Authors: Donald Mccaig
Sallie swallowed. “But, Alexander, can't you wait? Everyone says the Federals will be in Richmond before the month is out.”
His words tumbled over one another in his eagerness. “Don't you see? That's the cunningest part. If I take a principled stand, and am confined with the other Federal prisoners, my story will be credited. If I wait too long, I am merely another convict with a complaint!”
For the first time in her life, Sallie Botkin fainted.
Two warders came to Sallie's cell on the morning Alexander was to be flogged. One offered to read from the Bible, but Sallie said no. Perfectly composed, she sat on her stool, hands folded in her lap. She did hope Alexander might not scream.
Even while they tied him to the whipping post, Alexander remained confident reason would prevail. When the fire of the first blow reached his lungs, his bellow was less pain than astonishment. With no defenses prepared, no stoicism at hand, he begged and shrieked like a child. Life proved so much worse than he feared.
The flogging was done by an Irishman who, offended by Alexander's unmanly noises, laid on worse than he otherwise might have.
Of course, Mr. Tyree could not flog a white man.
LETTER FROM CATESBY
BYRD TO DUNCAN GATEWOOD
B
EAVERDAM
, V
IRGINIA
J
ULY
2, 1862
DEAREST KINSMAN,
In the past seven days I have witnessed sights I had not thought to see in this life. Of dead men and dead horses and swamps and gunpowder I am heartily sick.
After our bungled attack at Gaines Mill, Corporal Fisher (who regularly cleans me out at poker) and I had picket duty in a copse of sycamore trees which had been splintered and shredded by the day's cannonades. At dusk, when the wounded earth was steaming and the night fog rose from the streams and swampy places, we heard a noise. It was a single soldier: a corpulent Federal private in a uniform so fresh he must have donned it for the first time that evening. When he espied us he stopped, uttered a cryâhalf alarm, half moanâbefore extracting a horse pistol his parent may have carried during the Mexican war. The Federal's shape was deformed, his breast sharpish as if a rooster's breastbone had been grafted onto a man.
“I won't kill you if you don't kill me,” he said, his pistol wobbling from one of us to the other.
Corporal Fisher, who earlier had pillaged rations from one of this figure's deceased countrymen and was desirous of putting those rations to good use, replied, “Son, why don't you walk back in that fog and leave us patriots in peace.”
“I'm lost,” the Federal confessed.
“Well, son,” Corporal Fisher replied, “from our uniforms you can presume we ain't the folks you're lookin' for. Fellows you want wear blue.”
Duncan, I swear the fellow had a tear in his eye. “If I turn my back, you gonna shoot?”
“Naw,” Fisher said. “You ain't no use to us. Why, you wouldn't even make a good prisoner. Now, you are interruptin' a repast I have been long anticipatin'. Why don't you sound retreat? Follow General McClellan's sterling example and change your base.”
Then, Duncan, the fellow thumped his chest with the barrel of his pistol and it gave off a hollow sound, like someone beating an iron bucket. “I got no protection behind,” he complained.
Duncan, that Federal was wearing a steel breastplate some rogue of a sutler had sold him.
Corporal Fisher leaned his Enfield against a tree, perched on a downed sycamore, and began to unwrap his supper. “I ain't gonna take you prisoner and you ain't takin' me prisoner. Army you seek is somewhere behind you.” with no more ado, he began sampling Federal hardtack, which is, in every respect, quite as loathsome as our own.
Seeing that he was getting nowhere with negotiations, the Federal withdrew, facing us every cautious backward step. Since the ground was littered with shattered trees, his retreat was extremely tedious. Before he had quite disappeared, Fisher called out to him, “Yank, if you're gonna fight General Lee again it'd be well to put your armor on backward. It won't do you no good while you're runnin' away.”
So we have our jests even as dead men grin at us beneath the bushes where they crawled to die.
I am sorry to give news that Private Ryals was taken to the hospital suffering from cholera and he succumbed to that disease.
You are not a good correspondent, Duncan my friend. And since you have seen my infant son, Willie, I would welcome any word of him, his surprising beauty, intellectual prowess, etc. None but shameless flattery of the little creature will be permitted! I am so grateful that Leona has recovered from her delivery. Sometimes when the interlude between infants is too long, childbirth is dangerous.
