Read Adventures with the Wife in Space: Living With Doctor Who Online
Authors: Neil Perryman
There’s one element of
Doctor Who
that I haven’t mentioned yet: regeneration. In a way, it’s the most important, because without it, the show wouldn’t have lasted for five years, let alone fifty. If the lead actor becomes too ill, or too difficult, or too unpopular, he can simply be replaced.
It was
Doctor Who
’s then-producer, Innes Lloyd, who came up with this idea after the First Doctor, William
Hartnell
, had become increasingly erratic in his ability to play the part. Because the Doctor was an alien being, he thought, there was nothing stopping him from renewing himself into a younger, healthier person. The character of the Doctor could be defined by the person who played him. Suddenly, a programme that had a finite shelf life could now last for ever, continually reinventing both the lead character and the format of the show.
I learned that other Doctors existed on Saturday 8 June 1974, the day the Third Doctor became the Fourth. An hour before the episode was broadcast, my mother sat me down and told me, in no uncertain terms, that my
childhood
hero was going to die.
Mum didn’t use the word regeneration. No, this would be a resurrection. Just like Jesus, she said. Or the time our goldfish threw itself out of its bowl, or when next-door’s cat was run over by a milk float. And in much the same way that the next-door neighbours got themselves a new cat, and
we might get another goldfish one day (we never did), today everybody would get a new Doctor Who.
The regeneration itself lasts all of five seconds. It’s a simple visual effect – as simple as it gets. The camera is locked-off, the actors lie down in the same spot and then they mix the two images together. But it’s still one of the best tricks
Doctor
Who
ever managed to pull off.
When the Doctor dies, Sue doesn’t say a word. And I can’t say anything either because I’m too choked up, and if I look at her she might see just how choked up I am, so I honestly don’t know how she’s reacting right now. And then she breaks her silence
…
Sue:
That was a good scene. I can’t say I’m disappointed to see Jon Pertwee go but, yeah, that was very nicely done.
And then the Doctor transforms into
…
Sue:
It’s Tom Jones!
To date, the Doctor has regenerated eleven times. I imagine you could name the twelve actors who have played the part on television, but just in case you can’t, they are: William Hartnell, Patrick Troughton, Jon Pertwee, Tom Baker, Peter Davison, Colin Baker, Sylvester McCoy, Paul McGann, John Hurt, Christopher Eccleston, David
Tennant
, and Matt Smith.
*
However, it could be argued that many more actors have taken on the role of the Doctor, even if the part they are playing is incorrectly referred to as Doctor Who. These Doctors exist in a non-canonical alternative Whoniverse of comedy sketches, feature films and stage plays outside of the main Whoniverse (don’t bother looking in the dictionary, it’s not there).
Discussions of what is and what isn’t part of the
Doctor
Who
‘canon’ are to the programme’s fans what angels dancing on the head of a pin were to medieval theologians. Friendships can be wrecked over whether, say, Tom Baker’s appearance in his
Doctor Who
costume on
Disney Time
in 1975 means that it was actually the Doctor who materialised on Bank Holiday Monday to present
Disney Time
during the four-month break between ‘Revenge of the Cybermen’ and ‘Terror of the Zygons’ (for the record – of course he bloody didn’t).
However, should you ever find yourself ensnared in a tricky pub-quiz situation, and you are asked to name more than twelve actors who have played the Doctor, here are some of the less well-known regenerates:
Trevor Martin.
Trevor Martin is a fabulous actor with an impressive CV of film and stage roles. However, in 1974 he played Doctor Who in a West End stage production entitled
Doctor Who and the Daleks in the Seven Keys to Doomsday
. For one small segment of the population, this means the actor’s numerous appearances in plays by William Shakespeare and the like pale into insignificance compared to the three weeks he spent hanging around
the stage of the Adelphi Theatre, waiting for a Dalek to trundle onto its mark.
Richard Hurndall
. For the twentieth-anniversary story, ‘The Five Doctors’, neither Tom Baker nor William Hartnell was available to take part, one because he was sulking and the other because he was dead. Hurndall stepped in, giving an uncanny impersonation of the irascible First Doctor, except for the fact that he managed to deliver all his lines without mucking them up.
David Banks
. More usually concealed inside a Cyberman costume on television, David Banks was also Jon Pertwee’s understudy for a 1989 musical stage play called
Doctor Who:
The Ultimate Adventure
. When Pertwee fell ill one day, Banks grasped the nettle with both hands, and for the lucky people who saw that matinee performance, it is said, not least by David Banks, that he gave
the
definitive portrayal of the Doctor. Unfortunately, the number of people who claim to have seen David’s Doctor far exceeds the seating capacity of Birmingham’s Alexandra Theatre, so this hyperbole should be taken with a pinch of salt.
