Authors: Melvyn Bragg
Then he was out of the enchantment of the university and into the swathes of semi-detached houses which shored up the city, home of legendary Oxford landladies like his own, Mrs Harries, who had told Roderick and himself on their arrival that she would âbrook no nonsense'.
Walking often lifted his mood. There was a settlement inside himself which came from steady solitary walking, a physical clarification that could exercise its way to an experience of happiness, a rhythm which could reach into a reservoir of calm. It encouraged thought. He could understand why Wordsworth liked to compose his poems while he was walking, the beat of the heart, the breath of the stride, the beat of the line.
By the time he put the latchkey in Mrs Harries's lock his anxiety was dissipated. He would find a way to meet Natasha again. Whatever she did, he would not let her go.
Their daughter wanted to know precisely when they had fallen in love. Joe wanted to find a dramatic moment. Something wild and romantic, to smile over and cherish, a gift to one who had suffered so much, a light in the dark inheritance. Most of all she needed something to smile over, to remember fondly, to see her parents as young, younger than she was now, in Oxford as she was, wonderfully in love then, everything finally worth it because of that. Joe was tempted. Julia had later described what he did in those early days as âa siege' and been quite funny about his brazen dogged unsnubbable visits, sometimes two, even three times a day. But that was not enough; that did not deliver what his daughter needed. Roderick could tell funny stories about covering for Joe when, as the love affair developed, he failed to turn up at his digs and Mrs Harries went âmadly puritanical'; but that was later. It was the beginning she longed to know about, the seed of it, as if so much that was to happen would be understood and could be forgiven if only their beginning could be claimed as pure and marvellous.
He would retell the story of first seeing her beside the fire. He would tell of his first visit to her mother's âartist's studio' and elaborate on its garret bohemianism, its thrilling resemblance to the studio of Modigliani which he'd seen in a French film. He would describe the first meal and even point out the little Spanish restaurant. But falling in love had happened without Joe recognising it. Perhaps he was still nervous after Rachel. Perhaps he wanted it so much that he dare not look it fully in the face. Or he took his cue from Natasha, who was distant in those early weeks, as if seeing him short-sightedly.
It was Natasha who controlled those days. Joe sensed that to crash in
would be to destroy whatever small connection had been made. She was so far away from him. Her eyes were sometimes kind, sometimes teasing, but mostly they were clouded in concentration on herself, straining to combat and vanquish the reality of her abandoned state. They were eyes that wanted no one to look at them because they feared the pain would be too clear and too shameful. Only later did he realise that he had seen her always in those early weeks through a veil of pain. They were eyes that could seem to want to be closed in peace and for ever and whose expression, when Joe did catch it unawares, sliced to his heart.
He had to wait some time until he knew for certain they were in love, he said, because of your mother. It was not the beginning that mattered. But she would not be deterred and he did his best. He could joke that this older, more distinguished and experienced Frenchwoman of a mixed European ancestry simply did not recognise the obstinate country courtesy of the Northern grammar-school arriviste. There was even some pleasure to be had as Joe played up the story of the rustic lump and the courtly lady and there was a truth there. But he knew it was a waste of time to look for truth in the beginning.
Many years later he made a radio programme called
Not One Truth.
There was religious truth through divine Revelation, the truth in the genes, Galileo's truth that the book of the universe was written in the language of mathematics, the truth of the historical method, Keats's âBeauty is truth, truth beauty', truth as relative, as analysis, as physics, as reason, as fiction and finally as unknowable. The routes to private truth were no less numerous. Yet a single answer was always longed for by those, like their daughter, who thought all life would be made understandable if only they could see and hold the one key.
The start of the love that came to lock together Natasha and Joe in a dance of life and then of death had to come from her. Joe was willing. At that stage in his life Joe was longing to fall in love, it was a condition that had recurred after Rachel and more than likely it was the lack of response from Natasha in those first weeks, her very emptiness, which spurred him on and gave him courage. Had there been resistance perhaps he would have fallen away quite soon as he had done during the past year on his few tentative forays back into the ring.
