Authors: Nadine Gordimer
I turned round.
“No, sit downâyou'll excuse meâI just want to ask something, Joel, d'you know if Daddy's coming home to lunch or he's going straight to Colley? He's coming?” A short round woman stood in the doorway; she held her hands in front of her in the attitude of someone coming for instructions. They were puffy hands with hardened flesh growing up round small, clean but unkempt nails, the ragged-cuticle nails of domestic workers or children. Her body in a cheap silk dress that had the remains of an elaboration of black cotton lace and fagoted trimming round the neck was the incredibly small-hipped, thickened body of Jewish women from certain parts of Europe, the swollen doll's body from which it seems impossible that tall sons and daughters can, and do, come. The floral pattern of the apron she wore was rubbed away over the bulge of her breasts and her stomach. She looked at me from under the straggling, rather beautiful eyebrows you sometimes see on the faces of eagle-eyed old men, and beneath arches of fine, mauvish, shadowy skin, her lids remained level, half-shuttered. But the eyes were bright, liquid, water-colored.
I knew she must be Joel's mother and I felt acutely the fact that I was sitting casually on the bed, in the house of strangers. This I
felt in relation to her, and to Joel, the embarrassment he must feel at her accent, her whole foreignness before me.
But he answered her: “Colley?âWhy should he go there firstâOf course he's coming home.”
At once I was alone and they were both strangers. Something in the way he spoke to her, something he took from her own voice, as one takes a key in music, put me outside of them. I sat very consciously on the bed; what had been unnoticeably comfortable was now precarious: I had to brace my legs to prevent myself from slipping off the coverlet.
I smiled at Mrs. Aaron timidly as if to excuse her to herself. But she did not feel the need to be forgiven; she gave herself time to look at me with frank curiosity, as one might stop to finger a piece of material in a shop. “Joel,” she bridled, “why don't you bring the young lady into the lounge? Must she sit in the bedroom?âYou must excuse him, he doesn't think.” She drooped her head at him in an appraising, irritated smile. He made a little noise of smiling impatience. “No, it's not nice she should be stuck in this roomâIt's not so beautiful, believe meâ” Suddenly she and I were both laughing; as usual, I had deserted, in a desire to be liked had aligned myself in a sudden swift turn with what embarrassed or frightened me. We were led back to the living room, his mother talking on as if he were absent: “It's always like that. Anybody comes, he hides them away in his room.âCome sit down. Take a comfortable chairâ”
“No, really, I'm quite all rightâ”
“Come onâ” She made me move. All her own movements were slow, heavy and insistent as her voice, the movements of someone who has been on her feet a long time, like a horse who keeps up the plod of pulling a load even when he is set free in the field.
She went over to the sideboard with a kind of formal dignity, as if in spite of her wrinkled stockings and her feet which defied the shape of her shoes, her slip showing beneath the old afternoon dress as she bent, there was a grace of behavior that existed independently, as a tradition, no matter who performed it or how. Next to three packs of cards was a pink glass sweet dish filled with clusters of toffee-covered biscuit. “You'll have something? Come on.” I took
one, but when she saw it in my hand uncertainty came to her. “Perhaps she'll rather have a sweet, JoelâTake my keys, and in the bedroom cupboardâ” I protested and bit into the sticky biscuit. “âGo on, I've got some nice chocolates.”
I sat there eating my biscuit like a child who is being anxiously fattened.
“A bunch of grapes, perhaps? I got lovely grapes today from the market.”
Joel assured his mother that we did not want tea, lemonade or fruit.
She sat down near the door on a straight-backed chair and her swollen ankles settled on her shoes. We had been introduced, and after she had sat breathing heavily, thoughtfully, over her resting bosom for a moment (neither of us spoke; we could hear her) she said with polite, cautious inquiry, as if the reply would really give her an answer to something else: “Your father he's something on the Atherton Mineâand mummy? Your mummy's still alive?”
