For a few moments the other men at the bar froze, trying to make sense of what they’d just witnessed. Then Daley hurled a wild curse at Tyree and went for his gun. He still hadn’t cleared leather when he found himself looking into the muzzle of Tyree’s Colt.
“That’s it. I’m done!” Daley screamed, his eyes popping out of his head. He let his gun drop and it thudded onto the floor.
The three others at the bar, bad actors all, had the wild, reckless look of men who were thinking about auditioning for parts in the play.
But Tyree’s cold command stopped them. “Call off your dogs, Daley, or I’ll gut shoot you right where you stand.”
“You heard the man. Back off!” Daley shrieked. The big deputy was almost frantic with fear, knowing how close he stood to a bullet in the belly.
The others reluctantly lifted their hands clear of their guns, and one of them, a lantern-jawed man in a butternut shirt, asked, “Clem, you sure this is how you want it?”
“Yes, damn it,” Daley yelped. “Step away from it.”
“Daley,” Tyree said, no give in him, “take off my coat and lay it on the bar.”
The deputy hesitated and Tyree yelled, “Do it now!”
His face gray, Daley quickly peeled off the coat and did as he was told.
“Take me a month to get your stink out of that,” Tyree said. He leaned down and grabbed the Kid by the back of his shirt collar; then his eyes lifted to Daley again. “Where’s my dun?” he asked. “And my Colt.”
“They ain’t here, honest,” Daley said. “I took your hoss and the guns to the Rafter-L.”
“Daley, I plan on staying in town tonight,” Tyree said. “Come first light tomorrow morning I want to see that dun standing outside the hotel. I want my gun and belt hanging from the saddle horn. You got that?”
The big deputy touched his tongue to dry lips. He was badly frightened. With the Arapaho Kid out of it, no longer there to back his play, he felt naked and alone.
“Sure, anything you say,” Daley said.
“Now you and the others get on your ponies and ride out of here,” Tyree said. “I don’t want to have to be always watching my back.”
Tyree strolled outside the saloon door until Daley and the other Laytham riders mounted up and left town, the big deputy in the lead, slapping his horse with the reins until it stretched its neck and its legs blurred into a flat-out run.
When Tyree stepped back inside, the bartender asked, nodding toward the still unconscious Arapaho Kid, “What about him?”
“He killed a friend of mine,” Tyree said. “But I reckon his days as a shooter of unarmed men are about to come to a permanent close.”
“You gonna kill the Kid?” the bartender asked, his face shocked.
Tyree nodded. “Something like that.”
“Mister,” the bartender protested, “there ain’t nothing like that.”
“Maybe so,” Tyree said. “But there’s worse.”
He hauled the Kid outside and, as a curious crowd gathered, dragged him by the collar of his shirt to the horse trough near the hitching rail. Tyree repeatedly dunked the gunman’s head into the water, each time leaving it there until the man began to frantically kick and struggle and bubbles rose to the surface.
Finally Tyree forced the Kid to his knees. Then he bent and looked into his face, their noses only inches apart. “You awake now, Kid?” he asked through gritted teeth. “I want you to know exactly what’s happening to you, every last part of it.”
Blood ran in watery fingers from the gunman’s nose over his mouth and chin, but his face was dark and ugly with anger. “I’ll kill you for this, Tyree,” he snarled. “By God, I’ll gun you first chance I get.”
Tyree smiled and shook his head. “Kid, your killing days ended when you murdered Owen Fowler.” Tyree pulled the gunman to his feet and spun him around. He shoved his hand into the Kid’s pocket and found what he’d been looking for—four shiny new double eagles.
Tyree turned the man again and shoved the coins under the Kid’s smashed nose. “Four of these in your pocket and one on the bar in the saloon,” he said, his eyes hard, each breath short and harsh. “Is that what Laytham considered Owen Fowler’s life was worth, huh? A lousy hundred dollars?”
“You go to hell!” the Kid snapped.
Tyree viciously backhanded the gunman across the face. “Was it?” he yelled. “Was Owen worth only a hundred dollars?”
The Kid’s face was a bloody mess and he was struggling to breathe. “A bonus,” he gasped. “It was a bonus.”
“For murdering Owen Fowler?”
“Yeah, yeah, for Fowler.”
