All In: Double or Nothing (16 page)

"Are you alright baby?" I asked her.

"Uh-huh. Gonna sleep," was all she said.

Caleb pulled out of her and I lifted her up, laying her down in the middle of the bed. She was knocked out.

"We fucked her into unconsciousness," I told him as I looked down at her.    

Caleb laughed. "I'll get a towel to clean her up," he said, heading for the bathroom.

"I'll get the beer," I told him, then headed to the kitchen.

When I came back he'd washed her and pulled the covers over her. I handed him a beer and then climbed back into bed, propped up against the headboard. He slid under the sheets on the other side and sat up, both of us still naked. The whole thing didn't feel as strange as it should have.

"So how was it?" I asked him.

He grinned, "Fucking awesome. So damn tight."

"I bet."

"I'll switch with you next time."

"Next time?" I asked.

"Well, it apparently gets her off, and it's not like we touch each other."

"Yeah, it is pretty good."

"And it beats alternating nights," he added.

"Damn right it does. So she's into the restraining shit too apparently?" 

"Oh yeah. She didn't tell you? I figured she'd been using your police cuffs."

"Nope. Tonight she cuffed herself in the nightie to the dresser, waiting for you. When she realized you were going to be late she called for me to come help her get out of them. She was so damn hot and wet I couldn't resist."

"The first night we used them she freaked the fuck out," he grinned smugly.

"Yeah, I probably heard."

"Probably, but it was nothing compared to just now. I think she liked it."

"Yeah, although she may not admit it in the morning."

"True," he agreed.

"So, um, tonight's the first time we've fucked since I was shot."

His mouth dropped. "Damn. That’s been weeks."

"Yeah, three to be exact. Not many positions that wouldn't cause my leg to hurt like fuck."

"No wonder she's been so horny with me."

"Yeah well, I'm up for anything now, so I'll take some of the pressure off you."

He laughed but then when he sobered up asked, "How is this shit going to end?"

"Damn if I know. I do know we can't both keep fucking her."

"I know. But it's pretty good right now. I don’t have any complaints."

"I don't either," I said, looking down at Lauren's sleeping form. She was curled up on her side, her hands under her head, her hair spilling across the pillow.

"I saw her tuition bill for next semester. It's due soon and I was thinking about paying it for her. You know, to take some of the pressure off of her," Caleb said.

"That's a good idea. How much is it?"

"Almost two thousand."

"I'll split it with you if you want," I offered.

"Okay, thanks."

"How'd we get here? We've gone from fucking three or four girls a week to fighting over one."

"She's fucking perfect, and neither of us can live without her," he said.

"Pretty much,” I sighed, relaxing and just enjoying the moment.

Lauren

I woke up warm, with all my limbs trapped. I was facing Tyler, my arm was around his waist, his leg thrown over both of mine, his hand on my hip. Caleb's arm was around my waist and he was lying against me so close I could feel his erection jutting into my ass, and his warm breath on the back of my neck. It was nice. Really nice being snuggled by both of them at the same time. My two amazing, sexy men. But my body ached from being in this position for so long, or from being screwed so many times last night, I wasn't sure which.

I pulled my arm from Tyler and stretched, which caused my back to arch into Caleb's erection. He groaned and rocked forward into me, his arm tightening and pulling my stomach against him.

"Good morning sweetheart. How do you feel?" he asked.

"Good. Last night with the two of you both was incredible."

"Tyler and I talked after we fucked you unconscious, and we don't mind sharing at the same time."

"Oh really? I am a very, very lucky girl,” I told him. “So Caleb?”

“Yeah?”

“What are you waiting for? If you’re going to fuck me you need to hurry up so I can get ready for school.”

He groaned and pressed into me. “I need you from behind sweetheart. Roll onto your stomach for me.”

I did as he asked and he was on me before I could push myself up on my knees.

“Oh!” I cried out when he raised my hips and entered me.

“Good morning to the two of you too,” Tyler said when our motions right up against his body woke him up.

I turned my head to face him and reached down for his cock. He was hard and ready, thrusting into my fist.

“Oh God,” I moaned as my insides quickly tightened around Caleb. The orgasm ripped through me, making my arms and legs turn to jelly.

