Authors: Joanna Kavenna
*
She is pinioned by drugs. The midwife's hand is upon her knee, though Brigid can hardly feel it. And in the other hand she holds a watch.
âOK, now off we go again,' says the midwife. Brightly, as if it is a race.
*
The true horror, the horror I am not prepared for though I have already seen it once, is still to come, thinks Patrick, looking over at his wife, her face contorted, her jaw wide open in a snarl. He thinks of all the effort she has gone to, the months of pregnancy and hauling her belly around, and now this. He wants to put his hands on her, to comfort her, but she is engrossed in her state, and he holds back. Later blood will flow and then there will be the ruined and deflated belly, wrinkled as if aged prematurely, a flap of baggy skin. Patrick remembers this melancholy voided belly, which he loved because it had housed his son, because each silvery stretch mark reminded him of the months of suspense, the eventual birth. And then the gradual recovery, the body slowly regaining shape and definition, though never quite the same as before. But before that, they must pass through the terrifying beauty of the birth â the gory sundering. And now he says,
because it is all he can do, and he is otherwise ineffective, redundant otherwise, âGo on Brigid, push!'
*
Brigid thinks how impossible this is, how she fails to understand it, how her body is â even the second time, when they lied and told her things would be easy â refusing to release the child. She had never really considered that this birth might be worse than the first. In the midst of it, even as she strains and snarls, Brigid sees what is happening to her and knows it is worse than last time.
*
And though she can hardly imagine it, her thoughts turn to the child within her, contained in some bony unyielding place, its head trapped, and so she growls and wills her deadened muscles to work.
âGo on Brigid!' says Patrick. Like a nervous cheerleader. âGo on, you can do it!'
*
She screams in her effort, a thin shrill scream, and Patrick says, âGood girl, you're doing so well,' trying to make his voice sound warm and calm, and then the midwife says, âOK, and relax now.' Brigid lets her head fall back, and she stares at the ceiling.
*
It hasn't worked. The midwife examines her and makes the pronouncement. None of it â the grunting and straining and even the final cry â has moved the baby.
*
âUnfortunately, we could be doing this for hours,' the midwife is saying. The allotted hour has elapsed. It is 9.30 a.m.and the baby has not arrived.
âNo sign even of the head,' says Patrick.
âNo sign at all?' says Brigid.
*
Dr Gupta returns again, and he feels inside her and says little has changed.
âFor the sake of the baby, we cannot extend this any further,' he says.
âThe head really hasn't turned?' says Brigid. Incredulously, because she hoped so much it would.
âNo, I'm afraid it hasn't. At this point, the only real option you have is a Caesarean,' he says. Already she can see people moving around the room, making preparations. âAnything else carries a greater risk for your baby.'
âYou are certain?'
âPersonally, I am certain that the risks of any other procedure are significant,' says Dr Gupta. âA Caesarean is the safest course of action for your baby, and for you.'
*
Another doctor appears, with a form for her to sign. Consequences of a Caesarean may include ⦠she doesn't read the list. She signs her name, hands the paper back to the doctor. Patrick is beside her, winding his fingers around hers. They have no choice. There is simply nothing else she can do, and now she must abandon her efforts, submit entirely. She is close to tears once more, but she is exhausted beyond measure, flushed with chemicals, hardly in her right mind. There is a distant voice saying, âWhy me?' and she manages to conjure the image of Stephanie, just yesterday, and how sorry she had felt for her, and how certain she had been that this wouldn't happen to her. But it is remote now, she can hardly remember yesterday. Patrick says, âI'm so sorry, darling,' but he doesn't understand. He assumes she is devastated, he doesn't realise how
far she has fallen. Because under it all, the confused pulsing of her thoughts and the insistent rhythmic beep of the monitor beside her, and the doctors murmuring at the door, she has tumbled into a dark secret sense of relief, that it is no longer her responsibility, that someone else will prise the baby out.
âIt's over,' she says, and Patrick doesn't know what she means.
