Authors: Charles McCarry
A few months after the rogue cops went to jail and Fats Corso went free on a hung jury, a reform mayor was elected, largely on the strength of promises to clean up the police force and put Corso behind bars. He immediately ordered Patrolman Gallagher's promotion to lieutenant over the heads of many senior men, an action that provided the new mayor with a front-page picture of the hero cop, but assured Gallagher of the undying hatred of most of the rest of the police force. As long as the reform mayor was in office, Gallagher was untouchable. Unfortunately, the mayor had been defeated for a second term.
Jack said, “Did Phil give you any details about what happened last night?”
“What little he remembers,” Teresa said. “He said he pulled into the school yard to drink coffee from his thermos. All of a sudden this girl raps on his window. She's got no clothes on except white tennis shoes.”
“He remembered that detail?”
“Wouldn't you? Phil puts down his coffee and gets out of the car. The girl runs away screaming. He thinks she's probably on drugs. Naturally he chases her. It's very dark in the school yard, and as he goes around the corner of the school somebody trips him.”
“Who?”
“Not the girl. She's way ahead of him, running like a deer.”
“And?”
“That's all he remembers, falling ass over teakettle.”
“He was knocked out by the fall?”
Teresa said, “Come on, Jack. How could he be? Somebody whacked him on the head.”
Her voice was firm and, with its hard-edged Ohio diction, absolutely clear. No tears, no sign of nervousness. Yet her face was a mask of desperation. A jury, Jack thought, would believe every word if she took off ten pounds.
Jack said, “Let me ask you this, Teresa. Do you believe what your husband has told you?”
“Every word.”
“Do you always believe every word he tells you?”
“No.” Teresa's intelligent blue eyes snapped with anger. “But let me ask
you
a question,” she said. “Do you believe a man who was smart enough to fool them all for two long years and then send them to jail like they deserved would be stupid enough to let himself be caught in a situation like this? Knowing what enemies he has? Knowing they've sworn to get him?”
“Not really,” Jack said. “I'm sorry if I upset you, butâ”
“It's not you I'm upset with,” Teresa said. “Now I ask you, will you take the case?”
For the moment, Jack did not answer. This was not because he had not made up his mind, but because he was already, in his mind, addressing the jury. He got up and looked out the window, as if pondering his decision.
“I have to tell you we have no money,” Teresa said to his back. “I mean, none whatsoever. No savings. All we have is Phil's paycheck. We rent. The car is eight years old. We've got three kids under school age and I just missed a period. They'll stop Phil's pay. God knows how much the bail will be.”
“Forget about money,” Jack said.
“What does that mean?”
“It means I'll take no fee and we'll find the money for expenses elsewhere. Put money out of your mind.”
“Then you'll do it?”
Jack was the picture of sincerity. He said, “I'll do my best for you, Teresa.”
Now tears did appear in Teresa's eyes. She wiped them away with the back of her hand.
Jack said, “Did Phil know when the preliminary hearing is going to be?”
“Tomorrow morning at ten,” Teresa said. “They slipped him too much dope for him to appear sooner.”
“I'll see you there,” Jack said. “Don't talk to the cops. Be nice to the media if they call, but don't discuss any of the details of the case or repeat anything Phil told you. Just say you know your husband is completely innocent of any wrongdoing and let it go at that. No accusations of a frame. No wops and cops. Count to ten before every word. Don't let them see anger. Let others be angry for you.”
“Who, for instance?” Teresa said.
“You'll be surprised,” Jack said. “Now go home to the kids, and I'll go talk to Phil. I'll see you tomorrow morning at the hearing.”
3
After Teresa left, Jack called a reporter friend who had been at the scene of the arrest and had written the lead story about it for his paper.
“One question about the Gallagher business,” Jack said. “Where did they find the girl's clothes?”
“Let me check,” said the reporter. After a moment he came back on the line. “In the girl's car,” he said. “Are you taking this case?”
“One more question. Did you happen to look at the knees of Gallagher's pants?”
“Before or after he put them back on?”