“Fuck,” I said into the pillow. Caleb was still in me while he recovered above me, and my walls kept pulsating around him, making me want to rub against him even more. “I’ve gotta get a shower, but I can’t move.”

“Give me a minute and I’ll not only carry you to the shower but I’ll wash you too,” Caleb said. His lips pressing soft kisses on my shoulder and back before he moved off of me.

I looked over at Tyler who seemed to be in a good mood, all things considered. “You okay?” I asked, meaning with everything.

“Yeah. Last night was good.” 

“Yeah, it was. Glad this is working out for everyone,” I said, reaching out to rub his arm. I gave him a kiss then raised up to start heading to the bathroom.

“Ready?” Caleb asked. I nodded and he threw me over his shoulder.

…

I had texted Jess earlier, and after I got out of my last class I headed to Tex & Shirley's to meet her for lunch. I hadn't talked to her lately or even told her about what I'd been doing with Tyler and Caleb.

Jess was already there and sitting in a booth when I walked in.

"Hey."

"Hey girl. What have you been up to? You haven't returned my calls since the day at the lake."

"Tyler and Caleb have been keeping me busy."

"Wait. Tyler
and
Caleb?"

I nodded.

"Spill it all right this second."

"So after Tyler got out of the hospital a few weeks ago we made a deal. The three of us decided to start from scratch. So ah, I'm sort of seeing them both so I can decide who I want to be with."

Jess's jaw had dropped and she hadn't picked it up yet. "So that's why you were getting frisky with both of them Saturday. You're fucking both?"

"Ah yeah. I've been alternating nights, although Tyler just healed enough for actual, you know."

"You have got to be kidding. Two hot as fuck men and you get them both?"

"Yeah."

"And they haven't killed each other yet?"

"No, they haven't gotten into any more fist fights. That was one of the rules."

"You have no idea how jealous I am. I can't find one decent guy and you have two. Two that want you so bad they are willing to share you."

"Yeah. So it was getting sort of difficult to maintain balance between the two of them until last night."

"What happened last night?"

"I had them both at the same time," I told her, and my face blazed with heat.

Jess covered her gaping mouth. "I need details. Lots and lots of graphic details."

I waited for the nearby waitress to leave before I said anything else. "I cuffed myself to Caleb's dresser, wearing lingerie, but he had to work over. I had to call Tyler to help me get loose so I could go to the bathroom. When he walked in, well, he was ready to go, so he was taking me from behind when Caleb came home. He climbed on the dresser and I ah, went down on him while Tyler finished."

"You little slut."

I covered my face. "I know, I am right."

"What happened after that?"

"They ah, took turns with me like four more times."

"Holy shit. I hate you so much right now. I haven't had sex four times in the past year."

"The last time I was between both of them."

"And how the hell was that?" she asked wide eyed.

"It was incredible, and the most intense, you know, that I've ever had." I was trying to watch my language since we were in public. Jess wasn't quite as concerned.

"Actually I wouldn't know about those since I'm a big 'O' virgin, but were things awkward today?"

"No, surprisingly. We all slept together then went another round this morning. They told me they talked after they f'd me unconscious, and agreed they wanted to keep doing it."

"You're doubling up while I get nothing. But that is so fucking hot."

"Tell me about it."

"So why are you sitting here when you could be doing them?" she asked.

"I needed to tell someone. Am I crazy? I mean this won't last forever, and I don't know what to do. I love them both, and I can't stand the thought of losing them."

"If everyone is happy then just go with it. See what happens, and have fun while it lasts, for my sake and all of womankind."

"I guess that’s all I can do."

"Yeah, it'll be such a chore," she snorted and rolled her eyes.

That night Tyler was in a really good mood, even after Caleb came home. I was studying for an exam so they left me alone until I closed the last book. When I stood up, both of them jumped up and converged on me. Tyler pulled my shirt over my head while Caleb pulled down my bottoms.

"I think I just want to cuddle tonight," I said, making both of them freeze in their tracks. "Kidding guys," I finally told them, cueing simultaneous exhales in relief.

