Authors: Benjamin Law
He laughed again. I imagined it was the kind of laugh that came after convincing someone to squeeze onion, ginger and lemon juice into their eyes.
Then came a question about sex.
âWhen we do more yoga,' Shirley read out in English to Ramdev, âshould we also feel like wanting more sex?'
Ramdev smiled again, greatly amused for someone who'd apparently never had sex himself. It was the first time sex had been mentioned during the conference and he approached the answer boldly. âThrough yoga, wives and husbands will have balance restored,' he said. âThey will be loyal to one another from the core of their hearts. When you do yoga, sexual disorders will be removed.' He nodded, certain in his convictions. âThrough yoga, your sexual desires will be balanced.'
The following day, when I got to meet Ramdev one-on-one, I could see he was wrong about the wrinkles. Crows feet had gathered around his eyes, though his skin was still smooth like a polished apple. There was also a single crease on his forehead, as though someone had run a blunt fingernail through it.
Ramdev had agreed to grant âprivate' interviews, albeit ones in which we would be surrounded by his all-male entourage, one of whom was a man in a business suit who would translate Ramdev's Hindi for me. Ramdev understood English well enough, but needed help communicating his responses. After
we sat down together, surrounded by his team, I asked him about some of his health claims, like the one that yoga had the power to cure people of HIV. Ramdev laughed â every thing seemed to amuse him â and said he stood by those claims.
âI never claimed to have personally cured HIV,' he said. âBut as far as HIV is concerned, there are three things that I've witnessed and claimed, and will say even now. One is the viral load. The CD4 counts responsible for your immune system, in some people with HIV, have decreased from 700 to 800 to as low as twenty-five.'
I nodded, understanding. By this stage a person would technically have AIDS.
âBut through
pranayam
breathing, the CD4 count becomes normal,' Ramdev said. âThe decrease in viral load is significant. The infection normalises. Even now, there are patients who experience these benefits.' He looked me in the eye, as if to challenge me. âIt can still be achieved with any patient you wish to refer or to send.'
On one level, I was impressed: Ramdev was familiar with the language of HIV and knew about CD4 levels and how viral loads worked. But the idea of AIDS patients doing breathing exercises to boost their immune system?
âThen in 2009, with the repeal of Section 377 â' I started.
Ramdev nodded, putting up his hands and interrupting, knowing what I was about to ask.
âWhen I visit the US or the UK, people â the gay community, gay individuals â they look at me and think, “Oh, this could be a dangerous person.”'
He laughed again, raising his eyebrows at his entourage as if to say,
Am I right?
They nodded their agreement and laughed back at him.
âBut I think
positively
of their conditions! It's a
habit
. It's a wrong habit, and also, it's a mental disorder.' He switched to English, as if to make his statement more official. âHomosexuality,' he said, âis a
bad mental habit
.'
His interpreter looked at me sternly to make sure I'd understood. I nodded.
âThe perversion can extend up to a level,' Ramdev continued, âwhere people wish to have
sex with animals
.'
âRight,' I said, taking notes. âSo it's a sliding scale, then. A spectrum.'
Ramdev turned out his palms and nodded. âIt's a spectrum of perversion, from normal sexual desire to perverted sexual desire. Most male homosexuals? They are actually
heterosexual
, you know. They have their usual sexual relationships with women, but they also wish to have homo sexual behaviour sometimes. So it's normally an extension, a perversion of normal behaviour.'
âAnd what about female homosexuals?' I asked.
Silence.
âLesbians,' the translator said ominously in English.
Ramdev shot me a little smile, as if he'd heard a dirty joke. âOh, it's also the same thing! If they were
purely
lesbian, you could argue that it was biological. But behaviourally,
they
are heterosexual also. Only the minority â 1 per cent â of these people are purely not heterosexual, purely gay or lesbian. Most are not attracted to each other sexually, but to each other as individuals. And then it becomes â¦'
âSomething else?' I offered.
âSomething else,' he said. âThese relationships can have a normal spectrum, but also a perverted spectrum. The practice of
pranayam
and meditation can give us a mastery over it, so
we'll be able to get out of the bad habit. People want to come out, but they don't feel confident enough because they don't have
tools
to come out.'
I looked at Ramdev confused, before I realised he didn't mean âcoming out' in the usual sense, but âcoming out' of a life bound by homosexuality. Looking at his beaming face, I felt conflicted: what he was saying made me squirm, but I also wanted to reach over and squeeze his adorable cheeks. For someone so insane and hateful, he was almost lovable in a cartoonish way. How horrible could he possibly be?
âYou say you can cure all this,' I said.
Ramdev sighed. â
Pranayam
and meditation can help.'
So Baba Ramdev's infamous de-gayification program was all about
breathing
correctly?
Pranayam
was the basis of breathing techniques taughed in yoga classes all over the world. I thought of my yoga classes back in Australia. Often these classes were packed full of gay men who wouldn't be straightened out even if you surgically inserted metal rods into their spines.
âDo you see homosexuality as a Western import?'
Ramdev shrugged. âThis is not a Western or Eastern thing. Only a bad habit. It's unproductive sex! It's like throwing the seed into the fire.'
âLike masturbation, then.'
Upon hearing that word, everyone nodded and murmured disapprovingly.
âHave people come to you for advice?' I asked. âI mean, say if I was to come to you and say, “Baba Ramdev, I am a homosexual, help me,” what would you say to me? What step-by-step advice would you give?'
âOf course I would help,' he said. âWe'd start with the
pranayam
practice, and that will lead the way forward â'
âIt's as simple as that?'
