24
The Confessions of Albert DeSalvo, IV
Albert was no more eager to confess to the slayings of Patricia Bissette, Beverly Samans, Joann Graff, and Mary Sullivan than he was to that of Sophie Clarkâor, indeed, to any of the others, despite his initial stated desire to unburden himself and despite his disclaimer that the details of the older women hadn't affected him the way those of the younger women had.
He couldn't explain why he had moved nineteen-year-old Mary Sullivan's body from one bed to another in the room she'd shared with Pamela Parker and Patricia Delmore at 44A Charles Street in Boston. He also blanked on other significant details of that murder. And there was physical evidence left at that crime scene that could not be connected with him.
62
On September 9, 1965, Albert and Bottomly discussed at length the fact that one of Albert's Bridgewater acquaintances was a young man incarcerated there for killing his wife. This man had known Mary Sullivan on Cape Codâhad in fact dated herâand, according to Albert, had referred to Mary with considerable contempt as “a skinny little bitch.” The wife-murderer's opinion of women in general was low; they were all, he confided to Albert, “no God damn good.”
Albert also told Bottomly that after this young man had found out that Albert had admitted to Mary's murder, he remarked, “Well, I don't have to. I don't have to play a game with you.”
Bottomly asked Albert to place when he had killed twenty-three-year-old Patricia Bissette. Albert thought it was after the death of Sophie Clark, which was true, and after the attack on Erika Wilsing, which wasn't.
A
LBERT
: And then, uh, this was Patricia Bissette hadda come next and you know what, how I figger this? This hadda be done Sunday morning. B
OTTOMLY
: Yuh?
A
LBERT
: And the date to my knowledge would be around the, uh, twenty-eight or twenty-ninth.
B
OTTOMLY
: Whatever that Sunday was, the last Sunday in December?
A
LBERT
: Yeh, becuz, uh, you know something'? we had coffee there. I know that I had my cup with me becuz she drank hers and I don't like coffee, not that much.
That Pat had offered her killer (or someone) this hospitality had been widely reported in the press, the Globe even stating that “the coffee in one cup had been served black and the other mixed with cream.” It was also noted that one unwashed cup had been found in the living room, the other in the kitchen.
Albert said Patricia had a Christmas tree in her living room and a record player with a broken cover. Again, he had previously viewed the crime scene photos.
Albert's confession to the murder of twenty-three-year-old Joann Graff of Lawrence was not particularly convincing. Because it had taken place the weekend after the death of John F. Kennedy, it received somewhat less press coverage than it ordinarily might have.
B
OTTOMLY
: Can you think back now to the Graff place? Did you see a telephone?
A
LBERT
: No, I didn't.
B
OTTOMLY
: You didn't notice the telephone? A
LBERT
: No.
B
OTTOMLY
: Did you take anything from the Graff place?
A
LBERT
: No.
B
OTTOMLY
: You didn't take a wallet?
A
LBERT
: Possible. It's possible.
B
OTTOMLY
: What would you have done with it if you did?
A
LBERT
: Threw it away.
B
OTTOMLY
: See what was in it and throw it away?
A
LBERT
: It's possible.
B
OTTOMLY
: Do you specifically remember anything?
A
LBERT
: What's that, in the wallet? Or taking it?
B
OTTOMLY
: Do you even remember taking it?
A
LBERT
: It's possible I took it and threw it somewhere.
B
OTTOMLY
: Mmm. But you're not positive either way.
A
LBERT
: No.
Even aided by these extremely leading questions, the Task Force chief was unable to draw the correct responses from Albert. Joann did in fact have a telephone. And her brown leather clutch wallet was missing from the apartment, presumably taken by her killer.
Bottomly persisted. “Now, remember the Anna Slesers case, you got a lot of blood on you which caused you some problems.”
A
LBERT
: Yes.
B
OTTOMLY
: Was there any blood in the Graff case.
A
LBERT
: None, none.
B
OTTOMLY
: None that you recall?
A
LBERT
: Graff? None.
According to the Lawrence police report by the officer who had discovered Joann's body, there was blood on the bedspread and on the victim's bra, which had been ripped open.
Bottomly asked Albert what had happened when the latter had walked around Joann's buildingâas Albert claimed he had, and as had been reported in news accountsâlooking for the victim's apartment.
B
OTTOMLY
: Okay. Now, ah, you mention that you ah saw this guy up on the, up one floor up and asked where Graff lived.
A
LBERT
: I recall going into this apartment. Going up and going to the farthest to the left and talking with this man. [This was Kenneth Rowe, who could not later identify Albert.]
B
OTTOMLY
: Right, andâ
A
LBERT
: I remember talking to him.
B
OTTOMLY
: I thought you said leter [sic] or maybe earlier you couldn't remember exactly which you talked to a woman.
A
LBERT
: Yes.
B
OTTOMLY
: An older woman and you described her?
A
LBERT
: The opposite side of her apartment up in the left corner.
B
OTTOMLY
: Now, how did you represent yourself to that old woman, do you remember?
A
LBERT
: No, I don't.
B
OTTOMLY
: What lines you used with her?
A
LBERT
: No, I think I may have just talked to her occasionally that's all. As to what I said to her I don't recollect.
The Task Force chief was not about to concede defeat so easily.
B
OTTOMLY
: Did you represent yourself as being in for maintenance orâ
A
LBERT
: I don't recall.
B
OTTOMLY
: What if I used the word detective does that help you at all?
A
LBERT
: No. Never used that word.
B
OTTOMLY
: You never represented yourself as a detective?
A
LBERT
: Never used myself as a detective.
It wasn't the answer the Task Force chief wanted.