*
Prisoner 730004 is dragged roughly from her cell. âWe must move quickly for your protection,' says a guard. There is another guard beside him, both of them sinewy like trees, their faces wiped of everything except conviction. She sees them plainly before her, and then they open a door and the corridor is filled with light. Dazzled by the glare, she blinks and turns away. Now they are grappling with her, tying her hands.
âFor your protection and that of the species,' one of them says.
She is walked along corridors, the doors tightly shut. Door after door, and she thinks that behind each door is another prisoner, and she wonders what they have all done, how they fell under the censure of the Protectors, and how they will be punished. She wonders if any of them will be freed â but that question seems absurd, when freedom is Darwin C. She feels sick and wants to pause, but the men lead her along. They will not look directly at her, they just march on, their boots hammering on the floor, a rhythmic thud, and she is dragged along beside them.
âWhere are we going?' she says, after the hammering has gone on for a long time.
âYou are not entitled to ask such questions.'
âWill I see my friends?'
âYou are not entitled to ask such questions.'
*
The hammering begins again and the doors are all tightly shut and Prisoner 730004 falls silent, they will not answer her. She struggles on, her grey-faced captors flanking her, their arms rubbing against hers, and she remembers her parents and how they were sent to the mass-scale farms, and how she believed at the time this was a good place for them to go, a pleasant retirement, a gift from the Protectors, and it was only gradually that she pieced the rumours together. Then she was stricken and horrified for many years, because she had been so eager to believe a lie. Because she had waved them off, in her willing ignorance.
*
Her parents had believed it too; they had gone to the train as if they were embarking on an adventure, and she wonders when they realised â whether they began to suspect something on the train itself, as they were shunted into a carriage with dozens of others, all of them old and frail and clearly expendable â or whether they suppressed their fears until they saw the farm itself. She wonders when they knew they were being discarded, and how long it took them to die.
*
Prisoner 730004 understands more than her parents did about this world, the world of the Protectors. If they send her to the mass-scale farms, she knows what that will mean. She will be given a bunk in a vast barn, full of others like her, she will be dragged into the domes at daybreak, there to collect the harvest, she will work until the sun drops beneath the horizon, she will receive her allotted
ration of food. She will not be murdered, not precisely; she will be neglected and beaten when she fails to work, and her deprived body will protest, it will struggle for survival but it will decline nonetheless. She wonders what happens then â there are many rumours about what happens then â but now she does not want to think any more about the mass-scale farms. She is afraid, though she tries to tell herself that she must not show her fear. The drugs are making her afraid; they are conjuring these memories of her parents. The Protectors want her weak so she will beg for mercy. So she will tell them what they want to know.
*
But they will send her away whatever she says. Prisoner 730004 strives to remember that, despite the drugs they have fed her. Though the drugs are designed to make her cowardly and penitent, she tries to resist their effects. She must remember, she thinks, that she will not be saved.
*
The guards slam their feet on the cold floor. They slam their feet and she is dragged along beside them. The smell of the guards is thick and vile; she is repulsed by their bodies close beside her. They have walked for so long, it is a surprise to her when they stop. They come to a sudden halt outside a door. High and broad, and barred against her.
*
âWait here,' say the guards.
*
In Lazarettgasse, Robert von Lucius hammers on the door of the asylum, and for a long time no one comes to meet him. He hears bells tolling in the distance. He hammers again, more loudly. There is another lengthy pause, and
then, finally, the face of Herr Meyer appears, but he will only open the door a crack. He seems different today, all his oily charm is gone. It has seeped from him, and he is pale-faced and reluctant. He peers around the door with a sour pinched expression, and says, âHerr von Lucius. You have returned again?'
âYes, I wanted to see Professor Semmelweis.'
âI am afraid you cannot enter,' says Herr Meyer, holding up a hand.
âWhy not?' Robert von Lucius is prepared to argue, to fight the man; he has come full of resolution and even excitement. He says, âCome now Herr Meyer, I demand an appointment.'