“Yes.” In an awkward burst I made some attempt to make my life real to her. “We've always lived there. My father's Secretary.âI hate the Mine.”
She stirred slowly in her chair. “So? It's your home, we all got to like our home.”
There was a pause. I was overcome with the theatrical way I had burst out ridiculously: I hate the Mineâand the even acceptance of this old woman's reply. She got up slowly, stood looking round the room as if to make sure she had forgotten nothing. “Well, you'll excuse meâ” she said, as if I were not there, an air of apology that seemed to throw the onus of my presence on me, and went out slowly and suddenly both withdrawing and yet taking the field at the same time.
“Would you like to wash?” said Joel, getting up. “They leave you rather sticky, though my mother really does make them very well.” He put the dish of sweet biscuits away carefully in the sideboard.
I don't know why he surprised me; Joel was continually surprising me by ease when there might have been strain, a word where there might have been a vacuum. He said what he thought and
somehow it was never what I thought he was thinking: his nature had for mine the peculiar charm of the courage to be itself without defiance; I had always to be opposing myself in order to test the validity of my reactions, a moral “Who goes there?” to which my real feelings as well as those imposed from without and vaguely held suspect must be submitted in a confusion of doubt. And when I answered myself and acted, anxiousness sometimes made me mistake bravado for honesty.
Now I had been ready to make it easy for Joel; to show him that so far as I was concerned, he need not mind about his mother. This was quite a different thing from finding that he did not mind about his mother; that far from being apologetic of the peculiar sweetmeat which politeness had forced me to eat, he seriously commended her skill in preparing it.
Yet, as so often happened with him, what put me out momentarily, set me free as the expected reaction from him could not have done; it was not necessary to pretend anything, even understanding. I could be curious about the old portraits looking down on us. They were his father's parents: “The old chap was supposed to be a Talmudic scholar. I don't quite know what the Christian equivalent of that would be. ⦠The Talmudâit's a kind of book of religious philosophy. Somewhere in every Jewish family they've got a Talmudic scholar preserved, it's a distinction none of us can afford to be without. Like ours, he's usually dead, but there are stories about how during his life time he spent his days and nights poring over books of wisdomâyou know, the Talmud's rather like Shakespeare or
Finnegans Wake
nowâhundreds of different interpretations of the text and scholastic arguments which die unsolved with their protagonists.âHe doesn't look much of a scholar, does he?”
We looked the old man in the eye.
I laughed. “She looks the brainy one.”
“She was the go-getter. These Talmudic scholars are nice for prestige, but mostly they don't make a living. With him I really think it must just have been an excuse to get out of working and hang around the synagogue with his pals.”
“You make it sound like the men's commonroom.”
He pulled his nose down sardonically, laughing. “Now you see
where I get it from. The family glories in the education I'm getting myself, while really all I'm doing is learning to play a devastating hand at bridge.âBut seriously, as soon as any member of a Jewish family shows any inclination even vaguely connected with learningâit could be stamp-collecting or pornographyâeverybody starts wagging their heads: he's just like old Uncle so-and-so, so studious.
⦠She
took in dressmaking to keep the family.” Under her eyes, we wandered back to Joel's room; she had the imagined power of the dead and alien to fasten her look far beyond the frame or carved limits of their presence; like the face of the idol whose symbolism you do not understandâis he to bring rain, corn or protection?âbut whose jeweled eye you feel long after you have left the temple.
I left the house just before lunch with two of Joel's books under my armâone was always taking something from him, he was one of those people who give out of a sufficiency in themselves, welling up beautifully to a constant level no matter how often dipped into, and quite independent of material possession or the condescension of generosity. His father had come home but I did not see him, although I could hear, in the back of the house, a heavy tread and a moody voice speaking another language. Joel hung on the gate making a ridge of his brows against the sun. There was a fascination about the way he looked in the full sun; the fascination I had felt in the faces of Indian waiters serving food in Durban hotels. That steely darkness of black curly hairâperhaps it was just that his hair was like theirs. But their faces came up in the sun as his did. The quiet-colored faces and neutral hair among which I had grown up had a way of almost disappearing in bright sunlight, only a sear of gleam here and there traced their light-flattened contours, and they blinked laughter, as if the brightness were a hand pushed in their faces. Ludi was something else again; his brightness took on brightness, like metal.
