Devil's Knot: The True Story of the West Memphis Three (53 page)

425. In the interview in January 2002, Paudert said that none of the allegations of misconduct that had been reported to him related to the department’s investigation of the 1993 murders. Sergeant Lawrence Vaughn, head of the department’s new internal affairs office, agreed. Vaughn said that he had been working as a uniformed patrol officer in 1993 and had participated in the search for the children. “I was there on the scene at the discovery,” he said. “I was there when they were bringing the bodies out of the woods. There were so many people there, we had to set up a perimeter. We were sitting by the hearse. We assisted in putting the bodies into the vehicle.” (Inspector Gary Gitchell had begged the crime lab for information about the “Negroid hair” found in the sheet around Christopher’s body, but no explanation had surfaced. Yet, during the trials, when defense attorneys had asked the crime lab’s trace evidence expert, Lisa Sakevicius, if she had ever received “any Negro type hairs from any West Memphis police officers to compare with the questioned hair,” Sakevicius testified that she had not.) Vaughn also reported that Sudbury’s role in the murder investigation had been unique within the department. According to Vaughn, after the boys’ bodies were found, Gitchell had assigned all of his regular criminal detectives to work the murder investigation, and he’d temporarily reassigned the department’s narcotics unit, where Sudbury was second in command, ordering them take over the regular detectives’ duties. Vaughn said that Sudbury—who’d been the first West Memphis detective to question Damien, the first to report Jerry Driver’s suspicions, and present during key interviews with John Mark Byers and Vicki Hutcheson—was the only narcotics detective whom Gitchell had allowed to participate in the murder investigation. Sudbury, Vaughn recalled, “was the only one who worked both.”

426. Damien’s son, Seth, born six months before his father’s trial, turned eight in 2001. Seth and his mother, Domini, had left Arkansas after the trials, and their contact with Damien in the years that followed had been slim.

427. The wedding, which was approved by Warden Greg Harmon, took place on December 6, 1999.

428. She’d moved to Little Rock, and two years later the couple asked the warden for permission to marry. The wedding ceremony, held in a visitation room at the maximum security unit, began and ended with the sound of a bell. Damien wore his white prison uniform and shackles. His head was shaved in the manner of a Buddhist monk. A Buddhist priest from Little Rock, who also worked as a volunteer chaplain at the prison, performed the ceremony, which was attended by a half dozen of the couple’s friends, including some of the supporters from California. Officials at the prison stressed that while inmates generally had a right to marry, they do not have a right to sexual contact. “There was no reception, no honeymoon, no overnight stay in Branson,” a prison spokesman said, referring to a popular vacation spot in southern Missouri.

429. “Death Row’s Echols Ties the Knot in Prison Fete,” by Cathy Frye, December 7, 1999.

430. Though the handling of money was illegal in prison, and Jason had never had much of it to begin with, he was trying to understand finance. “I know to stay away from credit cards,” he said. “I know that mutual funds are a safer investment and offer a higher yield, but that right now is the best time to buy stocks. I wish I could get out right now and just buy a bunch of stocks while it’s low, and just keep buying stocks every month, every month…. I just don’t want my kids to live in a trailer park.”

Index

Allen, Mike

attempt to depose
questioning Jessie
on second documentary
testimony
on the case

America’s Most Wanted
(television show)

Appeals

Damien
failed
Jason
Jessie

Arkansas

attitudes toward verdicts
bifurcated trials
DNA testing
in documentary
freedom of information law
maximum security unit
reaction to documentaries in,
Second Judicial District

Arkansas Crime Laboratory

Arkansas Democrat–Gazette

Arkansas law

Arkansas State Police

investigating officers in West Memphis Police Department

Arkansas Supreme Court

appeals to
arguments at
postconviction petitions before

Arkansas Times

Arrests

Atkinson, Michael

Autopsies

Autopsy reports

M. Byers
to defense lawyers
delayed

 