“After.”
“No, but I've got some pictures here.” He looked at the photos, Jack could hear him slapping them down on the desk one after the other. Finally he said, “Here it is. The pants were torn at the knees.”
“Like he fell down on pavement? If you blew the picture up, could you see if his knees are scraped?”
“Maybe. Are you taking this case?”
“Yes.”
“What's the gimmick?”
“Gimmick?” Jack said. “There's no gimmick. Phil Gallagher's an innocent man.”
The reporter said, “Sure he is. All the signs point that way. Especially the fact that he had a hard-on the size of a three-cell flashlight.”
“You have pictures of that?”
“This is a family newspaper. But that's what the other cops said.”
“âThat's what the other cops said,'” Jack repeated. He said, “Let me ask you a question, Glenn. Do you think an honest man like Phil Gallagher, a hero cop who has laid his life on the line for what's right, a guy who has powerful enemies, bad cops and notorious criminals who will stop at nothing, would be stupid enough to rape and sodomize a fifteen-year-old girl at gunpoint in the back of a police cruiser, on a public street, while under the influence of LSD? And if he did, that he'd still have it up after all that?”
“Good line, but the question is, will a jury believe Gallagher's enemies would be stupid enough to set him up in such a crude and obvious way? A lot of people would say the situation is so unbelievable that it can't be anything but the truth.”
“That contingency is not covered by the rules of evidence,” Jack said. “Juries know the truth when they hear it.”
“That must be why they fuck up as often as they do,” said the reporter. “They hear it so seldom. You're going to have to prove this guy's innocence, Jack. Reasonable doubt won't be enough.”
“My client will be acquitted because he is innocent,” Jack said.
“Oh yeah,” said the reporter, typing away. “Good luck, counselor.”
He hung up without saying goodbye. But he was pleased that Jack, a Harvard man, wanted to hear his opinion, and he was betting on Jack to win and hoping that the dirty cops who hated Gallagher would lose and be humiliated, and all that came through in the story that he wrote for the next day's edition.
Every news organization in town, plus the wire services, sent a reporter to Phil Gallagher's preliminary hearing. The defendant, now wearing county jail coveralls instead of his blue uniform, was an upright, handsome man, but he was disoriented by the drugs he had taken, and he had not shaved in two days. The day before, Jack had talked to him for about an hour but had learned little more than Teresa had told him. Gallagher remembered falling, remembered pain. His knees and hands were skinned like those of a child who has taken a fall on a sidewalk. He remembered not being able to breathe.
Jack showed no curiosity about this detail. He said, “When was the last time you fired your service revolver?”
“Last Monday, on the range.”
“When did you last clean it?”
“Same day.”
“Has it been out of the holster since?”
“No. Because of the kids I lock up my whole harness in the hall closet as soon as I get home.”
“What about the LSD?”
“The only thing I can figure,” Gallagher said, “is someone slipped it into my thermos.”
Jack said, “Like a police officer who had just confiscated LSD while making an arrest?”
The judge disallowed the question, but it was already on the record with the media, which was all that counted. Gallagher was charged with rape and forcible sodomy of a minor, resisting arrest, assault with a deadly weapon (the arresting officers said that the drug-crazed Gallagher had fired his pistol at them before they wrestled it away from him), and several other felonies and misdemeanors. If convicted on all counts he faced life in prison, almost certainly without possibility of parole. Gallagher pleaded not guilty to all charges. The prosecutor asked that bail be set at $200,000, but after a conference at the bench he did not press the point when the judge, at Jack's suggestion, released Gallagher without cash bail but confined him to his own home under what amounted to house arrest.
Jack asked for certain tests to be carried out on Gallagher by the crime lab unit of the Ohio State Patrol, and not by the local police. These included saliva, urine, and blood tests, close-up photographs of the accused's knees and elbows and palms and forearms, a wax test to determine if he had recently fired a pistol, and a complete medical examination, including physical and X-ray examination of the skull and a search for recent bruises or punctures of the skin on any other part of the body. He also asked that the court forthwith take custody of and place under seal all evidence so far gathered in the case, including any blood or urine samples already taken, and all of Gallagher's personal belongings, especially his uniform, his thermos, and his service revolver. The judge granted all these requests.
