Authors: Mercedes Keyes,Lawrence James
South
. He sat at the left end from where he faced
them, next to him was Lawrence Carter, in the
middle, their clergy, Father Walter Hannah, next
Richard McKinney and at the end, James Armfield.
Aside from the men sat an elderly matron in a
lone chair to the left; quiet in observance.
It was Father Hannah who stood, cal ing him
forward.
There was a table present that Quinton was to
stand behind, facing them, and over to the far right, a
single chair.
“Dr. Caine, to the table please, and the Negro
– the chair there – is for her.” He pointed toward it.
Realizing the gravity of their situation, Suga
rushed there, keeping her head down the entire time,
silent as a mouse and just as frightened as one, she
sat with eyes on her tightly bal ed hands. Quinton
dare not look her way, but kept his eyes straight
ahead; he was deliberately arrogant before them.
Once they were in their places, father Hannah
proceeded, “Are you sir, aware of the reasons we’ve
summoned you here today? What charges you
face?”
Crossing his arms as if standing before those
beneath him, he returned, as if bored by it al , “I’m
sure, I’l find it rather intriguing.”
“Dr. Caine, in England, I’m certain your
cockiness is wel received, let me assure you, here it
is not! Such airs do nothing more than rile those who
sit in judgment of your crime.”
“I’ve committed no crime for any of you to be in
judgment of; I find these entire proceedings
ludicrous.” He returned.
“That remains to be seen.” Father Hannah
continued.
“Yes, so it does - what false witness has come
forth and what claim have they made?”
“This gathering has been commissioned by us;
you wil remain quiet as we proceed in the manner
for which we’ve organized it. Therefore, let your
silence be your counsel until you have been given
permission to speak, is that clear?”
“I do speak English, rather clearly – therefore, I
must also hear it and thus comprehend it.”
Suga thought she would faint clean to the floor,
‘Lord God, what is he doin’, he gone get us hanged!’
With nostrils flared, the clergyman drew in a
deep breath to gather his wits; once he felt back
under control he went forward with his questions.
“Is it true, that you – almost two months prior
received a servant girl, a Negro in order to assist
with settling in here?”
“That is true. Just so happens to be, the young
woman I was instructed to bring with me. Why – what
do you know, there she is, sitting in absolute fright,
for doing nothing more, than the job she was given.”
Father Hannah turned red, feeling his anger
grow under Quinton’s condescension and sarcasm.
One of the men coughed over a barely concealed
eruption of mirth, while Bancmen’s eyes narrowed.
Father Hannah continued. “You sir, wil not stand
before us, haughty in your snobbery! This is a court,
and you wil conduct yourself with the utmost respect
before it.”
“Very wel , your
honor
– please – list my crimes
wil you.”
“I assure you, we wil – as there appears to be
a couple of them. Shal we begin with the first?”
“And that would be?”
“We have reason to believe, that you sir, are a
spy.”
“WHAT?! Whose insanity has caused them to
mutter such an outrageous lie?” Quinton sputtered in
disbelief, “Have you al taken leave of your senses?!”
he blasted, “What would I possibly have to gain by
taking part in such a fool-hardy occupation! From the
moment of my taking a place within this community I
have done nothing more than practice medicine and
do research! To give aid to those in need; where in
that do you find reason to accuse me of such a
crime?!”
“What else would an Earl, pretending to be a
doctor, be doing here? No servants to treat? No
farmers on your land?”
Quinton sighed, he needed to calm himself and
answered simply, “If you must know – I found myself
bored with it al . I am young, I sought adventure, and
found myself here; up until this event, I was rather
taken with this community and its people. Lest you
forget, I have not been here more than three months
and have done little else but run to the aid of al who
were in need. If I might remind you…” He turned to
Henry Bancmen, “… one of those patients has been
your mother, whom I sat in attendance to, day and
night, administering to her, successful y - is that - not
so?”
Bancmen was silent as he gave his nod.
“Perhaps that was the device you used to gain
our trust?” Father Hannah went on.
“How very convenient her timing then, perhaps
she too is a spy, in cahoots with me! Perhaps she
was not sick at al , merely faking it to make me look
good.” He fired out, glaring from one man to the
other, his bold stare settled on Bancmen, “And – I
might further add, at no time had I asked for a coin –
as an Earl, I am not in need. If I remember
correctly…” Quinton wasn’t completely crazy; he
knew to be careful with how he implicated the slave
trader, “… you knew that I was a man alone,
struggling and you sent the girl to me to give aid –
which she has. Now, I am to stand accused of
crimes that neither of us is guilty of?”
“Why are you here?” One of the other men
asked.
“Why are you here!?” Quinton turned the
question on him, “Perhaps, in truth, you are the spy,
and I am being used-…”
Thrusting up from his chair to his feet James
Armfield bit out, “That is absurd!”
“Yes! And I find it as absurd for me, as it is for
you! If I am guilty of a crime, make it one which has
some standing, some validity – but nothing so
ridiculous as that!”
“Why did you not identify yourself from the very
beginning upon settling here?” Armfield asked.