Richard E. Grant.
Two for the price of one, here. Grant has played the part twice, once in 2004 in a
computer-animated
story called ‘Scream of the Shalka’, and previously in 1999 when he appeared alongside
Rowan Atkinson, Jim Broadbent, Hugh Grant
and
Joanna Lumley
in a sketch for Comic Relief. None of them inhabited the part with a tenth of the conviction of David Banks.
But the most famous non-canonical Doctor of them all is surely
Peter Cushing
. After the success of the Daleks on TV, producer Milton Subotsky was responsible for bringing them to the big screen in the movies
Dr Who and the Daleks
and
Daleks: Invasion Earth 2150 AD
. The veteran Hammer
Horror
star Cushing was cast in the mistitled lead role. Now, these movies have their admirers – current producer Steven
Moffat
, for example – but as a child, I knew these films weren’t kosher and this guy playing ‘Doctor Who’ was emphatically not the Doctor; as well as having the wrong name, he was just too human. Besides, rather than laser beams, the movie Daleks fired lethal blasts of compressed air – in a big-budget film, for God’s sake! Like Milton Subotsky could give a shit.
Sue:
What the hell is this? This is in colour.
Me:
Well spotted.
Sue:
This is the movie, isn’t it? This wasn’t part of the deal.
This wasn’t the reaction that I’d hoped for. I thought she would be grateful for a splash of colour.
Sue:
WHAT THE F**K?
As far as Sue is concerned, everything is wrong. Not just different. Wrong. The TARDIS interior; the Doctor; his extended family; the music; the Daleks; even the film’s aspect ratio gets under her skin.
Sue:
They called him Dr Who. That means his daughter’s name must be Barbara Who and that must be little Susie Who. This is stupid. Why are we watching this again?
I persuaded her to stick with it, and while there were a few isolated moments that met with Sue’s approval (
explosion-based
, mainly ), they still couldn’t mitigate for the wrongness that permeated every frame.
Sue:
The most interesting thing about the film is that they made it so close to the TV show. It’s not as if we are watching a remake thirty years later, with loads of expensive CGI. And yet they appear to exist in two completely different timeframes. On the one hand, the film is clearly much more impressive – it’s quicker, bigger and better made – but at the same time it’s a lot less impressive than the original. And the original wasn’t that impressive to begin with.
She refused to give the film a mark out of ten.
Sue:
It doesn’t count.
*
Quantity and names of actors who have played the Doctor correct at the time of going to press.
The boys I went to school with were football crazy, football mad. All they wanted to do was talk about Saturday’s goals and swap Panini stickers. All I wanted to do was swap
Doctor Who
Weetabix cards and speculate about how the Doctor might escape last Saturday’s cliffhanger. Even the boys who did watch
Doctor Who
didn’t want to talk about it. But then again, what do boys talk about? Even as adults, most of our interactions tended to consist of: ‘Got … Got … Need … Swap … Got’ and ‘Tag! You’re it!’
So I defected to the girls, who were a much more chatty and imaginative bunch. When we played
Doctor Who
in the playground, I was
always
the Doctor and the girls were always Sarah Jane Smith or, better yet, one of the monsters. I am still warmed by the memory of Bethany McKenna and Beverly Sharpe crushing me to death between their chests as they pretended to be the robotic bear-hugging mummies from ‘Pyramids of Mars’. Bethany and Beverly, if you are reading this, please be aware that I am hoping to restage this event in 2015 as part of this classic story’s fortieth
anniversary
celebrations. Do get in touch.
*
Tom Baker was my Doctor. I forgot about Jon Pertwee within the first ten minutes of Tom’s debut. With his wild staring eyes and insane toothy grin, he was some way
from the suave dandy played by Jon Pertwee, but by the time the Fourth Doctor had donned his floppy hat and wrapped his inordinately long multicoloured scarf around his neck, I was hooked. Mum thought he was ‘much too silly’ but she was wrong.
The new Doctor discharges himself from the infirmary but the medical officer, Harry Sullivan, manages to intervene before he can escape in his TARDIS. The Doctor believes that his new nose is a definite improvement on the last one.
Sue:
Your entire face is a definite improvement! Cheer up! You’re not Jon Pertwee any more!
The Doctor bamboozles Harry during an exceedingly strange medical, but Sue seems to enjoy it.
Sue:
He is certainly larger than life and very charismatic – you can’t take your eyes off him. But he will tone it down eventually, won’t he? He’s a bit full on at the moment.