"My room tonight?" Tyler asked. Caleb and I nodded but thinking was already becoming difficult. Tyler's hand was between my legs as he kissed me and Caleb was standing behind me, his hands caressing my breasts, while he kissed down my neck. Caleb finally picked me up by my waist and hauled me to the bedroom, throwing me on the bed.

"We bought something to play with today," Caleb said with a grin, as he and Tyler quickly stripped out of their clothes.   

"Oh really?" I asked, already getting hot at how worked up they seemed to be, and just looking at their gorgeous bodies.

"How do you feel about us tying you down, spread eagle?" Caleb asked.

"Oh. Ah, both arms and legs restrained?" I asked, a little nervous. Caleb and I had only done wrists. But if that got me off, then all limbs restrained probably would be even better.

"Yeah. With soft fabric, not cuffs that will hurt you," Tyler answered.

"That sounds ... fun. Tie me up."

I laid down flat on my back and held out my arms and legs to the sides. Caleb tied my left arm and leg, while Tyler tied the right sides to the bed posts.

"Now that you've got me restrained, what're you going to do to me?" I asked as they climbed up on the bed.

"I want to lick you pussy while you suck Caleb, then Caleb can fuck you while you suck me, then we might do the sandwich thing we did last night."

"Wow," was all I could say. "I might orgasm just thinking about all that." I looked down at both men, and, based on their huge erections, they were rearing to go.                       

"So you're okay with all that?" Tyler asked.

"Oh yeah, but enough talking, let's get to it already."

Tyler smiled as he kneeled between my legs and Caleb crawled up beside me. I turned my head to the side and watched him stroke himself until he pushed the head of his cock to my lips.

"Is this okay?" he asked. Tyler's lips and tongue on my inner thighs made it hard to speak.

"Yes, and you know how much I can take. I'll shake my head no if it's too much, okay?"

"Okay," he said before he pushed between my lips, and Tyler thrust his tongue into me at the same time. I moaned, then swirled my tongue around Caleb's cock, so he'd slide easier in and out of my mouth. Tyler seemed to be matching his thrusts with Caleb's. I wanted to raise my hips to meet his tongue but couldn't. Every time Tyler moved his mouth away I longed to reach down and hold him in place, making me tug on the arm restraints.

Caleb pulled back to hold off his orgasm, while Tyler kept flicking his tongue softly over my clit in circles, while at the same time sliding two fingers in and out of me. The combination of the two sensations was driving me insane. I cried out and arched my back as much as I could off the bed, begging for him to get me off.

Finally he picked up his pace and I fell apart, my body jerking against the restraint as I moaned through my orgasm. I whimpered when he raised up and changed places with Caleb.

Caleb filled me to the hilt in one hard push, then stayed still above me to give me time to adjust. Tyler's cock was ready for my mouth, the drop of pre-cum glistening on the end. I licked it away and sucked him into my mouth, causing him to have to pull back quickly to avoid coming.

Caleb's pace had picked up and was relentless as he pounded into me, and it felt even more intense the way I was spread open. Sometime between when my next orgasm hit and when I was able to open my eyes again Tyler had entered me while Caleb laid beside us and watched. He was fisting himself and moaning as much as Tyler and I were.

"Untie her legs," Tyler told Caleb and he quickly complied.

Tyler pushed my legs back and down on my chest, which I knew was one of his favorite positions. It made me tighter for him and let him go deeper. Reaching down he massaged my clit, throwing me into another orgasm as he thrust in and out of me. The more of them I had the needier I became. These two men were going to kill me before I became sated.

All three of us laid there recovering afterwards. Tyler was still between my legs, his head resting on my breasts where he occasionally licked or kissed one of them lazily. Caleb slid over and crushed his mouth over mine in a frantic, desperate kiss, sliding his tongue into my mouth and retreating, leaving me wanting more, but not able to do anything while my arms were still restrained. My entire body was hypersensitive after all the orgasms that'd blasted through me.

"You two have ruined me," I told them when Caleb pulled away. "I don't know if I can ever be with just one of you again."

"And you've ruined us. I don't think I could be with another woman again," Caleb said leaning down to give me another kiss before untying my wrists.