I must tell of the Strasburg farmer who produced a fine wedding celebration for his daughter. When the bridal party exited the church, our quartermaster's men were leading their horses away. Carriages of the wedding processions stood unhitched and, so far as I know, still stand outside the church. Our quartermaster notices all weddings in the countryside. He avers he is beginning to notice funerals too.
Of Jackson's troops, only Burke's regiment fought at Mechanicsville. Although the very air roared with battle, the 44th was never summoned. The next morning we were ordered to scavenge the battlefield. We heaped rifles, haversacks, shoes, and foodstuffs on our commissary wagons. Though my son Thomas would appreciate some souvenir of our victory, I took nothing, fearing the example I might set. Some of our menâCorporal Fisher among themâneeded no example and happily pocketed valuables from the Federal dead. Our officers could not halt the pilferage.
Leona writes that you are reconciled to your parent. He is as good a man as I know and oft times when I am in doubt or confused I resolve the issue by asking what Samuel Gatewood might do in my place. I was glad to learn that Stratford's wheat crop is promising. Until this war is over, our provender will come from our domestic economy. I count my family fortunate to abide at Stratford, where food is plentiful.
General Jackson shattered the Federals in the Valley and now Lee shatters them on the outskirts of Richmond. Surely they must sue for peace!
Although I confess to a stirring in my heart when the yell goes up and our brave banners start forward, these battles in the swamps below Richmond have impressed me with the awfulness of war. Horses scream, wounded men weep all night. Only the crash of great guns drowns out these terrible commonplaces.
Since we are so near Richmond, President Davis sometimes pays us a call. Yesterday afternoon, he and his entourage arrived where General Lee was directing operations. Lee inquired, “Sir, who are this army of people?” Davis replied that he did not know.
“Well, sir,” Lee stated, “they are not my army and I do not want them here.” And so our President was driven away by his own general.
The Federals abandon prodigious stores, and we are eating like Turkish pashas: hams, salt beef, an immense herd of cattle captured on the hoof. And these are the mere residue of the tons of foodstuffs the Federals burned during their hasty retreat. The combined stink of unburied dead and scorched bully beef is unforgettable.
Tuesday our line formed along the railroad, where it crossed the Chickahominy on a trestle. Because of the high banks we expected a peaceful bivouac and were resting, smoking, writing letters home, until the Federals, despairing of withdrawing an ammunition train, set it afire and throttled it toward our lines. The cars bulged and thrashed and streamed white smoke, and the entire train shook as if palsied as it hurtled toward us. The locomotive failed to negotiate the final curve before the trestle and dove like an iron arrow to the mud flats below, and the subsequent explosions made my ears ring. Duncan, what shall we do when this war is over? We shall never see these sights again in our lifetime. There is something truly glorious in this prodigal waste.
General A. P. Hill has distinguished himself in battle, and though his kinsman Spaulding must have been at Hill's side, I have no news of him.
I am gladdened to learn that your wound is knitting. A modest limp conveys distinction upon a young man. When will you rejoin us? Although Lieutenant Bartles has your old company, I am sure the men will be happy to revert to your cooler leadership. Stonewall Jackson is so successful every junior officer is imitating his habits. Since Stonewall sucks on a lemon for refreshment during battle, so do they. Our quartermaster cannot keep a supply.
Your Obedient Servant and loving brother-in-law,
Catesby
RESPECTABLE WORK
R
ICHMOND
, V
IRGINIA
J
ULY
4, 1862
THE AMALGAM OF
metals ideal for casting church bells is identical to the formula armorers prefer for cannons, and a good many of Richmond's bells had been melted down for that purpose. After General Lee's guns had done their duty, driven the invader from the city and ceased their thundering, the victory peals in Richmond were faintâvictory was celebrated in the Confederate capital by a municipal buzzing like a hive of especially satisfied bees.
Men who'd known Richmond in Patrick Henry's time couldn't recall a warmer June, and the air had been thick as a wet glove. Citizens had stayed up half the night to the flash and rumble of guns, and fell gratefully into bed at dawn. Cary Street and Broad Street were jammed boardwalk to boardwalk with carts of wounded, and beside the carts walked dirty, bloodstained men. Though men in the carts cried out, the walking men were uniformly silent.