What he tried to tell their daughter was that Natasha had no wiles, she had no agenda, she had no English baggage of âplacing' him. When she gave him her attention she possibly saw a rather blurred young Englishman who had loomed out of an undergraduate Oxford she scarcely knew, and certainly not in young men such as Joe. There was from her no categorisation after the English fashion. In that undemanding ambience, Joe's confidence grew.
âWhat did Mum think of you when she first met you?' He had an answer to that yearning question only years later and even then he was sure that he knew it only in part. âNot much, at first,' he said. âShe thought of me very little at first and in the landscape of her mind I was way in the background, I was that small figure in the far distance only there to prove a point about perspective. I don't know if she thought of me at all then.'
From the beginning, Joe was eager to spend his energy on her as recklessly as a rich suitor lavishes gifts, but it was better than that, Natasha thought, because he did not give any signal she could recognise of looking for a reward. Now and then he attempted a kiss but proved too shy. Once or twice she caught him looking at the bed with a cautious hope, easily deflected. What he seemed to want was to look after her. Her only previous experience of that was deep in the unwanted past, two loving friends of her mother, ages ago in Provence.
But this was different. He was younger than her, she felt safe in that, as if the age gap was a sure layer of security, enabling her to control him, and yet he as it were âmothered' her. Even fussed over her. He took her to London to see
West Side Story
, recommended by James, a friend, a classical scholar who had become bored with Classics and left the university more than a year ago. They had continued to keep in contact. He bought the train tickets, pre-planned the day in some detail, went to a small Italian restaurant in Hampstead (also recommended by James, who lived there), clucked over their poor seats in the half-empty matinée and stealthily stole to better seats after ten minutes or so, using the pretending-to-go-to-the-Gents' manoeuvre. He even asked her if she ought not to be wearing a coat in this weather! She did not have a coat. She only just prevented him from buying some hideous garment in the January sales. She insisted on the adequacy of her old
black leather jacket and soon he took a liking to it. Very gradually his attentions, for they could be chastely and rather formally described in that word, began to touch feelings in her she had thought dead.
âYour mother trusted me, I think,' Joe said to their daughter, âthat was the heart of it. And she was right.' He paused and sought to engage with the look in his daughter's, her mother's, eyes. âAnd she was wrong.'
Joe introduced them with pride.
âDavid Green â David knows everything about who's who in Oxford; Natasha Prévost.' He had described her to David at length one evening in David's enviable Georgian rooms in St John's Street.
Joe had chosen the bar of the Randolph which David liked and which for Natasha was conveniently across the road from the Ashmolean. To Joe it suppurated exclusivity and made him uncomfortable but his determination was that David and Natasha know and like each other and if it had to be the bar of the Randolph then that was the price. It was not part of his experience, a clubby male bar casually crowded with the latest inheritors of Brideshead, informal in expensive sports jackets, cravats and cavalry twill trousers.
David watched him go across to the bar with what Natasha construed as a possessive amusement.
âHe is your marionette?' said Natasha.
âHe is yours,' said David.
She liked his boldness. David Green was rather large, constantly in movement as if physically uneasy but the movements seemed choreographed; his hair black and long, his face generous and expressive, mouth thin, vivid, rate of speech rapid, emphatic, punctuated by giggles which Natasha came to delight in.
âLet me say this at once,' said David, âwhile Joe's at the bar (I know you prefer Joseph). He described you perfectly but what I had not been prepared for was a certain hauteur which makes you rather nearer my class than his although I do know they order things differently in la France.' He pronounced âla France' in the French way.
Natasha was yet some time away from being fond of David and he had moved too fast on a first encounter.
â
Je m'excuse, mais
in France we do not fly to conclusions with so little proof.'
âAh!
La logique française.'
âNon. Good manners,
anglais.'