“My identity has been known from the
beginning, it is my title that I cared not to share, for
what good would it serve me, here?” Each of the
men colored red at the truth in his words.
“Furthermore, if that title was tied to spying – why in
God’s name, would I use it in sending a missive? I
thought spy’s had secret codes and other such?!” He
argued his case once more looking from one man to
the other and then, finalizing his argument against
spying he stated, “The using of my title in the missive
was nothing more than customary etiquette. I
daresay something you seem to know nothing
about!”
James Armfield, with his face flaming, took his
seat, leaving Father Hannah to carry on, “Very wel –
that aside, there is the matter of the girl. Where –
exactly does the girl reside?”
“With me.” Quinton answered immediately.
“You are a bachelor sir.”
“She is a young Negro servant; in some places
she would be cal ed a slave.”
“While true – she is a female nonetheless. You
are a man; it is frowned upon and strictly forbidden
to have such an arrangement. Why do you not at the
end of your day, send the girl on her way?”
“On her way to where exactly? She is without a
home, without family; would you have her sleeping in
a barn – open to any sort of dangers? What good
would she be to me then?”
“What good is she to you now?”
“She is my assistant in research – helping me
to prepare necessary medicines to treat different
maladies, such as the many patients you have
interviewed may have suffered from.”
“If their statements have a thread of honesty,
you wil have been informed of that already. That
aside, there is the matter of domestic chores I
cannot be bothered with; my studies are no longer
impeded with my residence fal ing down around me;
thus, more for the servant girl.”
“Very wel , at the end of the day, send the girl
back to Mr. Bancmen, he as a married man with
back to Mr. Bancmen, he as a married man with
household with servants, could no doubt find a place
for her.”
“The girl would be of no use to me there, I have
been training her - I cannot do so if she is running
back and forth between my dwel ing and Mr.
Bancmen’s – there is much for her to learn – much
for her to do. She has a room of her own and a bed
there of her own. Once more, ask Erwin Murray, he
came in and constructed her room himself. And her
training, once again, ask any of those I am certain
you questioned, she has a skil for healing-…”
Cutting him off, Father Hannah brought the
focus back, “You sir – are a bachelor, she is a
female – the rest does not matter – might I suggest
you marry.”
“I have no room in my life, for a wife – if I did, I
would have done so with one more suitable to me,
back
in England.”
It was a deliberate insult; the five were
immediately offended by his comment.
“Are you saying, there are none here, good
enough for you?”
Quinton stood with his heart pounding, praying
as he cocked a haughty brow; which only riled them
al the more.
“You – how dare you! My daughter is more than
good enough! It is you, who is not worthy of her, or
any woman here for that matter – you and your
stinking elites!” Richard McKinney spat, thinking
about how his daughter Clarice longed for him,
asking for permission to cal on him – it simply was
not done, he had forbidden it, now – he was glad that
he had saved her from the humiliation.
“Let us al please stay focused on the matter at
hand. It is an easy enough solution; I wil have the girl
back.” Bancmen spoke up to break the tension in the
room.
“I’m sorry, the girl is my servant and I wil
continue on as I have done, for there has been no
crime committed.”
“So you say sir!” McKinney hissed, angry at
having his daughter devalued by the man before him.
“The girl is untouched! She is as she came to
me.”
“That can be proven easily enough.” Father
Hannah interjected, and looking at the young woman,
who sat quietly before them, said. “Check the girl –
we wil have proof of the matter now.”
Quinton felt his stomach tighten with the thought
of such an indignity forced upon her, but it could not
be helped – there was no way around it. He forced
himself to stare straight ahead, daring not to look her
way.
Suga glanced up with wide eyes towards
Quinton, he looked completely bored by it al , with his
eyes towards the men who faced him.
Without ceremony, the much older woman,
tromped her way across the distance between them
and upon reaching Suga, grabbed her by the arm
and snatched her from the seat, practical y dragging
her to a side room, shoving her through the door, she
slammed her against the nearest wal . As if she were
on a farm checking one of her livestock, she hitched
up her skirt, ripped her bloomers open and shoved
her hand between her thighs, “Spread your legs girl,
now!” She bit out nastily. With little choice, frightened
into silence, Suga spread her legs and closed her
eyes to endure being probed to the woman’s
satisfaction. When done, she used the inside of
Suga’s skirt to wipe her hands on.
“Wel I’ah’be, so ya’are. Back outside with’ya –
sit down.”
Head down once more, Suga rushed back out
the door and sat down, her face on fire from
humiliation; she did al she could to tune out al that
was happening around her. She thought about her
mother and al that she’d gone through. She thought
about the other slaves, young women like herself, her
sisters and al that they’d gone through too, wishing
she had never met nor been given to Quinton
Thaddeus Caine. His misleading kindness, fairness,
Thaddeus Caine. His misleading kindness, fairness,
difference made her soft, made her lower her guard,
made her think such nonsense that she was truly, as
good as anyone else – because he made her feel
that way.
But that day, what had been done to her – that
was the truth – she was nothing but a fool in
believing things just might be better for her.
Quinton blocked his mind, dare not look her
way – he dare not feel what just happened to her –