Authors: Harry Turtledove
Winship turned and stared. Not far away, a camel brayed, a hideous, almost unearthly sound. Winship’s eyes swung to the beast and fixed on it for close to half a minute. Then he surveyed the camp again. “General,” he said at last, his voice hoarse, “had anyone told me you had even a brigade here, I’d have called him a liar to his face. How the devil you managed to move a whole goddamn division so far and so fast is beyond me. My hat’s off to
you, sir.” Fitting action to word, he removed the broad-brimmed black felt from his head.
“I wouldn’t have believed it myself,” Major Sellers said solemnly. Stuart was about to kick him in the shins when he redeemed himself by adding, “But the general can do just about anything he sets his mind to.”
“I’ve seen that,” Winship said, his voice gloomy. “I was in the Army of the Potomac when he rode all the way around us during the Seven Days.” Turning to Stuart, he asked, “What are your terms for the surrender of my force, sir?”
“About what you’d expect: men to stack arms and yield up all ammunition. You and your officers may keep your sidearms.”
“Very well.” Theron Winship looked at the acres of campfires, at the men moving from one to another, at the rows of tents, at the rows of animals—with another lingering glance of disbelief at the camels—and at the ranked field guns stretching back toward and into the night. “Under the circumstances, that’s generous enough. I accept.”
“Excellent,” Stuart said briskly. “Major Sellers will accompany you back to Contention City, to make sure you are complying with the terms. We’ll see you by eight tomorrow morning. Be ready to travel then.”
They shook hands again. Horatio Sellers looked back toward Stuart. Stuart kept his face bland as grits without butter. With a grunt, Sellers and Lieutenant Colonel Winship rode north toward the Yankee garrison. When Stuart announced to his men that the U.S. officer had surrendered, their cheers and Rebel yells split the night.
As soon as it was light enough to travel, they rode up the San Pedro to Contention City. They reached the refining town before Stuart had said they would. He was glad to see the Yankee troops hadn’t burned any of the stamping mills or refineries. He hadn’t mentioned that when discussing the surrender with Lieutenant Colonel Winship, for fear of putting ideas in his head.
Winship had his men drawn up in formation, waiting for the Confederates. He had eight companies of infantry there, and a battery of field guns. Fighting from cover, he could have put up a formidable resistance.
When Stuart came up to him, the U.S. officer looked puzzled. “Where are the rest of your men, sir?” he asked. “Have
you detached them for duty elsewhere, having obtained my capitulation?”
Stuart knew he should have answered
yes
to that, to increase Winship’s confusion. But he couldn’t resist the temptation to tell the truth: “Lieutenant Colonel, this is my entire force.”
Winship needed a moment to take that in. When he did, he went purple under his coat of tan. “Why, you God-damned son of a bitch!” he shouted, which made his own men stare at him. “You hoaxed me. If I’d known this was all the men you had, I’d’ve fought—and I’d’ve whipped you, too.”
“I doubt it,” Stuart said, on the whole truthfully; Winship could have hurt him, but he didn’t think the U.S. officer could have kept him out of Contention City if he had a mind to break in. He grinned at the furious Winship. “It doesn’t matter anyhow, not now it doesn’t. You’re under my guns, sir.”
“You hoaxed me,” Winship repeated, as if ruses of war were not permitted. “Let me unstack my guns, General, and fight it out. Fair is fair, and this isn’t. You got my surrender under false pretenses.”
“Yes, and I’m going to keep it, too,” Stuart said cheerfully. “My men worked long and hard to set up that camp and all those fires last night. If you think I’m going to waste what they did, Lieutenant Colonel, you can think again.”
“It isn’t right,” Winship insisted. He kept staring at the Confederate soldiers who were taking charge of his men, as if still convinced there should have been five times as many of them as there were. His company officers, on the other hand, were looking at him. Jeb Stuart would not have been happy, were he on the receiving end of those looks.
More of his troopers, including a couple who knew a good deal about mining, went into the refining works. They came out with enormous smiles on their faces. “General, we’re going to make us a hell of a lot of money on this little visit,” one of them called to Stuart.
“Load up some wagons, then,” Stuart answered. He detailed guards to try to make sure the profits accrued to the Confederate States rather than to individual soldiers.
