Lethal Legacy: A Novel (Guardians of Justice) (2 page)

Okay. That was odd.

“I’ll tell you what. Why don’t you give me a day or two to review the case file? Then I’ll get back in touch and we can discuss this.”

The further flattening of her lips told him she wasn’t pleased with the delay.

“Is there someone else who might be able to give this more immediate attention?”

Cole tapped his pen against the lined tablet in front of him. He was tempted to tell her none of the detectives were sitting around twiddling their thumbs. That they all had active cases that demanded immediate attention. That a few days wouldn’t make any difference to her father.

But Alison was always on his case about his lack of tact. So he took a deep breath and worded his response with care.

“Ms. Warren, please understand that I’m taking this very seriously. But with Detective Carlson on vacation, I need some time to go over the facts of the case and get a handle on how the resolution was reached. Any other detective would do the same. However, if you prefer, I’d be happy to ask my sergeant to assign someone else to assist you.”

She pinned him with an appraising gaze. He met it without blinking. Finally, she snapped her purse shut and stood. He rose too.

“All right. I’ll wait to hear from you. Tomorrow, I hope.”

“As soon as possible.”

The sudden narrowing of her eyes told him his hedge hadn’t gotten past her.

“Look, Detective, I realize this isn’t your top priority, like it is for me. But I knew my father for thirty-three years. I talked to him every day. I saw him go through some bad times, including the death of my mother, and he was a survivor. A man of strength and faith, who turned to God—not to pills or carbon monoxide—when times were tough. I can’t dispute the facts of your investigation, but I do dispute the conclusion. And I’m convinced this document”—she jabbed at the packing slip on the table—“proves there’s more to this than was discovered the first time around.”

He regarded her for a long moment. If John Warren had indeed been a man of strength, his daughter had inherited that attribute in spades. Her voice rang with conviction, and the resolve in her eyes was formidable.

“I have a feeling your father would be proud of you.”

Cole wasn’t sure where that had come from. Or why he’d spoken it. But the comment seemed to disarm her. The rigid line of her shoulders eased a tiny bit, and the angular tautness of her face softened.

“He was a good man.” The soft, grief-laced words tugged at his heart. “He deserves to rest in peace. That’s why I want to get to the truth. Why I want to be certain justice is served.”

“That’s what we want too.” Cole picked up the packing slip. “If we’ve missed anything, I can promise you we’ll do our best to make it right. Let me walk you out.”

He followed her back down the hall, wishing he could give her the resolution she wanted. Verify her father hadn’t chosen to take his own life. But the St. Louis County Crimes Against Persons detectives were pros. It was unlikely he’d find any mistakes. Still, the tulips were an anomaly. And if they had messed up, he wasn’t going to pretend they hadn’t. He’d entered this business to fight for justice, not cover up the truth.

Kelly stopped at the door to the reception area and held out her hand. “Thank you for your time.”

Though her shoulders were squared and her gaze steady, a slight tremor ran through her cold fingers as he gave them a squeeze.

“I’ll be in touch.”

With a nod, she turned and walked toward the exit.

Cole watched her go, his gaze lingering on the russet waves cascading down the back of a silky blouse that was tucked into the waist of her slim black slacks.

Too bad he hadn’t had someone like her to take to Jake’s wedding.

“Nice.”

At the comment close to his ear, Cole jerked around. Mitch was checking out Kelly over his shoulder.

Annoyed, Cole shut the door to the reception area, edging his colleague back none too gently with his shoulder. “Didn’t you just get engaged? To my sister?”

Mitch grinned. “Appreciating beauty isn’t the same as drooling over it.”

“I wasn’t drooling.” He hoped. “Besides, I don’t mix business and pleasure.”

“You could have fooled me. You were sure enjoying the view. So who is she?”

“Her father died five months ago. She’s not buying our suicide verdict. It was Alan’s case.” Cole started down the hall.

“I remember that one. From what I heard, it was cut and dried.”

Cole stopped short, and Mitch almost ran into him. “How come
I
don’t remember it?”

“You were tied up with that high-profile missing person case.”

“Oh yeah.” He’d been immersed in it for two solid weeks—and the ending hadn’t been happy.

“What did the daughter want?”

“She has some new evidence she thinks supports her position that it was murder.” Cole started toward his office again. Mitch fell in beside him.

“Does it?”

“It raises a few questions. But I need to look over the case notes.”

“Maybe you’ll find an excuse to pay her a visit.”

Cole stopped at the door to the office he shared with several other detectives and squinted at his friend. “I just told you. I don’t mix business and pleasure.”

“The evidence suggests otherwise—but I’ll let it pass.” Mitch grinned and lifted a white sack bearing the logo of a familiar fast-food chain. “I brought you a burger anyway. Consider it a peace offering.”