âTouché.'
âJoseph is very fond of you.' Natasha looked at him steadily. âHe is not difficult to impress.'
âHis unguardedness, which I love, and his defencelessness may be a little more seductive than you imagine.'
âSeductive? I don't think so.'
âI am probably wrong. I'm told I make rather a habit of it.'
âTold?'
âPeople!' He waved his hand at the early evening crowd in the bar. âCritics.'
âAre you on the stage?'
âAh!' said David, relieved at Joe's arrival. âThe drinks.' For Natasha and himself halves of bitter, for David a cocktail.
David sipped at the cocktail almost distastefully. Joe was to realise that David did not really enjoy drinking and his aim was to avoid being an outsider by imbibing steadily but as little as possible. As he sipped, an action which necessarily gave him pause, his eyes swivelled around the room and lit up at several recognitions which his eyebrows and the ends of his otherwise occupied lips acknowledged; the manoeuvre was done with some speed so as not to appear rude but it was clear to Natasha that there was a greed or more like a need for it and that softened her towards this otherwise swashbucklingly dominant figure.
âYou've caught me out,' David said, reading into her glance. âMy little weakness.'
âYou enjoy it,' said Natasha.
âThat's the only point in having a weakness.'
Natasha nodded in recognition at the effort that David was making.
âHe was a star, you know,' David said, waving both hands as if he were about to transform Joe into a Hollywood icon. âThey made a film
and Joe wandered around looking significant although we could never quite fathom what he was being significant about.'
âAlienation,' said Joe, promptly, quite enjoying the role into which David had cast him.
âMuch better if it had been about class, and your exile from your class,' said David. âAlienation is far too European and middle class for you. Joseph and I went on the Ban the Bomb march together last Easter,' he said to Natasha, âwith the jazz bands and Bertrand Russell, with vicars and MPs and playwrights, all very English, very village English, like a garden fete, and the conversation among the undergraduates in the evenings would often revolve around this word “alienation”. I thought they should stick to class. Now there's a subject.'
âYou see yourself as his guide, don't you?'
âI,' said David, giggling, âam his Virgil, guiding him through the Oxford circles of hell.'
âThis is a very boyish hell, David.'
âSo it seems this evening. You should see them scent blood and bay at the sound of breaking glass â Evelyn Waugh is reliable on that.' He paused. âLet me tell you something.' Another mite of a sip and a rapid smile from those long curvaceous lips and he leaned forward, voice guarded. âIn my first week here at Oxford, four of us met in my rooms for tea. We had never met before. Each of us had been to a different public school. In less than an hour we discovered that we knew about sixty people in common â in their case often sisters and cousins but in all our cases friends we'd met through school chums or at London parties or wherever. It's a caste . . . England is a hierarchy of courts and clubs and this handsome cadre may be tolerant and amused by the Joes of this world but, as a group, they do not rate or like or understand his world. Individuals can be an exception, of course.' His smile melted Natasha's resistance. âBut Joe's background is very foreign, slightly threatening, coarse, and less attractive than, say, that of any roughneck from the old colonies. He is, unfortunately for them, English, and being at Oxford theoretically one of “them” but he is clearly not, until he converts and adopts their religion, but even then . . .'
âWhy should Joseph need a guide to that?' Natasha asked. âAnd how can it matter? Class is of no importance in the real world.'
âOf course you are right,' he said, and changed the subject.
Soon David left, all but danced away, full of beaming affection for both of them, his drink barely touched, on his way to the first of three parties that evening. Natasha and Joe soon followed. She too had scarcely touched her drink.
Natasha had to be back by seven to babysit the three Stevens children; Joe went to eat in college.
When he came back the children were headed for bed. The boys were aged eight and six, the girl four. Joe's contribution was to romp with them and make them too excited to want to go to bed. Natasha sent him down to the kitchen, with which he was now quite familiar. He made a pot of tea and read more of
Justine
while he waited.