Ramdev gave me an exasperated look, like a teacher working with a dim child.
âIt's those four breathing practices that you're aware of now,' he said.
âThe internal change comes from practice,' a member of his entourage whispered urgently.
âUh-huh â¦'
Ramdev snapped. âNext question!' he said, shaking his head, decidedly offended. âStop this! Stop!'
His entourage bit their lips and looked away awkwardly.
âStop this!'
So we stopped.
In New Delhi, I sat in a plush hotel room, sipping tea and listening as someone gossiped to me about Ramdev.
âOh, I'm
convinced
he's gay,' Dr Anjali Gopalan said. âYou see him with those young boys on his TV shows â¦'
âYou mean his disciples?'
âWhatever they are,' she said. âThe way he touches them and looks at them â¦'
I laughed. Anjali raise her eyebrows, mock-serious.
âThere's something there!' she said.
Anjali Gopalan was in her fifties and had thick salt-and-pepper hair, an intimidatingly intelligent brain and the constant suggestion of mischief in her eyes, as if she was plotting something diabolical. She also had a lot of history with Baba Ramdev. Before, during and after the repeal of Section 377 â the so-called
ban on homosexuality â Ramdev and Gopalan often appeared on nightly current affairs programs to spar about the issue. In that time, Anjali's face became synonymous with the fight against Section 377. After all, it was her organisation that was the petitioner in the case of
Naz Foundation v. Government of NCT of Delhi
.
One of Anjali's most memorable confrontations with Ramdev had taken place when they were miked up in TV studios in separate cities, waiting for the host to introduce them. Because the connection was already live, guests were able to talk among themselves. Baba Ramdev had gestured to Anjali on the monitor and snidely asked the TV producer a question.
âSo, she is also like
this
?' he said, implying she was a lesbian.
âYou know, Babaji,' Anjali said, âI am
exactly
like you are. There is no difference between you and me. Meanwhile, it looks like you've found one
great
way to sell more of your medicines.'
Furious, Ramdev was about to fire back when the cameras started rolling.
âOh, he was so fucking angry with me,' Anjali said. âHe's a vicious queen.'
Whenever they had these televised debates, Ramdev was hostile but also appeared confused by Anjali. Unlike the flamboyant gay male activists Ramdev was happy to dismiss and mock, here was a woman whose title was âdoctor' and who dressed traditionally and conservatively. It was hard for Ramdev to attack Anjali for being stupid or an outsider to Indian culture. And she was also straight.
âHe didn't know where to place me,' Anjali said.
Anjali was famous throughout India for establishing the Naz Foundation in 1994, an HIV organisation that now occupied a five-storey building, including three levels where twenty-seven
HIV-positive kids lived. Some were orphans, others had been given up by HIV-positive parents who could no longer take care of them. On the walls were brightly coloured murals of butterflies and birds. It looked like a well-funded day-care centre you'd find anywhere in the world, except for its panoramic views of New Delhi.
When it started in 1994, the Naz Foundation had focused exclusively on men who had sex with men. Anjali had worked in New York City at the height of the AIDS crisis and saw close male friends die hideous deaths: slow, painful and shrouded by stigma. She saw how quickly the virus spread and knew India would be hit soon. When she got back to Delhi, Anjali teamed up with a doctor named Rajiv â who was also straight â and together the pair would go to Delhi's gay cruising parks with sample medications and supplies for sexual health tests.
âPoor man,' Anjali said, chuckling, thinking about Rajiv now. âRajiv didn't know what hit him. These boys would fall in love with him, but he was so good.'
They met with a lot of resistance. Older queens in the park would tell the younger boys not to listen to Anjali. She had come from the West, they said, and was spreading false rumours about a disease that didn't exist. Some of them speculated that the real reason Anjali was there was that she, like Baba Ramdev, wanted to make them all straight. Anjali laughed thinking about it now but, looking back, realised she had been on a steep learning curve too.
âYou're very clear in the States when you go through your training,' she said. âPeople are either straight, bi or gay. Here, in India, there's like this whole other world. One had to relearn everything.'
For a start, most of these Indian men didn't identify as
âgay'. They had no sense of community or even sexual identity. The Naz Foundation set up phone lines, which they advertised in public spaces where men were known to have sex. Besides the men themselves, parents called in constantly, bemoaning the fact that they'd discovered their son sleeping with other men. When Anjali and other Naz counsellors told parents homosexual behaviour wasn't a disease, the parents weren't convinced.
âEvery time we counselled parents, we'd beat our heads against the wall,' Anjali said. âIt always came to this: “If you think we should accept our son as he is, and it's really normal and natural for our son to be like this, then why is it
criminal
?”' Anjali looked at me with both her palms facing upwards, exasperated. âHow do you argue with that?' she said.
Anjali and the other counsellors tried persuading the parents that Section 377, a law that dated back to 1860, was an unfair legislative relic and that they were doing everything they could to fight it. The parents were never convinced. Deep down, Anjali, too, felt that nothing was ever going to change. The Indian legal system was infamously slow and inefficient, and sexual minorities would never be attended to with any urgency. Every other day, Anjali would end up at the local police station, negotiating with the cops to release Naz Foundation outreach workers from detention. They would be caught in the parks trying to engage with men about safe sex, and the cops would haul them off. The police gruffly explained to Anjali that her staff were technically promoting an illegal behaviour. For Anjali, the breaking point came when the Naz Foundation discovered a young Indian man who had been forcibly given shock treatment for being gay. When Anjali and Naz took the case to the National Human Rights Commission, they were
told it wouldn't be investigated â once again, because homosexual sex was illegal.