As he handed it over, Mitch pulled his phone off his belt and checked caller ID. “No rest for the weary. Enjoy.” Putting the phone to his ear, he set off down the hall.

The aroma of the burger wafting up from the bag set off a rumbling in Cole’s stomach, and he headed for his desk. Funny. All of a sudden, he was hungry.

Digging into the loaded quarter pounder, he wolfed down half of it before pausing to take a drink from the almost-empty can he’d left on his desk. The soda was warm, but at least it was wet.

His hunger somewhat assuaged, Cole scooted in front of the computer and pulled up the case file for John Warren. Might as well take a look while he finished his lunch.

A quick skim gave him the basics. Warren, a retired accountant, had been found in his garage after Kelly, who was out of town, couldn’t reach him and called a neighbor to check on him. Cause of death—carbon monoxide poisoning. There were no other injuries, no sign of a struggle. Toxicity tests had revealed zolpidem and an elevated blood alcohol level.

Alan’s investigation had backed up those findings. An empty beer can and a small bottle containing generic Ambien tablets had been found near the body, which had been slumped against the wall of the garage, close to the tailpipe. Three more beer cans had been found in the trash in the kitchen. At his daughter’s insistence, Alan had talked with a number of her father’s acquaintances, including the minister at the church the two of them had attended every Sunday, and all had expressed shock and disbelief at the man’s actions. He had not been under psychiatric care.

But he
had
been diagnosed recently with lung cancer and was facing surgery, followed by radiation and chemotherapy. Even his daughter had admitted he’d seemed more quiet—even a little down—in the last weeks of his life.

Cole couldn’t refute Alan’s conclusion. All the evidence pointed to suicide. At sixty-nine, John Warren could have decided it wasn’t worth all the pain and effort to fight a cancer that was very hard to beat.

Yet he’d written an upbeat note to his daughter the day before he died, talking about plans for the future.

Kelly was right.

It didn’t compute.

Still, it was possible he’d ordered the generic Ambien to have on hand in case things got really bad, and then, in a moment of despondency, decided to pack it in.

Cole tapped a finger on the shipping slip she’d left, then picked up the other half of his burger and reread the case summary as he finished off Mitch’s peace offering. He had two witnesses to track down this afternoon on a hit-and-run case, and he didn’t have the time to delve into the details of the Warren file now. He’d get it done, though. Later today, or tomorrow.

But based on his cursory review, he didn’t expect to find any irregularities. He’d worked dozens of cases with Alan, and his colleague wasn’t the kind of detective who missed things.

If all the i’s were dotted and the t’s crossed, however, Kelly Warren was going to be very, very disappointed.

And he didn’t look forward to giving her the bad news.

Twenty-eight hours later, as Cole walked up the stone path to the front door of Kelly Warren’s bungalow, he told himself compassion and charity had prompted this personal visit. That he wanted to soften the blow by delivering his news in person.

But that motive couldn’t account for the sudden acceleration in his pulse as he pressed her doorbell. Nor could it explain his quick shave in the men’s room at the office. Or his sudden urge to straighten his tie and settle his coat more evenly on his shoulders.

And no way would compassion or charity produce a surge of adrenaline at the sound of the lock being turned. Or shut down his lungs when Kelly opened the door and looked at him with those big green eyes, her hair tumbling around her shoulders.

“Detective Taylor! This is a surprise.”

He saw the hope flare in her eyes—and felt like a heel.

“I thought it might be better if we talked in person. May I come in?”

“Yes, of course.” She gestured toward the living room. “Have a seat.”

He chose a blue wingback chair beside her fireplace. She perched on the edge of the cream-colored couch.

“Looks like I interrupted you.” He gestured to the paint-spattered rag wadded in her fingers.

She glanced down, as if she’d forgotten she was holding it, then tossed the cloth on the glass-topped coffee table, creating the only clutter in the immaculate room. “No. I was about to call it a day.” She wiped her palms down her oversized, paint-streaked shirt and rubbed at a stubborn green stain on the back of her right hand. “Sorry. I’d have cleaned up if I’d known you were coming. I’m a commercial artist, and things can get a bit messy in the studio.”

“Watercolors, right? Magazine illustrations, children’s books, greeting cards . . . I’m impressed.”

She tipped her head. “So am I. Can I assume you found all that information in my father’s case file?”

“Yes. Detective Carlson was very thorough.”

At his definitive tone—and its implication—she stiffened. “You’re telling me my new piece of evidence isn’t enough to reopen the case, aren’t you?”

The chill in her voice didn’t quite disguise the disappointment—and desperation—underneath.