Bakken, Kathy

Baldwin, Jason

accused by A. Hutcheson
appeals
arrested
attempt to separate trial from
Damien’s
bite mark impressions
black T–shirts
bragged about murders (claim),
J. M. Byers blamed
case against
closing argument
criminal record
Damien’s link with
deal offered to
as defendant
in documentary
family questioned
fiber evidence
found guilty of capital murder
Jessie to testify against
Jessie’s accusatory statements about
Jessie’s decision not to testify against
jury assessment of
juvenile tried as adult
knife linked to
linked to crime
news reports on
and occult
presumption of guilt
pretrial concerns
pretrial motions
in prison
probable cause to arrest
questioned
reading
and satanism
sentence
severity of situation of
suspect
see also
Echols, Damien, and Jason Baldwin trial

Baldwin, Matt

Beasley, Mandy

Berlinger, Joe

and blood-stained knife
second film

Bicycles

Black clothing

Black man, reports of

Black T–shirts

Bland, Danny

Blood

absence of,
on necklace
testing site for
on T–shirt

Blood samples

Bojangles rest room
Bojangles rest room: lost

Damien

Jason

Jessie

Blue Beacon Truck Wash

Bodies

discovery of
evidence found with
evidence analysis of site
location and condition of
marks on
photograghs of
position of
tied,
tied with rope (claim)

Bojangles restaurant

bloody man

Bouisson, Maurice

Branch, Steve

Branch, Stevie Edward

body found
cause of death
evidence analysis from photos of
family background
Jessie found guilty of murder of
marks on face
murder
reported missing
reports of sightings
testimony regarding injuries
tied

Bray, Donald

and A. Hutcheson
Lax met with
notes from interviews
stroke
and suspects

Burnett, David

Damien and Jason’s trial
Damien and Jason’s trial: gag order
Damien and Jason’s trial: meeting with prosecution
Damien and Jason’s trial: sentencing
Damien and Jason’s trial: Supreme Court upheld decisions of
errors
Jessie’s trial
Jessie’s trial:
in camera
hearings
Jessie’s trial: verdict
and lawyers’ payment
ordered Byers’s conviction expunged
pretrial motions
Rule 37 petitions

Byers, Christopher

belt whipping by father
biological father
blood on knife consistent with blood of
body found
J. M. Byers adopted
castration,
evidence analysis from photos of
cause of death
funeral
Jessie found guilty of murder of
medical records
mental health problems
missing
murder
“Negroid” hair in sheet around
reports of sightings
school problems
signs of sexual assault
testimony regarding injuries
tied
weapons used on
wounds

Byers, John Mark

arrested on drugs and weapons charges
belt whipping Christopher
blood and urine samples
blood on knife consistent with blood of
blood same as adopted son Chris
and blood-stained knife
blood-stained knife: questioning about
brain tumor
crimes
criminal charges
death of wife
discrepancies
in documentary
and drugs
evidence against
evidence that he lied
ex–wife
failure to meet court’s conditions
girlfriend Mandy
interviews with
on Jessie’s trial verdict
police informant
at pretrial motions
prison interview
reaction to verdict
records of crime expunged
release forms for search
released from prison
reported child missing
in second documentary
as suspect
testimony: second trial
witness

Byers, Melissa

blood samples
criminal charges
death of
death of: investigation
in documentary
drug informant
drug use
on Jessie’s trial verdict
parents of
police questioned
reaction to verdict
testimony

 

Cadwal lader, Sara

Capital murder

alternatives to
Damien and Jason guilty of

Carson, Michael

testimony
witness

Castration

mistake in records regarding
testimony regarding

Catholicism

Champion, Lloyd

Children

Child’s tennis shoe

Christianity

Circle diagram

Clark, Ryan

blood sample

Clinton, Bill

Coerced confessions

expert witness on

Confession ( Jessie)

attempt to suppress
changes in
coerced
false
foundation
involuntary
leaked
published
questionable parts in
recanting
testimony conflicting with
in trial
validity of
voluntariness