“What are you going to do with us?” Theron Winship asked.
It was a good question. Most of the defenders of Contention City were infantrymen. They would have as hard a time keeping
up with his troopers as his own foot soldiers would have done. Reluctantly, he decided he had to take them down into Sonora even so. “If I parole you, you’ll still be able to fight Indians and free up other men to fight us,” he told Winship. “You’ll come along south with us, and probably sit out the rest of the war in Hermosillo.”
If that prospect appealed to the U.S. officer, he concealed it very well. “General, you’ve just made a hash of my military career,” he said bitterly.
“That’s too bad,” Stuart answered. “If things had gone the other way, though, you would have made a hash of mine. Since those are my only two choices, I know which one I’d pick if I had my druthers. And since I do—”
Since he did, his soldiers methodically plundered the mineral wealth of Contention City, then set fire to the stamping mills and refineries. With great clouds of black smoke rising behind them, they started south down the San Pedro River toward the border between New Mexico Territory and Sonora.
They didn’t push the pace now, not with prisoners marching on foot and the sun blazing down from the sky. Even as things were, men and animals suffered from the heat. It wasn’t nearly so humid as it would have been back in New Orleans or Richmond, but it was fifteen degrees or so hotter than it would have been back East, which rendered the advantage meaningless.
To Stuart’s disappointment, they didn’t reach the deceitfully oversized camp with which he’d fooled Theron Winship before darkness forced a halt to the day’s travel. The Confederate commander was proud of his work, and wanted to show it to Winship in detail. Whether the man he’d gulled would have appreciated it never crossed his mind.
Stuart had already fallen asleep when Major Sellers came into his tent and shook him back to consciousness. “Sorry to bother you, sir,” he said while Stuart groaned and sat up on his folding bed, “but there’s some Indians out there want to have a powwow with you.”
“Scouts bring ’em in?” Stuart asked, pulling on his boots.
“Uh, no, sir,” his aide-de-camp answered. “One second they weren’t anywhere around. Next thing anybody knew, they were right in front of your tent. They could have come in if they’d had a mind to. They said they’ve been watching us all day, and we never set eyes on them once.”
“They’re good at that,” Stuart remarked. He stepped out into the night. Sure enough, half a dozen Indians stood there waiting, some with U.S. Springfields, the rest carrying Winchesters. The oldest of them, a stocky fellow in his late fifties or early sixties, let loose with a stream of Spanish. Stuart, unfortunately, knew none.
One of the younger Indians, who had a look of the older, saw that and translated: “My father likes the way you tricked the bluecoats. He wants to fight the bluecoats at your side. He has been fighting them alone too long.” More talk from the old man, this time in his own gurgling tongue. Again, the younger one spoke for him: “He wants—sanctuary, is that the word?—for his band of the
Dineh
, the Apaches, you would say, in Sonora, like the Confederacy gives to the tribes in the Indian Territory who fight against the USA. When Sonora belonged to Mexico, the bluecoats would chase us over the border. The Confederate States are strong, and will not let that happen. We will fight for you because of this.”
“Does he?” Stuart said. “Will you?” Whoever the old Indian was, he had an astute understanding of the way the Confederacy dealt with the Indian tribes along the U.S. border. If he had any power, he might make a useful ally. Even if he was only a bandit chief, his men would make useful scouts. Stuart spoke carefully to the younger Indian: “Tell your father I thank him. Tell him that because I am new in this country, I do not recognize him by sight no matter how famous he may be, but perhaps I will know his name if he gives it to me.”
The younger Indian spoke in Apache. When he fell silent, his father nodded to Stuart, then pointed to his own chest. “Geronimo,” he said.
Riding over the prairie somewhere between Wichita and the border with the Indian Territory and the Confederacy, Colonel George Custer was in a foul mood. “I have the Thanks of Congress back in my quarters at Fort Dodge,” he said to his brother, “there up on the wall where everyone can see it. And what is it for, I ask you?” He answered his own question: “For going after the enemy and hitting him a good lick. It was your idea, I know, but I’m the one with the eagles on my shoulders, so the scroll came to me.”
“Don’t fret yourself about that, Autie,” Tom Custer said. He was not and never had been jealous of his older brother. “Plenty of chances for glory to come our way.”