Leaning forward, he rested his elbows on the arms of the chair and clasped his hands, trying for a professional but empathetic tone. “The note does raise questions, but after a careful review of the file, I found nothing to suggest any stones were left unturned. As far as I could tell, Detective Carlson followed up on every piece of information he had and discovered nothing to suggest any other conclusion.”

Kelly stood and paced to the end of the room, her back to him, the rigid line of her shoulders communicating her distress.

When the silence lengthened, he tried again.

“Ms. Warren, there was definite evidence of suicide. Your father overdosed on a high-powered sleeping pill. He drank alcohol, which compounded the effect. He was found in a closed garage next to the tailpipe of a car that had keys in the ignition and an empty gas tank. There was no sign of a struggle or foul play. The Crime Scene Unit found no fingerprints or trace evidence. The neighbors saw nothing irregular. The only thing missing was a farewell letter, but less than 25 percent of people who take their life leave a final message.”

“Then how do you explain the note he wrote the day before he died?”

She didn’t have to turn around for him to tell she was fighting to hang on to her control. He could hear it in the quiver in her voice.

“I can’t.”

“Doesn’t it suggest foul play to you?” She swung toward him, distress etching her features. “And why would he take sleeping pills and drink alcohol? If he wanted to kill himself, he could have just gone to the garage and turned on the car.”

“Maybe the drugs and booze made it easier to take that final step.”

Her eyes narrowed. “My dad was a courageous man, Detective.
If
he had decided to do something that drastic, he wouldn’t have sugarcoated it. Besides, I checked with his doctor. He didn’t have a prescription for Ambien. I also looked at his credit card bills to see if he’d ordered it from one of those overseas drug places that don’t require a doctor’s script. Nothing. So where did he get it?”

“There are domestic black market sources for drugs of every kind.”

She sucked in a breath, as if he’d slapped her. “My dad wasn’t into anything underhanded. If he’d wanted sleeping pills, he’d have asked his doctor.” She pinned him with a fierce look. “Someone was targeting my father, Detective.”

“But who would do that? And why?”

“Detective Carlson asked me the same question. I don’t know. Isn’t it your job to figure that out?”

“Yes, but we can only work with the clues we have. According to the case notes, you yourself said your father had no enemies.”

“None that I
know
of.”

“Detective Carlson interviewed all the people you suggested. They didn’t offer any leads, either.”

“Nor did they believe my father would have committed suicide.”

“People under pressure can do uncharacteristic things, Ms. Warren.” He gentled his voice. “And a lung cancer diagnosis is very tough. The mortality rate is extremely high. One of my uncles died of that disease. It wasn’t pretty.”

Her demeanor softened, and a flicker of sympathy warmed her eyes. “I’m sorry for your loss. And I do hear what you’re saying. Even though the cancer was only stage one, we both knew he was in for a tough fight. But he
was
a fighter. He was also a man of rock-solid faith who believed in the sanctity of life and always put his trust in the Lord. Suicide wasn’t an option he’d consider.”

If he ever got into trouble, Cole hoped he’d be lucky enough to have a Kelly Warren in his corner. She had the tenacity of a bulldog when it came to defending someone she loved.

Cole rose, planted one fist on his hip, and raked his fingers through his hair. When he’d come here today, he’d planned to let her down easy. To suggest her father had simply hidden his despair from her. Remind her that not everyone who committed suicide posted warning signs.

But the strength of her conviction made him vacillate. “I can see I’m not convincing you.”

“I knew my father, Detective Taylor.” She lifted her chin, in a dig-in-her-heels gesture he was coming to recognize. “Short of finding a note in his own hand, I won’t believe he took his life. Even then I’d have doubts.”

“In your statement in the case file, you admitted he seemed a bit down in the last weeks of his life.”

“No!” Her eyes flashed, and her nostrils flared. “I never used that word. He was a little . . . contemplative, maybe. Quieter. Who wouldn’t be, after hearing a diagnosis like that? But he was not depressed.”

Her vehemence was persuasive. Drawing a breath, Cole capitulated. “Okay. Let me do this. I’ll talk to Detective Carlson after he returns. The two of us will review the case, maybe pull in a few more people to get some fresh thinking. Have you been through all of your father’s things?”

“No. I’m getting ready to put his house on the market, but I hadn’t planned to sort through everything until I officially listed it with the real estate agent.” She linked her fingers and looked down at her clasped hands. “It’s very hard for me to . . . to be there right now.”

“I can understand that. But there’s a chance you might find something helpful that only you would recognize as significant. And if you do, I promise you we’ll follow up on it.”

She raised her chin, and a faint glimmer of hope reignited in her eyes. “So you’re not closing the door on this?”

“No. If there’s been a miscarriage of justice, we’re as interested in fixing it as you are.”