As the scene plays out, Sue laughs. A lot.
Sue:
He’s very funny, but I’m not sure that the kids would have felt the same way. I think the Doctor’s eyes popping out of his head would have frightened half of them to death.
As much as I had loved the Third Doctor, he had silver hair, which meant I thought about him the same way I’d think about a grandfather or a kindly uncle. The Fourth Doctor was different; we didn’t know anyone like him. He
looked like a nutcase, behaved like a nutcase, and, I would later learn, was being played by a nutcase. But what a nutcase.
In his second story, ‘The Ark in Space’, the Doctor has a famous speech about the indomitable spirit of mankind as a species. Tom Baker plays it like he’s onstage at the Globe Theatre, and when I watch it now, it makes me profoundly grateful that the BBC happened to cast an actor who saw no reason not to take the part of a time-travelling
extraterrestrial
extremely seriously. He had all the mischief and all the heroism and wisdom of previous Doctors, but he was,
perhaps
, the first actor who really believed he was the Doctor.
I remember two things about watching ‘The Ark in Space’ as a child. One, it scared the willies out of me, and two, I couldn’t wait to reproduce the terror I felt in the school
playground
the following Monday.
The monsters in ‘The Ark in Space’ – the Wirrn – were giant insects, and as you will have realised by now, giant insects always gave me trouble. This lot were a swarm of intelligent wasp-like monstrosities who wanted to
impregnate
you with their babies, and you knew you were in trouble if your flesh started to break out in green weeping pustules, an effect the cash-strapped BBC special effects department achieved by wrapping the actor’s hand and lower arm in painted bubble wrap.
Body horror translated well to the playground.
Everyone
knew how the dreaded lurgy worked. I remember Beverly Sharpe walking around with her hand stuffed in her pocket – a sure sign that she’d been infected by the Wirrn – and when she tried to strangle me with it later, I was impressed to find that she’d gone to the trouble of wrapping several
layers of Sellotape around it. Beverly was the first girl I ever kissed, by the way. On the lips and everything.
The Doctor tries to reason with Noah, who is now acting very strangely indeed.
Sue:
So this is basically
Alien
?
Me:
There are certain similarities, yes.
Sue:
How did they sneak this idea into an afternoon teatime slot? It’s horrific.
Me:
This story gave me nightmares when I was a kid.
Sue:
Yes, and you’ve been terrified of bubble wrap ever since. So when was
Alien
released?
Me:
1979.
Sue:
So Ridley Scott might have seen this before he made
Alien
?
Me:
It’s possible.
Sue:
Maybe he showed it to his crew and said, ‘I want it to look like this, but with decent lighting, sets, monsters and music.’
*
I never hid behind the sofa when I watched
Doctor Who
. For a start, we called it a settee, not a sofa, and it was pushed right up against our living-room wall. So I’d sit on the floor with a cushion in my lap, and if things got too frightening for me, I’d bury my face in its folds. And if the sound effects were too disturbing, I’d press the corners into my ears.
I did this a lot when Tom Baker was playing the Doctor,
especially during the end-of-episode cliffhangers. Like the time Sarah Jane Smith fell from some scaffolding at the end of ‘Genesis of the Daleks’, part 2. I was so convinced that she couldn’t possibly survive this fall, I ran into the kitchen to find Mum.
Me:
Sarah Jane’s dead! Sarah Jane’s dead! Sarah Jane’s dead!
Mum:
Calm down and stop crying. The Doctor’s friends don’t die. I’m sure he’ll catch her in the next episode.
(I didn’t feel cheated when part 3 began with Sarah Jane falling safely onto a gantry
that wasn’t there the week before.
She was still alive. That’s all that mattered.)
The playground games fizzled out by the end of 1976 and our last hurrah was a homage to ‘The Hand of Fear’, which was ideal for the girls because all they had to do was walk around in a trance, a palm face up in the air, repeating the phrase ‘Eldrad must live! Eldrad must live!’ over and over again. Even I could have done that.
‘The Hand of Fear’ was also Sarah Jane’s last story.
I didn’t see it coming. One minute the Doctor and his best friend are running rings around Eldrad on a planet made from ice, the next minute he’s dropping her off in Croydon because he isn’t allowed to take her to Gallifrey. It didn’t seem fair, not after everything Sarah had been through.
Sarah Jane’s departure hit me for six. I wasn’t used to companions leaving, and while I could vaguely recall her predecessor, Jo Grant, I had been too young to form any meaningful attachment to her. Sarah Jane was my first
proper companion. She was the big sister I never had, the one I wanted to baby-sit me.