These unexplained requests made excellent copy and raised many questions in the minds of journalists; as Jack knew, their questions would soon become the questions of their readers and viewers.
Outside the courthouse, Jack told the cameras and microphones, “The truth will be discovered in this case. I promise you that. And the truth is, Phil Gallagher is a hero in war and peace who can stand on his own two feet in any court in the world. The truth is his friend just as the forces of darkness are his sworn enemies. Phil Gallagher is an innocent man. Phil Gallagher will be free. Justice will be done by the great state of Ohio and its people. That's all we have to say at this time, ladies and gentlemen.”
Phil Gallagher, standing beside him, shaved now and dressed in blue jeans and a winter jacket, said nothing. As Jack had earlier instructed him to do, he put an arm around his wife, as if afraid for her safety.
4
Morgan arrived home from our meeting in the Keystone Motel in time to watch Jack's statement on the noon television news. She was outraged. Jack had taken the case, devised his strategy, and splashed himself all over the media without consulting her.
In her agitation, short of breath, she looked out the window. Down below was Jack, bantering on the sidewalk with a little pack of pencil reporters who had walked back from the courthouse with him. As he talked, they scribbled in their notebooks. Because of her training, because of her true auspices and secret purposes, Morgan felt a pang of anxiety. She feared the press, feared its curiosity, its stupidity, its moralism. Below her window a perfectly relaxed Jack smiled, looked serious, joked, insinuated, charmed. She thought it was folly to let journalists come so close.
One of the reporters was a thin young female with a soft-lipped vulnerable face. Morgan knew the type: Ten years ago she had gone to demonstrations, a copy of Che's memoirs held title outward against her chest, not to fight for the cause but to meet boys and sniff tear gas from afar. To outward appearances, Jack paid no more attention to her than to the others, but Morgan knew Jack. His eyes were on this female, and she knew it. The interview ended. The reporters scattered. She stood on tiptoesâminiskirt, skinny legs, windblown hairâand hailed a cab. As she got in with flashing thighs, she gave Jack a shy smile.
“Jesus!” Morgan cried, closing the door of Jack's office behind the two of them.
Jack said, “Hi, Morg. How was your trip?”
Morgan said, “You're all over the goddamned television.”
She never swore among strangers anymore, but now she was swearing at Jack in the harsh half-whisper she used when talking to him in the office. Danny sat on the other side of a thin partition, working on his wills and trusts and torts.
Jack said, “Practicing law.”
“Oh, is that what you call this sideshow? You didn't think you should consult me on something as public as this?”
“You think lawyering is too public?” Jack said. “What do you think the future's going to be like?”
Morgan said, “This is now. You've exceeded your instructions. Behind my back. This is very serious, Jack.”
“Well, gee, Morgan,” Jack said. “I'm sorry I slipped the leash, but I wasn't exactly in control of the timing. You were on the road, no phone number. It was an opportunity to be seized.”
“A rapist cop? Take on the Mafia and the police?”
Jack said, “Wops and cops.”
Morgan said, “This is not a joke.”
“No, it's a breakthrough case. I'm going to defend this guy, and I'm going to get him off, and we're going to reap great benefits from that.”
“Jack, for Christ's sake. He's a pig. An enemy of the people. You're going to save a cop? A cop that raped a child?”
“Why not?”
“What planet are you living on? You can't fulfill this mission by fighting for the wrong side.”
Morgan was close to Jack, still whispering, waving her arms. Jack seldom touched her, but now he captured one of her flying hands and held it between both his own hands.
He said, “Morgan, honey, I'm sure you're absolutely right about everything and I've made a terrible mistake, but it's too late to do anything about it. No matter how badly I've fucked up the plan, I'vegot no choice now but to win this case. If I lose it, I'll never recover. So give me a break, okay?”