“Not when we’re doing what we’re doing,” Custer ground out. “The Rebs poked at Wichita once, so we have to gallop back and forth to make sure they don’t do it again. I tell you, it makes us look like a prizefighter covering up where he got hit last instead of doing any punching himself. And for what? For Wichita?” He clapped a hand to his forehead in florid disbelief.
“It’s not much of a town,” Tom agreed.
“Not much of a town?” Custer said. “Not much of a town? If it weren’t on the railroad, it wouldn’t have any reason for existing. Oh, the Rebs shipped a few cows through there ten years ago, when they were still pretending to be nice fellows, but they gave that up a good while ago. Now it just sits there, bleaching in the sun like any old bones. And we have to defend it?” He rolled his eyes.
“We have to defend the railroad line and the telegraph, too,” Tom said.
Custer sighed. His brother had advanced the one irrefutable argument. Without the railroads and the talking wire, travel and information in the United States would move as slowly as they had in the days of the Roman Empire. Even bereft of the Confederate States, the United States were too vast to let Roman methods work.
“Trouble is,” Custer said, “if we try to defend the whole line of the railroad, that ties up so many men, we can’t do much else in these parts.”
“I know,” Tom answered. “If it’s any consolation to you, Autie, the Rebs have exactly the same problem in Texas.”
“The only way I want the Rebs to have my problems is for them to have problems I give ’em,” Custer said, which made his brother laugh. “I don’t want any problems myself, and they’re welcome to as many I don’t have as they like.”
He waved back toward the two Gatling guns, which weren’t having any trouble keeping up with his troopers. The men weren’t going flat out, of course, and he’d taken pains to make sure the Gatlings had fine horses pulling them. Tom understood his gesture perfectly, saying, “Yes, that’s the kind of problem the Rebels should have, all right. Those guns mowed them down same as they did to the Kiowas.”
One of Custer’s men let out a yell. The colonel’s first glance was to the south—were they about to collide with the Confederates? He looked around for a rise on which to site the Gatling guns. What had worked once would probably work twice.
But he saw no Rebel horsemen, nor Indians, either. More troopers were calling out now, and some of them pointing north. Custer spied a courier riding hard for the regiment. He waved to the bugler, who blew Halt. The men reined in. A couple of them took advantage of the stop by getting out their tobacco pouches and rolling cigarettes.
Bringing his lathered horse to a halt, the courier thrust an envelope at Custer. “Urgent, sir,” he said, saluting. “From Brigadier General Pope, up at Fort Catton.”
Custer stared at him. “Good God,” he said. “That’s all the way up in Nebraska.” The troopers close enough to have heard him started buzzing with speculation. He didn’t blame them. Why the devil was General Pope reaching down to the border with the CSA?
Only one way to find out. Custer tore the envelope open and read the orders it contained. When he was done, he read them again. They still said the same thing, no matter how hard a time he had believing it. “What’s the news, Autie?” Tom Custer demanded impatiently.
“We—the whole regiment, including the Gatlings—are ordered to report to Fort Catton as expeditiously as possible.” Custer knew he sounded numb. He couldn’t help it. In the slang of the War of Secession, this was a big thing, and no mistake. “A regiment of volunteer cavalry will take over patrolling here in southern Kansas.”
“Fort Catton? On the Platte?” Tom sounded as bewildered as his brother felt. “It’s a couple of hundred miles from here, and a couple of hundred miles from any fighting, too. Why don’t they send the volunteers there?”
“I don’t know. It says we’ll get further orders when we arrive.” Custer pointed to the courier. “You there, Corporal—do you know anything more about this?”
“No, sir,” the horseman answered: a simple but uninformative reply.
“What in the blue blazes does General Pope want with me?” Custer muttered. He wondered if it dated back to his service on
McClellan’s staff during the War of Secession. Pope and Little Mac had been fierce rivals then. After Lee whipped Pope at Second Manassas, Lincoln had relegated Pope to fighting Indians in the West, and he’d been here ever since. Of course, a little later on Lee had whipped McClellan even worse up at Camp Hill. That relegated the whole war to the ash heap, so Pope was in a sense already vindicated.
“We’ll have to find out when we get there, that’s all,” Tom said. He worried less about Army politics than his brother did. If it was a legal order, he would obey it, and that was that.