“I'm back to the gun,” Kelb said. “Mr. Gillette, how did the revolver get into your hands after the murder?”
“Margaret Handle gave it to me.”
“In your opinion, why?”
“I don't know. I only know what she said when she gave it to me. She said, âThis gun was used to kill Botho August.' Then she walked right out the door.”
“At what time of day did this take place?”
“I'd say around 7 a.m.”
“How did Miss Handle seem?”
“Seem?
I don't know that either. But she suddenly came back into my store and said, âIf you walk to the lighthouse, you'll find Botho lying in his yard. He's dead and I've covered him up.”
“Is that all she said?”
“Yes.”
“What did you do then?”
“I placed the revolver inside an oilcloth. I put on my coat and walked to the lighthouse. You can imagine how high my curiosity might have been.”
“And found what? At the lighthouse.”
“Just as Margaret said. Botho August, dead as a doornail. His nightshirt torn away, right next to him on the ground. He was covered with a wet blanket. I went to the wharf, told some men. They went back with me. I went to get Reverend Sillet, but he wasn't at home. I looked for him. I found him at the Harbisons' house having a late breakfast. By the time he and I got back to the body, people were gawking.”
“You can sit down.”
“All right.” Romeo sat down.
Mitchell Kelb looked at John Rut. He sighed, then
turned toward Margaret. “Miss Handle,” Kelb said, “is what Mr. Gillette just reported how you remember itâthe parts about you giving him the revolver and so forth?”
“Yes. Except I forgot I'd covered Botho August with a blanket,” Margaret said. “Do you want to hear about that?”
“Not necessarilyâ”
“I took the blanket off his bed, brought it down the stairs. It was raining hard still. I covered him with it.”
“Did you participate directly in the murder?”
“I saw Orkney Vas run off from the body. I came downstairs. As I said. As I said, I found the revolver.”
“Did you put a bullet in Botho August is what I'm asking?”
“We're not wasting the crown's time now!” John Rut said.
“Miss Handle?” Kelb said.
“Yes, I did.”
“Even after he'd been shot twice already. Howâ”
“It all happened very fast. Fast in the rain. That Botho seemed to fly awake and reach for the revolver. I grabbed it first. I thought he'd kill me. I don't know what I thought. I shot him.”
Margaret did not break down; she in fact stiffened her posture.
“So you lied before. Perjured yourself before, when I asked if you at any time that night had possession of the gun.”
“Yes. I'm sorry.”
“Did you at any time that night see Fabian Vas?”
“No. That's the truth. No.”
“A lie will come back around at you some way or another. You know that. That's all of my questions for you just now, Miss Handle. Mr. Vas, stand up, will you?”
I stood up.
“Fabian Vas,” Kelb said, “that night, did you participate in the murder?”
“Be sure to speak up, Fabian, so we can hear you!” a voice said from the back of the store. It was my Uncle Bassie; it was my father's messenger.
His presence, and my cowardice, emboldened me to lie. I knew then and there I would lie. I lied. “My father and mother had been quarreling all night. It was awful,” I said. “My mother kept crying out, âDo you want me to drown myself in the sink?' Other things. Other things out of shame at the adultery. It went on for a long time. Hours. I'm their son and I heard it all. I heard my father say, âI'll kill him!”
“Kill whom?”
“Botho August.”
“Orkney Vas actually said he was going to kill Botho August?”
I looked at my uncle. “Yes, he did. I heard him.”
“On the night of October 8, did you
see
Orkney Vas in possession of the revolver?”
“This is my fatherâ”
“I'm asking.”
I took a deep breath. Bassie stepped out onto the porch.
“Yes, I saw him go to the woodshed. I kept out of sight, following my own father that way. Out of sight in the rain,
on to the lighthouse. He shot out a window. That happened right away. Then Botho stepped out of the door. They had words. I heard words but couldn't hear what they were exactly. My fatherâ”
“Fabian?”
“Shot Botho August. He shot him twice. He dropped the revolver and ran.”
“Orkney had a lantern, as Miss Handle testified. Did you see the murder by lantern light, then?”
“What I saw of it, yes. Then my father doused the wick.”
“Did you see Miss Handle fire the third shot?”
“No, I did not. I was very confused. I was afraid for my father. I hated Botho August. It was as if I'd shot him myself. I was afraid for my father, for what he'd done. I went to my childhood hiding place, though I'm twenty years old.”
“Where was that?”
“Boas LaCotte's barn.”
“And before dawn, there was a family reunion, you might sayâ”
“I wouldn't call it that.”
“âwherein, you, Alaric Vas, and Orkney fled Witless Bay. On the
Aunt Ivy Barnacle.
”
“For Halifax. Yes.”
Kelb picked up the revolver, spun the empty cartridge, then said, “Mr. Gillette said he emptied this cartridge. Mrs. Dollard, be sure to note that.” He inspected the revolver for a moment, for all the world like a man browsing in a store. Holding it by the barrel, he tapped the table
with the handle. “I've got some thinking to do,” he said. “Adjourned.”
Margaret rode her bicycle back to the house.
Though I did not attend that year's Guy Fawkes activities until the very last moment, I can describe them in general, because I had been to them since I was four years old. During the day, wood is stacked: warped doors, driftwood, fireplace logs, sticks thrown in by children, and mostly green boughs and tar barrels, as they produce the thickest smoke. I remember when I was eight a house burned down in September; in late October, the charred roof beams, windowsills, porch railings, steps, and scraps of furniture were hauled by wagon to the Guy Fawkes bonfire heap.