Confession(s), false

Conflicts of interest

Constitutional rights

read to Jessie

Corning, Arkansas

Coroner

Cotton Mather on Witchcraft
(Mather)

Craighead County

Craighead County Courthouse

Creative Thinking International

Crime

cult–related
and the occult

Crime laboratory

analysis of “Negroid” hair
“Cause of Death” sheet
fibers analysis
knife sent to

Criminal profiler

Crittenden County

trials moved out of

Crittenden County Courthouse

Crittenden County Drug Task Force

Crittenden County Sheriff’s Office

Crow, Greg,

incident at Rector
pretrial motions

Crowley, Aleister

Cult activity/cults

in Damien and Jason’s trial
focus on
as motive
occult and

Cult cops

Cult expert

Cult materials, search for

Cult theory

support for

Cult-related crime

 

Davidson, Scott

Damien and Jason’s trial
Damien and Jason’s trial: sentencing phase
Mallett’s attack on
questioning Gitchell

Davis, Brent

cult motive

Damien and Jason’s trial

Damien and Jason’s trial: closing argument

Damien and Jason’s trial: cross-examining Damien

Damien and Jason’s trial: meeting with judge

Damien and Jason’s trial: objections

Damien and Jason’s trial: sentencing phase

incident at Rector

Jessie’s trial

Jessie’s trial: closing argument

offered Jason deal

possibility of Jessie tetifying against Damien and Jason

Rule 37 petition hearing
on second documentary
theory of motive

Davis, Lorri

Death penalty

Death row

Defendants

homes searched
paid for interviews

Defendants’ families

in documentary
reaction to verdict

Defense

Damien

documents not turned over to
Jessie
problems faced by

Defense lawyers

assumption of guilt
and confessions of suspects
discovery mess
and discovery of knife
documents released to
payment
prominent, interest in case
and quality of police investigation
pretrial motions

Defense lawyers, Damien and Jason’s trial

final witness
lesser charges
move for mistrial
objection to “cult expert,”
sentencing phase

Directed verdict

Discovery

additional
cult-related activity in

Discovery materials

Discovery mess

Lax’s investigation of

Discovery records, Lax’s search in

Discrepancies

J. M. Byers
in Jessie’s statements

DNA

DNA evidence

DNA testing

Documentary

detectives’ criticism of
lawsuit against makers of
second

Dog skull

Dougherty, Robin

Driver, Jerry

suspects
testimony
theft charges
transcript of interview with

Durham, Bill

interview with Driver
polygraphs
polygraphs: Jessie
suspects

 

Ebert, Roger

Echols, Andy “Jack,” 42

Echols, Damien

accused by A. Hutcheson
allegations against
appeals
arrested
attempt to separate Jason’s trial from
bite mark impressions
blood on necklace of
J. Byers blamed
called evil
closing argument
conflicts of interest in defense of
cult activity
on death row
as defendant
defense
depression
did not drive
in documentary
drinking blood
drugs
family questioned
fiber evidence
found guilty of capital murder
and V. Hutcheson
interest in occult
investigation directed at
Jessie’s accusatory statements about
Jessie to testify against
Jessie’s decision not to testify against
jury assessment of
in juvenile detention center
juvenile tried as adult
manic-depressive
marriage
mental state
money received for interview
musicians’ interviews with
name change
news reports on
and the occult
overdose of medication
owned knife
police reports of interviews with
polygraph
possibility of fair trial
presumption of guilt
pretrial concerns
pretrial motions
in prison
probable cause to arrest
psychological problems
psychological problems: and trial
psychological problems: in sentencing phase
questioned
reading
religious beliefs
remarks admitting guilt overheard

Other books

City of Ash by Megan Chance
Darkness Falls (DA 7) by Keri Arthur
The Digital Plague by Somers, Jeff
Amber by Deborah Challinor
Things I Did for Money by Meg Mundell
Still William by Richmal Crompton
Fallowblade by Cecilia Dart-Thornton