It was a foggy morning, cooler, the sun a pale coin in the east. Dew glistened the grass as Cousin Molly's barouche turned into the penitentiary's sally port. A brief pause, a murmur, and the clop-clop-clop across the cobblestones until it drew up before the keeper's house.
The coloreds were lined up against the outer wall, chained to a chain that might have hauled an anchor. Some had erected scrap-canvas shelters, some had strung blankets on poles, most sat against the cold stone and wrapped their arms around themselves. While waiting return to their masters, they marched out to dig fortifications. Each morning, Keeper Tyree's manservant made him one small pot of coffee and these men could smell it. Their nostrils twitched.
The cellblocks were brick above stone. The yard cobblestones were perfectly regular. The roofs of workshops and warders' quarters were cedar shakes, long faded to undifferentiated gray. The old cellblocks were capped with roofs of slate.
Cousin Molly's barouche was done up in the grand style, blue with gold trim for the footboard and door, and Cousin Molly's driver's faded uniform was of the same color scheme. He rapped the keeper's door more sharply than any prisoner would have dared.
Abruptly, the door swung open, and the driver recoiled slightly before proffering the message that had been entrusted to him. The door thudded shut.
A streamer of thick fog drifted into the yard, clammy on the skin. A raven cawed somewhere. Cousin Molly's driver returned to the barouche, ducked under its formal black canopy, and spoke. The keeper's side door banged open, and Tyree's servant hastened across the yard to the female cellblock, up the stairs to the second floor.
Men make drama of the material available to them: the acting keeper's vanished servant, the barouche waiting quietly in the fog, Mr. Tyree's window curtains suddenly swept apart and his sallow face pressed to the glass, the girl hurrying across the yard behind Tyree's servant, wearing her prison shift belted with dark cloth.
Even the colored prisoners knew about Cousin Molly. They knew that Convict Sallie Kirkpatrick shared Cousin Molly's food parcels with other female prisoners. When Tyree intercepted Sallie and reproved her, and Sallie threw her head back, proud and defiant, the coloreds shook their heads: even with Mistress Semple on your side, it didn't do to cross Mr. Tyree.
Cousin Molly dismounted from the barouche: a round, respectable women dressed entirely in brown. Her smile was below freezing.
“You'll pardon me, madam,” Tyree met her, “if I cannot find these circumstances amusing.”
Cousin Molly's bright blue eyes narrowed down to slits, her lips tightened, and she grew several inches taller than her statutory five feet two.
“Nor do I, Acting Keeper Tyree. Camp Winder's beds are full, badly wounded men lie on the floor in rows, the surgeons operate until they drop in their tracks, I haven't slept in seventy-two hours, and you delay me. You have seen Governor Letcher's order. Must I interrupt the governor for another?”
“But madam, nursing is not respectable work.”
“Do you presume that I am not respectable, Acting Keeper Tyree? Who are your people?”
“No, no, you misunderstand.” The keeper ran his hand over his hair. “Mrs. Kirkpatrick . . .”
“Are you concerned for Mrs. Kirkpatrick's respectability? In her circumstances? Acting Keeper Tyree, you are pleased to thwart me. I assure you such is not in your best interests.”
A bitter smile fastened itself to Tyree's mouth. “I am awfully pleased to know that you have my welfare in mind, ma'am. For my own trivial purposes, I shall require a receipt for Convict Kirkpatrick.”
“Of course,” Cousin Molly said indifferently. The acting keeper retreated into the prisoners' parlor, opened and slammed drawers.
Ignoring his clatter, Cousin Molly turned to Sallie. “Our victories, child, use us up more than our defeats.” She unfolded a handkerchief and blew her nose. “I am not certain I do you a service employing you. Many who volunteer to assist at Camp Winder cannot stomach the work.”
“I am of no use in this place,” Sallie said simply. “I cannot promise that I will be equal to the task, but I am willing to try.”
When Tyree proffered his receipt, Cousin Molly signed it carelessly, without reading.
“And Alexander . . . ?” Sallie looked at the older woman.
“Alexander is thrown upon his own resources, my dear. I pray he will make the best of them. Child, time is of the essence. You will be outfitted from my wardrobe. Good day, Mr. Tyree.”
Every eye in the prison yard yearned after them.