“Okay. I’ll start going through his things.” She exhaled, and her taut posture eased. “Thank you.”

“I’m just doing my job. And now I’ll let you get back to yours.”

He crossed the room toward the door, turning when he reached it. She’d followed him partway, and the late-afternoon sunlight backlit her as it slanted through the window, burnishing her russet hair and isolating her slender form in a corona of light. And she was, indeed, isolated. As he’d learned from the case file, she had no family left. Her mother had died when she was twelve, and there were no siblings.

That had to be tough. All his life, Cole had been surrounded by love. He still had his mother, and while he might complain that Alison was too independent for her own good and Jake took his big-brother role too seriously, he knew he could count on them, no matter what. That in a time of crisis, they’d both be by his side.

Kelly Warren didn’t have that kind of support system.

And being strong and capable and determined didn’t compensate for that lack.

For a fleeting moment, he was overcome by a powerful urge to take her hand. Link his fingers with hers and assure her she wasn’t alone. That if she needed help of any kind—case-related or not—he’d provide it.

But that was crazy. As he’d told Mitch yesterday, he never mixed business and pleasure—and he didn’t intend to start now.

Grasping the handle, Cole pulled the door open and stepped onto the small front porch. “I’ll be in touch, Ms. Warren.”

With that, he strode down the walk toward his car without looking back.

Because if he did, if he saw her solitary figure silhouetted in the doorway, he was afraid the urge to take a personal interest in this case would resurface.

And he was even more afraid that this time he wouldn’t be able to resist.

At the sudden ring of her cell phone in the oppressive quiet of her father’s house, Kelly dropped the file folder she’d just retrieved from his desk drawer and watched in dismay as the contents flew in all directions and wafted down to the carpet.

Muttering in disgust, she rose from her chair, hopscotched over the cascade of papers, and trotted toward the kitchen. By the time her fingers closed over her phone in the depths of her purse, it was on the third ring. She jabbed at the talk button, not bothering to check caller ID before saying hello.

“Hey, Kelly. It’s Lauren. I just had a great idea. Why don’t we dig our skates out of the closet and hit the rink?”

Kelly leaned a shoulder against the wall, surprised by her best friend’s suggestion. Although they’d met as sixteen-year-olds in a figure skating class dominated by kids half their age, these days their get-togethers were usually over lunch or coffee. “I haven’t skated in years.”

“Me neither, but I’m game to give it a try. If we could pick each other up off the ice as teenagers while our junior counterparts snickered behind our backs, we can do it again. And I bet we could still do three turns and waltz jumps. Now that fall is here, I’m in the mood for winter sports.”

Kelly stared out the window of her childhood home. Fall
had
arrived. In the almost two weeks since Detective Taylor had paid her a visit, the color on the three giant maples that dominated the backyard had gone from pretty to spectacular.

Her dad had loved their glorious autumn display.

The scene blurred, and Kelly turned away, blinking back tears. “I’m sure you have better things to do on a Saturday morning than risk breaking a leg at the rink. Go out with that gorgeous husband of yours. Or take the twins to the park on this sunny day. It might be your last chance before winter.” Although she tried to sound upbeat, Lauren wouldn’t be fooled by her too-bright tone. They knew each other too well.

“My family won’t miss me for an hour or two, and Shaun needs some quality one-on-one time with the kids. I already convinced him to take them to the Magic House.”

As Lauren talked, Kelly wandered back into her father’s office and surveyed the papers strewn on the floor. She’d been digging into every nook and cranny of the house, searching for something—anything—that might pique the interest of the police and give them a concrete lead to follow. A reason to reopen the case.

So far, she’d come up empty.

But she wasn’t yet ready to throw in the towel.

“I appreciate the offer, Lauren, but with two deadlines looming I haven’t been able to put in as much time as I’d like going through my dad’s stuff. I was planning to spend the morning here.”

“You’re there now?”

“Yes.”

“You want some company? I could pick up coffee along the way.”

Throat tightening, Kelly dropped into the desk chair. Lauren knew she and her father had met every Saturday for coffee—and that his death had left an aching void in that part of her week. “I stopped at the coffee shop for a takeout on my way here this morning. But thanks for being such a great friend.”

“Hey, I’m just looking for an excuse to get out of the house. If I hang around, I’ll have to clean bathrooms.”

“Why? Use the quiet time to take a bubble bath instead.”

“Ooh. Low blow. You know that’s one of my favorite indulgences.”

“And I bet you don’t get to enjoy it very often with two five-year-olds in the house. We’ll meet for coffee next Saturday. I promise.”

“Hmm.” A moment of silence passed. “I have to admit a warm bubble bath does sound better than a cold ice rink.”

“Go for it. I’ll call later in the week and set up a time for next Saturday.”