Authors: Lauren Weisberger
It was over. It was over for good.
one year later â¦
Andy watched from the dining room as her mother worked her way down the kitchen counter, unwrapping platters of fruit and crudités, cookies and bite-size wrap sandwiches, taking a few moments to rearrange the morsels prettily on each tray. In the last two days, people and platters had streamed through Andy's childhood home in a near-constant flow, and although there were so many others who were willing to do it â friends, cousins, Jill, and of course, Andy â Mrs Sachs insisted on doing all the shiva preparation herself. She claimed it took her mind off her mother, off the last few horrible months of home hospital beds and oxygen tanks and ever-increasing amounts of morphine. They were all relieved the old woman's suffering was over, but Andy could barely believe her feisty, foul-mouthed grandmother was gone.
She was just about to join her mother in the kitchen when she saw Charles walk in, take a look around to make sure they were alone, and wrap her mother in a bear hug from behind. He whispered something in her ear and Andy smiled at the two of them. Her mother was right: Charles was a lovely man â kind, soft-spoken, sensitive, and affectionate â and Andy was thrilled they had found each other. They'd only been dating six months or so, but according to her mother, you didn't need years to get to know someone in your sixties: it either worked or it didn't, and this relationship had been smooth and easy from day one. Already they were talking about selling the Connecticut house and buying an apartment together in the city, and now that Andy's grandmother no longer needed round-the-clock care, Andy imagined they'd move quickly.
âHe seems great,' Jill said as she walked in the room and followed Andy's gaze. She grabbed a carrot stick and began to chomp. âI'm really happy for her.'
âMe too. She's been alone a long time. She deserves it.'
There was a beat of silence as Jill weighed whether or not to say what she was thinking and Andy mentally willed her not to. No such luck.
âYou deserve someone too, you know.'
âMom and Dad got divorced almost a decade ago. I've been â¦' Andy still couldn't say
divorced
in relation to herself; it sounded too strange, too foreign. âMax and I have only been apart for a year. I have Clem and my work and all of you. I'm not in any rush.'
Jill poured two plastic cups of Diet Coke and handed one to Andy. âI'm not saying you should rush into anything. Just that it wouldn't kill you to go out on a date. A little fun, nothing more.'
Andy laughed. âA date?' The word sounded so quaint, a throwback to a different lifetime. âMy world is playdates and ear infections and twos-program applications and ballet-shoe fittings and hiding vegetables in smoothies. I don't know what a date would look like, but I'm guessing it wouldn't include any of those things.'
âNo, of course it wouldn't. You might actually have to wear something other than yoga pants, and you'd definitely have to talk about something besides the benefits of Annie's Cheddar Bunnies over conventional Goldfish, but news flash: you can do it. Your daughter spends two nights a week at her father's, you've completely lost all your baby weight, and with a few hours invested in getting a decent haircut and maybe a dress or two, you could be right back out there. For Christ's sake, Andy, you're only thirty-four. Your life is hardly over.'
âOf course my life isn't over. It's just that I'm perfectly happy with the way things are. What's so hard to understand about that?'
Jill sighed. âYou sound just like Mom did all those years before she met Charles.'
Lily walked into the room, holding her frail grandmother's arm and helping her into a seat. Jill handed Ruth a cup of Diet Coke, but her grandmother asked if she could have some decaf instead. Lily agreed, but Jill motioned for her to sit. âI was just on my way to brew a new pot. Sit and talk some sense into my sister. Andy and I were just discussing that it's high time her nun days were over.'
âWow,' Lily said, raising her eyebrows at Jill. âYou actually went there.'
âYeah, I did. If we can't tell her, who can?'
Andy waved her hands as though trying to flag down a cab. âHello? Does anyone realize I'm actually sitting right here?'
Jill left for the kitchen.
âClem's at Max's this weekend?' Lily asked.
Andy nodded. âI dropped her off uptown on my way out of the city. She ran shrieking, “
Daddy! Daddy! Daddy!
” the second the cab pulled up to the curb and she spotted him. Literally took off and flew into his arms without so much as a glance backward.' Andy shook her head and smiled ruefully. âThey know how to make you feel great.'