As the barouche clattered out of the yard, Cousin Molly chattered breathlessly. “What a sullen fellow! Perhaps his post makes him so. Your new clothing, dear, will not gladden your girlish heart, for we Camp Winder matrons are garbed in dowdy, uncomfortable brown. Your garments will be warmer than you might like, and you must keep them buttoned up to the neck. You will be spared hoops. There are Confederate prigsâthough not one is a Confederate surgeonâwho would dispense with our services.”
Sallie's head was whirling, and though she heard words embedded in Cousin Molly's chatterâ“brown,” “neck,” “surgeons”âtheir meanings were lost. She understood that her life had changed again and that she would be asked to do tasks other women found repellent. She'd grown accustomed to the prison's smoky sour stench, and now when fresh air hit her lungs it was almost painful, like a draught of too chilly spring water.
At Cousin Molly's fine house on Broad Street, Sallie changed her garb under the watchful eyes of an elderly servant, who picked up her prison dress with reluctance.
“Do be careful,” Sallie said cheerfully. “You'll not find my lice agreeable companions.”
Early in the war, wounded soldiers were segregated by state and rankâTennessee officers to Chimborazo Hospital, Virginia privates to Camp Winderâbut as the number of wounded swelled, many nice distinctions were discarded and families seeking their son or father or brother made a melancholy tour from one hospital to another.
Chimborazo was the largestâsome said it was the largest hospital in the world. Camp Winder, under Chief Surgeon Lane, was built to accept Chimborazo's overflow, and when Winder could take no more, wounded men were placed in tobacco warehouses and private homes.
“I do not know how many wounded soldiers are in Richmond,” Cousin Molly confessed tiredly. “When melancholy overcomes me, I fear we will fight until every young man in the South comes under the surgeon's knife.”
Camp Winder was a rectangle of rough pine buildings on Richmond's north side. Water tanks towered above its whitewashed buildings. Within its perimeter fence, behind the wards, plump shorthorn cows grazed.
“Our own bakery, gardens, dairy; we are a complete island. Chief Surgeon Lane is a most dedicated organizer.”
Although Malvern Hill had been fought three days ago, wounded men were still coming into Richmond, many already stinking with infections that would kill them. A very young boy with a blood-soaked bandage around his forehead made a deep bow as the women passed through Winder's gate, and Sallie drew breath.
The ward had beds along both walls and at one end a small storeroom, which had been converted, at Cousin Molly's instructions, for matrons' use. It contained a camp bed, a chest (which doubled as a table), and one window (curtained).
Three brown-clad matrons came to Cousin Molly's elbow seeking instructions, passing on surgeon's orders, asking advice. Cousin Molly dispatched the pair to assist surgeons and requested the third stay on the ward. “That Kentucky boy is dying,” she noted matter-of-factly. “See if he wishes a letter written home.”
By now, the sun had got up in the sky. The ward stank of rot and the slightly sweeter smell of flesh trying to mend itself. The flies were everywhere, thickest on the bloody rags and lint bandages heaped beside the door. “Remove those,” Cousin Molly told Sallie. “Throw them into the ravine.”
The flies were angry at being disturbed and buzzed Sallie's face. The rags reeked of old blood and pus and feces and corruption. Sallie made a sack of a torn blanket and slung it over her back like a peddler.
The ravine was a deep ditch from the hospital grounds to the James which the water towers flushed every other day. The ditch was full of objects Sallie's eyes didn't care to identify. Some of the objects shimmered with maggots.
Men sat or lay on stretchers until convalescents carried them in to the surgeons.
“Must I lose my leg, sir?”
“It is your leg or your life.”
The matron presses the chloroform-soaked rag over the man's nose and mouth until his eyes roll back, the surgeon wipes his bloody saw on his apron front, and the saw bites and the hot stink of cutting bone, rick, rick, rick, and the fine-toothed saw jerks through, and the surgeon's swift knife finishes the job. The flap is sutured over the stump, the limb tossed into the tub of unnecessary human accouterments. Some limbs are small, some long, some short, some plump, several have been so shattered it is impossible to guess at their original shape or whether they were once arms or legs. The surgeon wipes his forehead with the back of his forearm. “How many more?” he asks.
When he is told there are another fifty waiting outside he closes his eyes for a moment and sways.
Cousin Molly touches Sallie's arm. “Child, you said you wished to be useful.”
“Yes, ma'am,” Sallie says. “It is not what I expected, that's all.”
“It will soon seem like all the world.”