"So you ready for another fuck sandwich?" Tyler asked and I laughed.

"God yes," I told him.

Tyler moved off of me, and Caleb laid down then pulled me on top of him, making me think they'd already discussed the logistics for tonight. 

"Fuck you're so wet," Caleb moaned when I slid down on his cock.

Tyler climbed up on the bed behind me, and I felt the coldness of the lube being spread before he pressed his cock against my opening.

"You ready?" he asked.

"Yeah, just go slowly okay?" I told him and he pushed forward.

Tyler's penetration made my insides automatically clench around Caleb, and he cursed at the sensation. Then slowly I felt the pressure increase as Tyler stretched me, pushing me down onto Caleb as he started to move. The feeling of both men completely filling me was almost overwhelming, and just this side of painful. But with each slight movement I was climbing higher and higher toward another explosive orgasm. One of them worked my clit until I erupted around them both, coming apart from the mind-blowing ecstasy. Collapsing forward on Caleb's chest was the last thing I remembered.

…

Caleb

"Jesus. Fucking. Christ." Tyler moaned as he fell onto his bed.

I was covering up Lauren who'd passed out after what I thought was her fourth orgasm of the night.

"Yeah that was awesome and all, but I still miss having her to myself," I told him.

"Shit, I do too. We can go back to that and just do her at the same time whenever she asks us to."

"It is pretty fucking hot," I admitted. "I think it helps my jealousy. Seeing you with her and then being with her too. I don't have to wonder, you know?"

"Yeah, that's how I feel too. I still wonder if she has a preference, and hate to think I may not be it."  

"I hope you're not it," I joked. "Beer?" I asked on the way to the kitchen.

"Yeah, thanks."

I grabbed two cans and went back to Tyler's room, handing him one as I climbed into his bed.

"You know, I never imagined I'd be sleeping in your fucking bed," I told him.

"You don't have to start now," he replied with a grin.

"Fuck you. You slept in mine, so now I'm sleeping in yours." 

"Just don't rub my leg or some shit during the night," he joked.

"Don't worry, hairy legs aren't really my thing."

I leaned down and brushed Lauren's hair from her face then kissed her forehead. Tyler looked away like that bothered him more than seeing me fuck her. We had serious issues.

"Did you know her birthday is Sunday?" he asked.

"Yeah, September first."

"She'll be twenty-one. I don't want her to get so drunk she throws up, but we should probably take her out to celebrate and have a drink."

"We could plan something and surprise her Sunday since she'll be off work, and school is out Monday for Labor Day," I told him.

"That's a good idea. Shooter's?" he suggested with a smirk.

"I guess. We could invite Jess, and whoever she suggests, and maybe Dylan and Will."

"What happens with us three in public? You mind if they know we're sharing her?"

"No. Do you?" I asked.

"Not really. Everyone probably already knows. Have you bought her a present yet?"

I smiled. "Part of it. The other part has to wait until Sunday. I hope you won't be pissed but I got her a kitten."

"You bought her a fucking cat?" he asked.

"Shhh! Yes, I bought her a cat. She's never had any pets. Her sorry ass mom wouldn't let her even have a fish."

"I hate that bitch so much," Tyler said, shaking his head. "She'll probably love it."

"All the things we had growing up we take for granted. She never had any of that normal shit. No birthday or Christmas presents, no one to take care of her if she was sick. Sometimes nothing to eat. She started doing her own laundry when she was like five to have clean clothes. She never had any toys or books, only the ones she borrowed from the library. She's never even left this city."

"Fuck," he said, leaning his head back against the headboard. "That's not even counting all those shitty men her mom kept around, that did no telling what to her."

"Yeah, makes me want to call my dad and thank him and mom for raising me like decent human beings,” I told him. I missed my mom so damn much, and really hoped she knew how much I appreciated and loved her.

“Seriously. It’s so unfair that she was raised liked that. Having to get a job striping at sixteen so she’d have a place to live and wouldn’t starve to death,” he remarked.

“I can’t believe she turned out to be the woman she is today. She’s tough, but she deserves to have someone take care of her for a change.”

“I agree. Or better yet, two of us,” he said.