âTell me about it. Yesterday when we took the boys into the city, Bear asked why a man was sleeping on the street. We tried to explain that's why it's important to go to school and study hard, so you can grow up and get a good job. Brainwashing the kid already, right? So Bear asks what Daddy does as a job, and we explain that he owns the yoga studio and teaches classes and teaches other teachers. So what does Bear say? “Well, when I grow up, I want to stay home and wear my pajamas all day, just like Mommy.”'
Andy laughed. âYou're lying.'
âI'm not. I have a BA from Brown, a master's from Columbia, and I'm working toward a PhD, and my son thinks I watch Bravo all day long.'
âYou'll set him straight. One day.'
âYeah, in all my free time.'
Andy looked at her friend. âMeaning?'
Lily diverted her eyes.
âLily! Spill it.'
âWell, there are sort of two things I think you should know.'
âI'm waiting.'
âOne is, I'm pregnant. The second is that Alex'
âMommy! Skye is pulling my hair and it hurts! He bit me! And he has a gross booger on his nose!' Bear materialized seemingly out of nowhere, shrieking a litany of complaints about his little brother, and it took all of Andy's energy not to strangle him into silence. Lily was pregnant? That alone was near impossible to fathom, but Alex
what
? Was stopping by to give Andy his condolences? Had been diagnosed with something hideous and terminal? Had moved once and for all to Africa or the Middle East and was planning never to return? And then it hit her. The only obvious answer.
âHe finally got married, didn't he?' Andy said, shaking her head. âOf course, that's it.'
Lily glanced at her, but Bear's cries had escalated, and Skye had toddled in, also in tears.
âNot that I wouldn't be happy for him under normal circumstances â I would â but I can't stand the thought of him married to that lying, cheating bitch. What is it with the two of us? Some sort of weird, shared inexplicable draw to fall in love with people who hurt and betray us. Why is that? Alex and I had our problems, no doubt, but trust wasn't one of them. Or does it really have nothing to do with us â it's just that everyone cheats on everyone these days, it's what the cool kids do, and any expectation otherwise is old-fashioned or unreasonable?' Andy took a deep breath and shook her head. âHow old do I sound?'
âAndy' Lily said, starting to speak, but Bear threw himself in her lap and almost knocked her off the chair.
âMommy!
I want to go home!
'
Andy eyed Lily's small but undeniable bump. She had so many questions, and yet her mind kept ricocheting back to Alex.
Bodhi appeared in the dining room and Lily practically threw both boys at him. She gave him the Look, the one with the laser-focused glare and the slightly raised eyebrows and the pinched mouth that said,
You're on kid duty and yet here they are, screaming and snot-covered and yelling for me. Why can't I have a conversation with my friend for ten uninterrupted minutes? Is that really too much to ask?
that every mother perfected within the first week of her firstborn's life.
He gathered them up with promises of Hershey's Kisses and sippy cups of milk, and for just a moment Andy missed Clementine. Being with her alone all week was difficult, and usually Andy loved Tuesday and Friday nights, when Clem was with Max, but seeing Lily's and Jill's boys made her want to hug her daughter close. She had been planning to stay in Connecticut that night and most of the next day, but maybe now she'd head back to the city first thing in the morning â¦
âI can barely believe you're pregnant again! When did this happen? Was it planned?'
Lily laughed. âWe weren't trying, but we weren't
not
trying.'
âAh, my favorite.' Andy couldn't help but invoke Olive. âNot not-trying is trying.'
âWell, regardless, we were pretty shocked. Skye and his sister will be eighteen months apart. I'm almost fifteen weeks already, but I was waiting to tell you until we knew the gender. A girl! Can you believe it?'
âI'm sure boys are great too â people swear they are â but there is nothing on earth as wonderful as a daughter. Nothing.'
Lily beamed.
Andy reached across the table and squeezed her friend's hand. âI'm so happy for you guys. If someone would've looked into a crystal ball that year we lived together in New York and told you that one day you'd be married to a yoga instructor, living in Colorado with three kids who can ski before they walk, would you have ever believed them?' Andy didn't say what else she was thinking: would she have ever believed she'd have founded, grown, and sold a successful magazine, gotten married and divorced, and learned how to be a single mom to an admittedly sweet and easy toddler, all by the time she was thirty-five? It was light years from what she'd expected.