Despite repeated requests from Bottomly, Albert didn't wish to discuss the murder of twenty-six-year-old Beverly Samans in Cambridge. He also made clear the reasons for his reluctance.
A
LBERT
: I don't want to talk about her.
B
OTTOMLY
: Oh, why not?
A
LBERT
: Not her.
B
OTTOMLY
: Why not?
A
LBERT
: I was told not to.
B
OTTOMLY
: Why?
A
LBERT
: You know, just on this basis until things are clearer.
B
OTTOMLY
: You mean on account of Droney? On account of the D.A., there? [John Droney, district attorney of Middlesex County, who did not believe Albert had murdered Beverly Samans] Well, I meanâit's gonnaâthe deal we had is you're supposed to tell about everything you know.
A
LBERT
: Yeh, but I also was told by Mr. McGrath in front of you and Mr. Bailey until he comes back and he talks to youâMr. Bailey's gonna talk to you, he says, when he comes back and Mr. Bottomly is present with him we will discuss that together. He says until you hear from me further, don't talk about it. He says when Mr. Bottomly and I will get together. He says, unless he saysâ
B
OTTOMLY
: Well that's gonna hold everything up. A
LBERT
: Huh?
B
OTTOMLY
: That's gonna hold everything up. A
LBERT
: No. Well he told me not to discuss that until that will be the last one he says til he talks to you privately. I gotta do what he tells me cuz you know yourself I'm going all the way. There's your fourth one right there, the question mark? There's no question at all there.
B
OTTOMLY
: The question mark meaning you can't talk.
Later that same day, August 24, 1965, Albert told Bottomly that he was “blocking out” Beverly's killing.
B
OTTOMLY
: You're doing that on orders, and I think it's messing some other things up, so I think we ought toâ
A
LBERT
: Till we find out.
B
OTTOMLY
: Till we get cleared on Samansâto talk.
A
LBERT
: Ahâpossibly you can bring Mr. McGrathâorâ
B
OTTOMLY
: I'll get in touch with him tomorrowâI'll tell him the point that we've reachedâA
LBERT
: Uh huh.
Albert was ready to confess to the slaying fully on September 9, 1965. Whatever consultations or arrangements with F. Lee Bailey that needed to be made had clearly had been taken care of in one fashion or another.
A
LBERT
: Tryin' to think where I wuz that morning, why I wuz there. She let me in. I'm tryin' to think what I said to her. UhhhâJesus ChristâI remember it too clearâon herâ(Long pause) (Heavy sighs)
B
OTTOMLY
: Well you tell it your way.
A
LBERT
: Do you want toâfirst sketch out the bathâthe uh the apartmentâ
B
OTTOMLY
: Just as it comes to you in the story, then sketch it.
A
LBERT
: All right, uhâthe uhâthe way she opened the door. Gee I think she had a zipperâshe had a zipper on in front of her.
B
OTTOMLY
: A housecoat on?
A
LBERT
: I think it was a housecoat or somethin'. I could be wrong on the zipper becuza that's what I don't seeâI gotta talk about it whether I like it or not.
B
OTTOMLY
: I see.
A
LBERT
: She uhâI opened it upâand she went into the bathroom and I went with her and I hadâI had gutten a knife fromâthat's itâthis ties it up now. (Bang) You know somethinââI wuz in there doing this job on the side. That's what happened. I wuz doin' a home in Belmont. That's how I gut to be over there in East Cambridge. [Beverly actually lived west of Harvard Square, about two miles from East Cambridge.]
B
OTTOMLY
: I see.
ALBERT: SeeâI wuz aâworking in a home in Belmont for a woman on the side doin' extra work.
Albert told the Task Force chief that while he was working in the Belmont house, he went down to the cellar, where he opened some drawers and looked into them.
A
LBERT
: And this knife wuz in there. There wuz a knife in there. And I took it.
B
OTTOMLY
: What kind of knife?
A
LBERT
: It wuz a push button knife.
B
OTTOMLY
: Switch-blade?
A
LBERT
: âBout that longâyeahâswitch-blade. Very sharp, pointedânever see 'em around here. I never seen one before.
B
OTTOMLY
: Curved, was it?
A
LBERT
: This wuz aâan Armenian family, that wuz livin thereâan uhâit wuz aâyou just pushed the buttonâp' tewâ
B
OTTOMLY
: Did it come out this way, or up straight? A
LBERT
: Think it wuz straight.
B
OTTOMLY
: Uh huh.
A
LBERT
: Came straightâyou just push the thing, right?
B
OTTOMLY
: Yuh.
A
LBERT
: She shot right out.
B
OTTOMLY
: Shot right out of the handle, huh?
A
LBERT
: Yuhâpretty sure it shot right out. And uhâthat there wuz in there an I put it in my pocket and I had carried it one or two days wit meâ
B
OTTOMLY
: Uh-huh.
ALBERT: Could be three daysâand I thinkâI'm almost positiveâon my way fromâhomeâthat I shot over that way.
B
OTTOMLY
: To Cambridge.
Albert claimed that this stolen switchblade was the weapon he had used on Beverly, and that after leaving her apartment he'd driven to Malden (a small city just north of Boston) and thrown the knife in a swamp. This wetland had been filled in with gravel and houses built atop it, Albert said.
The point that the switchblade obviously couldn't be recovered now was moot; it wasn't the murder weapon anyway. Beverly had been stabbed to death with one of her own paring knives, which the killer had washed and put on the drainboard along with an assortment of other knives, forks, and spoons in an attempt to mislead the Cambridge police. The cleaning job was as inadequate as was the effort to conceal; the knife was still bloodstained.