I wanted the Doctor to change his mind and return for her the following week, but he didn’t. It was at these moments that Tom Baker really made you believe he wasn’t quite human because a human being would have gone back for her.
*
There was one thing more frightening than watching
Doctor Who
, and that was missing
Doctor Who.
Take Saturday 6 December 1975, for example. It’s 5.55 p.m. and I should have been settling down to watch ‘The Android Invasion’, part 3 at home, but instead I was playing pass-the-parcel at some kid’s birthday party. Seriously, what kind of idiot throws a birthday party when
Doctor Who
is on?
And then there was ‘The Ribos Operation’, part 1. Dad had taken me to see a non-league football match. I
remember
that it rained the whole time, there were no decent seats, the roof was leaking, neither team scored a goal and I was bored to tears. The only thing that made this treat bearable was the knowledge that a brand-new series of
Doctor Who
was due to start when I got home.
The match finished at 4.45 p.m., which gave us a good hour to make it home in time. However, because Dad didn’t drive, we had to wait for a lift from his friend, Bob. Bob couldn’t have been a
Doctor Who
fan; he wanted to have a quick pint instead. I stood in the cold, draughty corridor with a packet of pork scratchings because I wasn’t allowed into the bar. The quick pint wasn’t quick enough.
I knew we wouldn’t make it back in time when, after several more quick pints, Bob finally decided to leave. I sulked all the way home about missing
Doctor Who
, which at least took my mind off being driven home by someone who must have been over the legal limit. Maybe, his
judgement
clouded, Bob actually put his foot down because in the event I only missed the first quarter of an hour.
However
, in the age before repeats, videos or the internet, I would not actually get to watch those missing minutes of ‘The Ribos Operation’ for another seventeen years. Thanks, Dad.
*
And then I saw
Star Wars.
Mum:
You were
Star Wars
mad.
Doctor Who
went out the window when
Star Wars
came along. You were obsessed with it. Especially the toys.
My mum is half-right here.
When
Star Wars
was released in 1978, I, like every other small boy in the entire country, thought it was the most mind-blowing film I had ever seen or was ever likely to see. By the end of the 1970s, my bedroom had become a shrine to Kenner’s range of
Star Wars
action figures. It was a drop in the ocean compared with what was out there, but enough for me to stage some very impressive battles at the bottom of our stairs. My favourite action figure was Bossk the bounty hunter (a crocodile in a yellow jumpsuit), but I had a soft spot for Luke’s Landspeeder too, until Joanne stepped on it and snapped its wheels off.
However, I still liked
Doctor Who
and Tom Baker – a lot. Although the programme couldn’t compete with the lavish special effects of
Star Wars
– no noticeable bubble wrap in sight – its lead actor, four years in, was still unassailable. The programme had grown noticeably sillier in recent months, in an attempt to appease an old lady named Mary
Whitehouse
, but Tom remained as exciting, weird and mercurial as ever. And
Doctor Who
could still satisfy some part of my imagination that nothing else could. The only reason I was playing
Star Wars
on the stairs is because the
Doctor Who
franchise didn’t have anything like the same amount of toys available, and by this stage of my life, I’d moved beyond the realm of pure imagination and I needed some props.
For my eighth birthday, my parents gave me a red Palitoy Dalek; for my ninth, I got a Denys Fisher Fourth Doctor doll to go with it. I now know that a manufacturing cock-up meant that Tom Baker’s head had to be substituted at the last minute with Gareth Hunt’s from
The New Avengers
. This didn’t bother me at the time as the head in question looked about as much like Tom Baker as it did Gareth Hunt (quality control on the
New Avengers
toys must have been half-hearted at best). There was a Denys Fisher TARDIS, too, but at £5.95 it was probably too steep for my parents’ budget, and I never got the Denys Fisher Cyberman either – the only Cyberman with a nose.
Here are a few more
Doctor Who
toys and tie-ins that I did have:
*
In 1979, Tom Baker’s Doctor Who was arguably at his most popular. Just over 16 million people tuned in to watch the final episode of ‘City of Death’. It helped that, although ‘City of Death’ is a wonderful story and Tom is
magnificent
throughout, there was nothing on the other side owing
to industrial action at ITV. It was during this period of Baker’s apotheosis that I went to live in New Zealand for five months.
We stayed with Auntie Angie and her husband, Uncle Mike, on their farm on the outskirts of Queenstown on the rural South Island. It was in the middle of nowhere – the nearest shop was miles away – but it was surrounded by beautiful countryside, there were gorgeous views of the mountains, and there were sheep. There were lots and lots of sheep. Plus, repeats of
Doctor Who
were on every day of the week.