Potluck supper is served at the church around six o'clock. The bonfire has blazed since dark, and by its light a mocking rendition of the original Guy Fawkes Day is performed. Traditionally, in Witless Bay, Romeo Gillette dressed up as King James I. He might wear a white wig with exaggerated curls; one year curls fell to his waist. Another year he wore a miniature weathervane on top of a hat. He might wear a vast, flowing court robe hemmed with cork net floats that drag along, all festooned with fishbones. Cotton stuffing protrudes from the robe in fistfuls at the sleeves. His king's throne is ten feet high, making him look like a dwarf. When I was fifteen, Romeo asked me to paint a flock of gulls on a bedsheet, and to have the gulls raining down gull shit. The sheet was stretched between poles and held above Romeo
during the procession. The sheet took me three whole days to complete.
Near the bonfire, novices would have tar pitch applied to their faces, smeared on arms and legs. Then they were led through the smoke, and the wild dancing and reveling began, all to the accompaniment of drums, accordions, even a bagpipe, if the only bagpipe player in the region, Peter Reid, accepted Witless Bay's invitation. He was in popular demand, though. Most every year, too, a few people succumbed to smoke and had to be dragged away and revived. The dancers all had smoke tears streaming down their faces.
The failed ambush on the throne was at once laughable and serious: the king had to go, if not this time, then soon! One year Romeo stood up and said, “I declare a free Newfoundland!” His declaration was his way for history to service his own hopes, and he drew applause and drunken cheers.
Anyway, around dusk on that November 5, Mitchell Kelb walked into our kitchen, took up an iron pot, and clanged it with a ladle. We all came in, obedient as schoolchildren. “I've decided, out of curiosity, mind you, to attend the Guy Fawkes bonfire,” he said. “Llewellyn Boxer seems to be a day late getting back here. Much to my chagrin, I can't find a guard for you, so you'll be on your own, which I've advised myself against. Nonetheless, I'm going. I can't allow you to attend, naturally. I can't allow you to leave this house, so don't. House arrest is serious business. Each of you will be accountable. I'll be gone no more than two hours, maybe three, according to my timepiece.”
He took out his watch, gold-rimmed, on a chain. He looked at the watch and said, “Exactly 4:18.” He returned the watch to his pocket. “Difficult and lonely as it might be, try and have a pleasant dinner without me.”
He set out down the road. We all stepped out onto the porch. There was a clear sky, night falling. We could see smoke from the bonfire. They had begun it a bit early this year, I thought. It looked to be where it always was, though, a few hundred yards south of the lighthouse, in a field back from the cliff.
I turned from the porch and saw Margaret go into the pantry. I went into the kitchen. My mother joined us there. Margaret threw back three shots in a row.
“Oh yes, to be sure, Margaret Handle,” my mother said. “That's your way in times of trouble, isn't it?”
“Not just at those times,” Margaret said, pouring another shot.
My mother began to cook furiously. She sliced and fried some onions. Scraping the onions from the cutting board into a bowl, she then filleted a sea trout that Romeo had brought us. “There's leftover codfish stew, but I don't want any more of that,” she said. “Three days in a row it's been in the house.” She rolled the trout in butter and fried it on a skillet. When this was ready, she all but slammed a loaf of bread onto the table.
“My God,” she said, holding on to the table edge. “Why don't we simply call ourselves by our true names here! Adulteress, murderer, and murderer!”
My mother opened a window. She leaned out and
breathed the night air. When the smell of onions died down a little, she served supper.
“The harbor's been smooth as a mirror all day, I bet, since there's been so little wind,” my mother said. “And I'm so cooped up inside. Have you noticed that since our one time rowing, Mr. Kelb has refused to take me out again? He's outright refused. I call it mostly his fault I'm so cooped up. Therefore, I'm going to act directly against his orders. I'm going to ignore his warning. I have to. I'm going to row out. I want to see the bonfire from a harbor view. I've always wanted to.”
Margaret made a hollow clucking. “Alaric,” she said, “Helen once warned me never to row in one direction if seabirds are towarding in the other. A sea hag will capsize you. So, Alaric, if you see gulls or the late-staying bullbirds flying toward shore, don't, don't, don't row out to sea. Just float in on the tide. Or wait till the birds are out of sight, then do what you please.”
“I'd gladly ponder advice from Helen. But coming from you, Margaret, in your condition just now, I think I'll row in any direction I choose, thank you.”
“Helen wasn't drunk when she gave me that advice, so what's it matter to the truth if I am?”
“This conversation is over,” my mother said. “Besides, who can see birds in the dark, bonfire or no?”
I watched as she put on a sweater, then a coat. She took a rain slicker from its peg, tucked it under her arm, then put on a stocking cap.
“And how will you two spend this Guy Fawkes evening,
once I'm out of sight?” she said. “Having some sort of close reunion?”
“For us to know and you to find out,” Margaret said.
“Mother, you never asked me if I spoke to Bassie. You must've seen him during the hearing,” I said.
“Bassie is a convict, whether in jail or out. And we never got along. Not really. Though I admired, at least, the fact that robbing a bank was a clear, stalwart decision on his part. He could make a true decision in his life. Though again and again a wrong one. Bassie. Yes, well, whenever he sat at our table, he never said, âNow, should I pick up the fork or knife first?” He'd just pick one up and let the other follow.”
“This is
your
decision, then? To row out in the harbor.”
“Yes. It's something I want to do. Just consider it an evening stroll, except on the water.”
And she left the house.