The Arapaho Kid’s right hand dropped for the gun on his hip. But Tyree saw it coming and slapped the hand aside. He yanked the Kid’s Colt from the holster and shoved it into his own waistband.
“You’re a sorry piece of low-life trash, Kid,” Tyree said, his voice suddenly level and chillingly calm. “Now I’m going to make sure you never kill another unarmed man.”
Judged by the standards of a later era, what followed next was brutal, savage and merciless. But it is wise for a man to hesitate to judge the conduct of Western men lest he fall into the common error of condemning what he does not understand. Chance Tyree lived at a violent time in a violent land and justice as he understood it was swift, certain and tailored to fit the crime.
Tyree dragged the kicking, yelling Arapaho Kid to the hitching rail and laid the gunman’s manicured, pampered right hand on the rough pine of the cross post. He pulled the Kid’s Colt from his waistband, held it by the barrel and, with the butt, smashed the hand into a pulp of blood, gristle and splintered bone.
Ignoring the Kid’s screams and the cries of the crowd for Sheriff Tobin, he did the same thing with the Kid’s left. And when it was over, he stepped back and looked down with cold eyes at the whimpering gunman, who was bent over on his knees, his ruined hands held close to his belly, rocking back and forth.
No backup in him, and no compassion either, Tyree said, “You’d best find yourself another line of work, Kid. I’d say your days as a hired gun are over.”
He grabbed the Kid by the back of his collar and pushed him toward his horse. “Now ride, and if I ever see you in the canyon country again, I’ll kill you.”
The Kid staggered to his horse, his pain-filled face ashen and scared. He wanted to get away from here, as far away as possible from the tall, relentless man with eyes the color of cold green death.
After several attempts, the Kid finally swung into the saddle and he kneed his horse forward. The big bartender from Bradley’s stood on the boardwalk. He threw Tyree a look of hatred, and called out to the Kid, “Hey, Kid, you want my shotgun?”
The Arapaho Kid gave the bartender a sidelong glance and gasped, “You go to hell.”
He kicked his horse into a lope and headed out of town. Tyree watched him leave until horse and rider were swallowed up by dust and distance.
“What’s going on here?”
Tyree turned and watched as Sheriff Tobin, pulling a suspender over the shoulder of his dirty red vest, bellied his way through the crowd.
“Can’t a man get any sleep around here?” he demanded, his eyes hidden behind his round, dark glasses. The hair that showed under the lawman’s hat was pure white and his face was pasty, like the skin on the belly of a dead fish.
“Sheriff, this man just done for the Kid,” someone in the crowd yelled. “Smashed both his hands to pulp.”
Then it seemed everybody was talking at once, trying to get in their two cents’ worth about what they’d just witnessed. Many voices were raised, but Tyree heard none that were friendly.
“Where is the Kid now?” Tobin asked, his uplifted hands quieting the crowd.
“He’s gone, Sheriff,” Tyree said. “And he won’t be coming back.”
He looked into Tobin’s face but could not read the man’s eyes, hidden as they were behind their circles of darkness.
Tobin turned and saw the bartender on the boardwalk. “Benny, what happened?”
The bartender stepped off the walk and pointed to Tyree. “This man braced the Kid in the saloon. Then he dragged him out here and smashed up both his hands, just like you was told, Sheriff.” The man called Benny turned and extended his arms to the crowd. “I think it’s a crying shame that an honest citizen can’t enjoy a little celebration in the saloon without being attacked and manhandled.”
A murmur of agreement ran through the crowd. A few were the respectable townspeople of Crooked Creek, but most were drifters and the assorted riffraff of the frontier, anxious for any kind of excitement, especially a possible lynching.
Tyree was an outsider here, and all the town’s sympathies were with the Arapaho Kid.
“Honest citizen, huh?” Tyree asked Tobin. He stepped closer to the big lawman. “Hold out your hand, Tobin.”
“Why?”
“Just do it.”
Tobin extended his powerful white paw and Tyree dropped the four double eagles into his palm. “You’ll find another one on the bar in the saloon. The Kid told me Quirt Laytham gave him these—a bonus for murdering Owen Fowler.”
Some of the respectable element in the crowd exchanged puzzled looks, wondering about what Tyree had just said, trying to gauge the truth or falsity of it.
Tobin felt, rather than saw, the shift in attitude and stepped quickly into the breach. “Maybe that’s what the Kid said, Tyree, and maybe it wasn’t. But in any case I wouldn’t take the word of a damn breed on anything.”
