  13. Clinton, Hillary
    1
  14. Cohen, Nick
    1
  15. Colombian drug smugglers
    1
    ,
    2
  16. Conservative Friends of Russia
    1
  17. Continental Petroleum Limited
    1
    ,
    2
  18. Corbyn, Jeremy
    1
  19. Cotelle, Sonya
    1
  20. Cotlick, Michael
    1
  21. Crimea
    1
    ,
    2
    ,
    3
    ,
    4
    1. (
      see also
      Ukraine)
    2. Putin annexes
      1
      ,
      2
    3. (
      see also
      Crimea)
  22. Curie, Marie and Pierre
    1
    ,
    2
  23. Curtis, Stephen
    1
  1. D3
    1
    ,
    2
    ,
    3
    ,
    4
    1. in inquiry report
      1
  2. D5
    1
  3. Dadayev, Zaur
    1
    ,
    2
  4. Derkach, Leonid
    1
  5. Dewhirst, Martin
    1
  6. Dombey, Prof. Norman
    1
    passim
    ,
    2
    ,
    3
  7. Donetsk People’s Republic (DNR)
    1
    ,
    2
    ,
    3
    ,
    4
    ,
    5
    ,
    6
    ,
    7
    1. (
      see also
      Ukraine)
  8. Dubov, Yuli
    1
    ,
    2
    ,
    3
    ,
    4
    ,
    5
    ,
    6
  9. Dumas, Alexander
    1
  10. Duritskaya, Anna
    1
  11. Dzerzhinsky, Felix
    1
  12. Dzhemilev, Mustafa
    1
  13. Dzholos, Oleg
    1
  1. Emmerson, Ben
    1
    ,
    2
    ,
    3
    ,
    4
    ,
    5
    ,
    6
    ,
    7
    ,
    8
    ,
    9
    1. on UK’s response to inquiry report
      1
  2. Erinys
    1
    ,
    2
    ,
    3
  1. Felshtinsky, Yuri
    1
    ,
    2
    ,
    3
    ,
    4
    ,
    5
    ,
    6
  2. Fermi, Enrico
    1
  3. Filinov, Rafael
    1
  4. Firestone, Jamison
    1
  5. Five Eyes
    1
  6. Fried, Daniel
    1
  7. FSB (
    see also
    KGB):
    1. AL dismissed from
      1
    2. and AL’s escape
      1
    3. AL’s investigation of officers in
      1
    4. and AL’s observation skills
      1
    5. and AL’s press conference
      1
    6. and anti-Semitism
      1
    7. author summoned by
      1
    8. author targeted by
      1
      ,
      2
      ,
      3
    9. contract killers used by
      1
    10. corruption within
      1
    11. as criminalised entity
      1
    12. in inquiry report
      1
      ,
      2
    13. and KGB’s lost supremacy
      1
    14. Lefortovo Prison used by
      1
    15. and Nemtsov
      1
    16. privately admits to AL’s murder
      1
    17. as purveyor of state terror
      1
    18. Putin becomes head of
      1
    19. research institute of
      1
      ,
      2
    20. UK severs cooperation with
      1
    21. Ukrainian officers recruited by
      1
    22. URPO unit within
      1
      ;
      1. dissolved
        1
        ;
      2. press conference of
        1
    23. in WikiLeaks cables
      1
  8. Furlani, Andrea
    1
  9. Fysh, Dr Raymond
    1
  1. G8
    1
    ,
    2
  2. Gadny, Oliver
    1
  3. The Gang from the Lubyanka
    (Litvinenko)
    1
    ,
    2
  4. Gazprom
    1
    ,
    2
    ,
    3
    ,
    4
  5. GCHQ
    1
    ,
    2
  6. Gelsemium elegans
    1
  7. Gent, Dr Nick
    1
    ,
    2
  8. Georgia
    1
    ,
    2
    ,
    3
  9. Geranin, Col. Vasili
    1
  10. Ginzburg, Yevgenia
    1
  11. Global Project
    1
    ,
    2
  12. Gloster, Justice
    1
    ,
    2
    ,
    3
  13. Glushkov, Nikolai
    1
    ,
    2
    ,
    3
  14. Gochiyaev, Achemez
    1
  15. Goldfarb, Alex
    1
    ,
    2
    ,
    3
    ,
    4
    ,
    5
    ,
    6
    ,
    7
    ,
    8
    ,
    9
    ,
    10
    ,
    11
    1. on AL
      1
    2. and AL’s deathbed statement
      1
    3. and AL’s escape
      1
    4. AL’s father blames
      1
    5. on Berezovsky
      1
      ,
      2
    6. deported to Turkey
      1
    7. Kremlin’s accusation against
      1
      ,
      2
    8. on MI6
      1
    9. and Potemkin
      1
    10. on Putin paedophile allegation
      1
  16. Goldfarb, Svetlana
    1
  17. Golovlyov, Vladimir
    1
  18. Gorbachev, Mikhail
    1
    ,
    2
    ,
    3
    ,
    4
  19. Gorbunova, Elena
    1
  20. Gorbuntsov, German
    1
  21. Gordievsky, Oleg
    1
    ,
    2
    ,
    3
    ,
    4
  22. Gorky Park
    (Smith)
    1
  23. Gourdault-Montagne, Maurice
    1
  24. Grayling, Chris
    1
  25. Grinda Gonzalez, Jose
    1
    ,
    2
    ,
    3
    ,
    4
  26. Gudkov, Gennady
    1
  27. The Gulag Archipelago
    (Solzhenitsyn)
    1
  28. Gunvor
    1

Other books

The Phoenix by Rhonda Nelson
As Birds Bring Forth the Sun by Alistair MacLeod
Magic in the Shadows by Devon Monk
Nauti Dreams by Lora Leigh
Trans-Sister Radio (2000) by Bohjalian, Chris
A Southern Exposure by Alice Adams