Herr Meyer says, perhaps less sour now and merely frightened, though prepared to deny everything, âHerr S is dead. He died in the night.'
And though his mind is suddenly blank, his thoughts erased by shock, Robert von Lucius hears himself saying, âBut how? How did he die?' He sees Herr Meyer working his mouth, forming a lie, he thinks. Even as Herr Meyer forms his lie, Robert von Lucius feels a great surge of rage as if he would like to strike him down.
âHe clearly had a degenerate condition. It festered internally and finally killed him,' says Herr Meyer.
âI do not believe you,' says Robert von Lucius. His body is tensed with rage, and with the effort of suppressing it. Yet he tries to speak slowly and clearly. He says, âProfessor Semmelweis told me he had been beaten. He said he believed he had internal injuries. He was a doctor, an esteemed doctor. He diagnosed himself â¦'
âHerr S was insane. This means anything he said cannot be considered,' says Herr Meyer, abruptly.
âYou are wrong. He died because he was savagely beaten. I am convinced of it. His death was avoidable. If you had treated him as a suffering human and not as an animal, he would have lived â¦'
Robert von Lucius stops talking. He understands that it is pointless to say anything to this man, this torturer, who thrives on pain and despair. And he is aware of something else, a horrified recognition that this is what he feared. He might have averted it, he thinks, if he had acted sooner, if he had allowed himself to act on his fears. So his rage is mingled with self-reproach, and he clenches his fists.
âHe was a violent madman,' Herr Meyer is saying. He is puffed up with indignation. Robert von Lucius wonders if the man truly believes, if he believes and does not doubt himself, that he has done nothing wrong. âWe restrained him in the only way possible. Otherwise he would have been a danger to himself.'
âYou are a murderer,' says Robert von Lucius. âYou have killed this innocent man, and thousands of women will die because of your actions.'
âYou should leave now,' says Herr Meyer. âBefore I call the guards.' And now he slams the door, and will not open it again, though Robert von Lucius breaks his knuckles hammering on it.
*
When he finally realises that this door will not open, Robert von Lucius turns away, head bent, stricken with a terrible dark guilt, that he saw the suffering of Semmelweis and did nothing. The man is dead, he thinks, and I planned to speak to him today, to understand him further. I planned to help him, but I have arrived too late, and my plans do not matter now. The man is dead and we shall never speak again.
He thinks â though he tries not to, but he cannot repel the thought â of Semmelweis dying alone in his cell, the fetid dungeon they cast him into, dying in darkness, deprived even of the light of the moon.
*
Robert von Lucius turns with his head bent, and walks back down the hill.
*
Heads bent, the prisoners are pushed into the room. Prisoners 730004, 730005, 730006, 730007 are pushed into the room, and they nod their recognition quickly, not wanting to incriminate each other.
*
Prisoner 730004 lifts her head and sees before her the servants of the Protectors, called Protection Scientists. Half a dozen men, hard and vital, the beneficiaries of intensive courses of gene therapy. They are the elite guardians of this civilisation; they act to protect the species â their actions justified by this aim. Their lofty phrases, all those phrases they threaded around her, as they are threaded about Darwin C, woven across a thousand walls â they believe them all, coldly, rigidly. To Prisoner 730004, they look alike, as she glances at their faces one by one â her glance rushed and nervous, because she knows they have come to condemn her. Perhaps she thinks they are alike because their faces phrase the same attitude of mind, this absolute conviction. Nothing will shatter this conviction, she thinks, as she scans them with her weary eyes. They do not look at her. The Head Scientist â taller and sterner still â appears among them, wearing a grey robe. He is old, but he has been repeatedly rejuvenated, his cells replaced; he is a
hybrid, an ageing body filled with borrowed life. Now one of the Scientists says, âLine them up.' And the guards obey them. Prisoner 730004 can barely stand, fear has softened her limbs, but a guard grabs her and she is lined up anyway.