A tall, thin man who looked like a merchant in a broadcloth suit and a high celluloid collar, said, “Hear, hear.” Tobin pressed home his advantage.
“You people break it up now,” he said. “Be about your business.” He turned to Tyree. “You come with me. I want to talk to you.”
“You arresting me, Sheriff?” Tyree asked, his voice hard-edged.
“No, though I could for what you did back at the wash. Cost us some good men.”
“They were coming at me shooting,” Tyree said. “I was defending myself.”
Tobin rubbed a hand across his unshaven cheeks then glanced at the blazing sun. “I don’t care to stand here in the street and talk. I burn up real easy. Come with me to my office.”
“What do you want to talk about, Tobin?” Tyree asked.
The big lawman stepped closer, so close Tyree could smell him, and his voice dropped to a confidential whisper. “I’ve got another proposition for you, and this one you’d be well-advised to take.”
Chapter 12
The sheriff’s office was a low log cabin with a timber roof, sandwiched between the telegraph office and a hardware store. It had a narrow porch and an awning held up by slender poles, a rocking chair set to one side of the door.
Inside, the place smelled like Tobin himself, a heavy mix of stale sweat, tobacco juice and smoke from the kerosene lantern that hung from a ceiling beam, its orange flame guttering. Black canvas shades were pulled down across the cabin’s two windows, blocking out every glimpse of sunlight, and the air was thick, cloying and close, hard to breathe.
A door at the rear of the office hung ajar on rawhide hinges and beyond was a single cell. The front wall of the cell was of red brick, a barred, iron door to the right. The rustler Roy Will lay on his back on a bunk in the half-light, staring at the ceiling, his shoulder heavily bandaged.
Tobin closed the office door leading to the cell. “I plan on hanging him the day after tomorrow, but, even so, it’s best he doesn’t hear our talk.” The lawman sat at his desk, opened a drawer and took out a bottle of whiskey. “Drink?” he asked.
Tyree shook his head. “Cut to the chase, Tobin. What’s your proposition?”
Tobin lifted the bottle to his mouth, took a gulping swallow that made his throat bob, then wiped the back of his hand across his mouth. He sat in silence for a few moments, studying the tall younger man, then said, “Tyree, now that Fowler is dead, this thing is over and it’s time you was riding on. There’s no point in your staying around and causing all kinds of trouble for everybody. Which brings me to this. . . .”
Tobin slid open another drawer, rooted around for a few moments, then came up with a thick stack of greenbacks. He threw the money on the desk in front of Tyree. “That’s a thousand dollars, more money than you’ll ever see in one place at one time in your whole life. All you got to do is lean over, pick it up and then be on your way. Ride out of the territory, Tyree. Go to Denver maybe and spend the money on women and whiskey. Hell, man, have yourself a time.”
Tyree made no attempt to pick up the money. He tilted his head to one side, smiling. “I’d say Quirt Laytham must be mighty scared of me.”
“Mr. Laytham isn’t scared of anybody,” Tobin scoffed, “especially not you.”
“Then why did he tell you to bribe me with a thousand dollars?”
The lamplight accentuated the pockmarks that cratered the sheriff’s white cheeks, picking out the beads of sweat on his forehead and nose. It was unbearably hot in the office. Tyree felt his shirt sticking to him, the fetid, feral stench of the fat lawman assailing his nostrils.
“You’re so smart, ain’t you, Tyree?” Tobin said. “So damned smart.” He leaned forward and propped his elbows on the desk. “Get this through your thick skull: Quirt Laytham doesn’t need to bribe you to leave anywhere. Step in his way again and he’ll crush you like a bug.” The sheriff shook his head. “No, this money was give me by somebody else, somebody who wants you long gone from here. For your own good, you understand.”
Tobin shifted his bulk in the chair and it squeaked in protest, sending a frightened rat scuttling across the floor. “After that . . . ah . . . shall we say, unpleasantness at Hatch Wash, Mr. Laytham and me figured Fowler would head for Luke Boyd’s place, seeing as how him and the old man were real close at one time. Me, I was gonna ride out there with the money today and talk to you private, like. But now there’s no need because there you stand as bold as brass and on the prod as ever was.”
“Who put up the money?” Tyree asked, intrigued despite himself.