âAlex. He's not married, Andy. It's just the opposite. He broke up with Sophie.' Lily shook her head. âOr she broke up with him, I'm really not sure how it went down, but they're definitely not together.'
Andy leaned forward. âHow do you know?'
âHe called me when he was out west last week.'
âHe
called
you?'
âIs that so weird? He had a week off work and was traveling through Denver on his way to ski with friends in Vail. I met him for coffee at a place near the airport.'
âSkiing with
friends
?'
âAndy! I didn't ask for addresses and social security numbers of his entire group, but he made it clear that there wasn't anyone along with whom he was romantically involved. Is that what you wanted to know?'
Andy waved. âOf course not. I'm just happy to hear, for his sake, that he's not with
her.
How do you know they broke up?'
âHe made it a point to tell me. Said he moved out about six months ago and lives in Park Slope now. Claimed he was dating around but wasn't interested in anything serious. He was just very Alex, you know?'
âHow'd he look?'
Lily laughed. âLike himself. Adorable. Sweet as could be. He brought books for the boys. Said we should keep in better touch and to call the next time we're in the city. The usual.'
âWell, I'm relieved for him,' Andy said. âI'm sure it wasn't easy, but it had to be a lot easier than getting married â¦'
âI didn't tell him anything about you,' Lily said, looking guilty. âDid you want me to? I wasn't sure.'
Andy had wondered but hadn't wanted to ask. She thought about this for a moment and decided it was better having Alex think she was still happily married and settled into her new life. Not that she would allow herself to consider for a single second that there might still be something between them â that even all these years later, he might still get that same jolt when they bumped into each other or heard her name â because in all likelihood it wasn't reality.
She still couldn't help but ask. âDid he mention me at all? Ask anything about me?'
Lily looked at her hands. âNo. But I'm sure he wanted to. You're always the big white elephant in the room.'
âThanks, Lil. You always know just what to say.' Andy forced herself to smile.
Andy glanced up and saw that Lily was staring at her.
âWhat? Why are you looking at me like that?'
âYou still love him, don't you?' Lily asked in a whisper, as though her grandmother, the only other person in the room, would be desperate to hear this juicy conversation.
âI think I'll always love him,' Andy said truthfully. âHe's Alex, you know? But that's all in the past.'
Lily was silent. Andy waited for her friend to say something, but Lily remained quiet.
âAnd Alex aside, I can't imagine being close to anyone. Not right now. I know it's been a year, but the ⦠whole thing still feels so fresh. I'm glad Max and I are finally in a good place, at least for Clem's sake. Barbara's so thrilled that Max is free to date more “appropriate women” that she's practically become a new person. I never thought I'd say it, but she's crazy about Clementine and is on her way to becoming a halfway decent grandmother. All the mayhem of the last year has finally settled down. Quieted. I don't want to date anyone. Maybe one day, but not now.'
Again Lily gave her that look; Andy knew she was lying to her friend â or at least not telling her the whole truth â and Lily knew it, too. Of course she'd begun to wonder if she would ever meet someone, ever get dressed up for a date or look forward to a long weekend away with a man. She wondered if she would ever share the joys and pains of parenting, have someone to confide in, to cook dinner with, and most of all, she wondered if she would ever give Clem a brother or a sister. She knew the chances of all that were good, if she wanted it, although it might look different now: a future boyfriend would probably be divorced himself, and most likely a father. What single guy in this thirties would choose a mother and a toddler when he could start a family of his own with a much younger girl? But that was okay, too. When she was ready, Andy would join a single-parents' group or list herself on Match.com or accept one of the few invitations to coffee she'd received from single dads she'd met at the Writer's Space â the coworking space she'd joined â or on the playground. And hopefully one day she'd hit it off with one of them, and instead of planning a big white wedding or an elaborate Hawaiian honeymoon or decorating their very first shared apartment, they would navigate the introductions and the schedules of their children, their exes, the blending of two completely separate lives. It would be different, but it could be wonderful in its own way. Andy smiled at the thought.