One could not know whether it was the sun or thought that was making Joel frown. His hesitation made me wait. When we had already said good-by, he asked: “Shall I come to you, now?”
I felt I understood what he meant. One could have a friendship in a train that could exist for years outside one's life as an entity, but once one met and talked at home instead of between here and
there, one part of one's life and another, the friend of the train moved in to one's life. “Yes, what about one evening? Tuesdayâno, that's the night I get back late. Wednesday, then?”
But he said, as if it suddenly didn't matter: “Oh, we don't have to fix it now.” Then he smiled on an inner comment. “Right,” he said, dismissing it, very friendly, and with a little wave, turned up the path. When I looked back as I turned the corner, to take in a last curious impact of that little house, I saw he had not gone in but was still standing there, on the veranda steps, watching me go or staring at some object of his own.
Joel came to the Mine several times and my mother received him without remark. She spoke to him for a few minutes with the usual slightly arch pleasantness which she showed toward my contemporariesâher whole manner on a higher, soprano key, like an actress helping across some lines whose meaning she feels may not be clearâand then left us on the fly-screened porch that was full of the flowered cotton chair covers and embroidered cushions she had made, the sawdust-stuffed stocking cat that held the door open. At four o'clock she came out with a tea tray laid with fresh linen and, not the best cups, but a little twosome breakfast set that was not in common use. I recognized in Joel's serious, careful manner that she was even pretty, with her thin, dry-skinned face and her red hair only slightly faded by the curls that the hairdresser steamed into it once a week, now that it was cut, and the almost antiseptic scent of lavender water that waved out of the flounces of her dress. She was even well dressed, in what I was now beginning to recognize was the Mine style: the flower-patterned, unobtrusive blues and pinks of English royalty.
My father spoke to Joel about “your people” and “the customs of your people” with the same air he used to surprise the Portuguese market gardener with a few words of Portuguese, or, when once we drove through Zululand, a Zulu tribesman with a brisk question in his own language. But though I sat in awkward silence, Joel answered with patient explanation, as the cultured native of a country ignores the visitor's proud clumsy mouthing of a few words of vulgar patois, and returns patronage with the compliment of pretending to
mistake it for real interest. “That's a well-mannered boy,” my father informed me. “They know how to bring their children up to respect older people. And of course they're clever, it goes without saying.”
Some weeks later I told my mother that Joel had asked me to go with him to a faculty dance. She put down an armful of clean laundry in alarm. “You wouldn't go when Basil asked you! And the Blake boy.”
“So?”
She stood there looking at me. Her face had the fixed, sham steadiness of someone who does not know how to say the unexpected. The impact of her thoughts left a sort of stinging blankness on her cheeks. As usual, she took refuge in an unspecified umbrage, her suffering of a complaint against me for which I must bear the burden of guilt without knowing its cause. She buried herself in the counting of shirts, left my pile of underclothing and handkerchiefs abandoned on the kitchen chair and swept away with the rest of the bundle to the linen cupboard.
I went after her. “Why don't you want me to go?”
Her tactics were common ones, and always the same: she went about a succession of household tasks with swift effort as if you were merely a distraction on the perimeter of her concentration of duty. When, as a child, I had wanted to be forgiven for some piece of naughtiness, I had had to follow her about the house like this, watching her hard, slender hands ignoring me. I asked her again:
“Why shouldn't I go?”
She hated to answer. By withholding her complaints, her accusations, her arguments, she withheld also the risk of their refutation and kept for herself the cold power of the wronged.
So now she said tightly: “You wouldn't go with Basil or the other one.”
I laughed. “Because I didn't want to.”
“They're not your type.” It was a quotation.