‘Absolutely not.’
‘Did you start any rumors? Is that what you did?’
‘No! Susan, I did nothing illegal. We just had a hunch. Call it a lucky hunch.’
‘Then why are you telling me this? I’m not interested in your hunches.’
‘Because the way the president’s talking,’ said Grey, ‘the way you’re talking when I see you on TV, it’s like you think the Chinese started it. You think they had some kind of political plan. That’s not what happened. I had a hunch and I shorted Fidelian.’
‘Did you know it was on the brink of twenty-three billion in writedowns?’
‘No.’
‘Then what was the hunch, Ed?’
‘It was … it was a hunch, Susan. We did some analysis. We had a hunch there were a bunch of banks that probably weren’t as strong as they looked and were overpriced. I didn’t expect any of them to go bankrupt.’
‘Not even Fidelian?’
‘No.’
‘Do you know anything about the process by which Bill Custler decided not to take the rescue offer?’
‘No. I’ve never spoken to Bill Custler in my life.’
‘From some other source?’
‘No.’
‘So what you called to tell me,’ said Opitz, ‘is that the origin of this crisis doesn’t lie with the PIC or the Chinese government, but with you. With a hunch you had that you could make some money by shorting Fidelian? Is that it, Ed?’
‘That’s right.’
‘That’s a hell of a story, Ed. Maybe one day you could write a book about it.’
‘Susan, it’s true.’
‘I’m not saying it isn’t. What does intrigue me, Ed, is why you thought you should tell me.’
‘Because it shows it’s not a political crisis. There isn’t any big political conspiracy here. That’s not how it started. It started with someone – me – taking a bet. It’s what happens every day. It’s the markets.’
There was silence for a moment, then Opitz started to laugh.
‘What? You don’t believe me?’
‘No, I do, Ed. I do.’
‘Then what’s funny?’
‘You are. Calling to tell me. Where have you been, Ed? Don’t you know what happened today?’
‘Of course I know what happened today! Hell, Susan, my fund’s falling apart in front of my eyes.’
‘I’m sorry, but–’
‘Suspend mark to market! For Christ’s sake, Susan, suspend mark to market and let some of us survive.’
‘Is that what you rang to tell me?’ demanded Opitz angrily.
‘No! I rang to tell you that I started it. I rang to tell you it isn’t political.’
‘It is now. Ed, it doesn’t matter how it started. Don’t you get it? That doesn’t matter any more.’
‘Then what are you going to do?’
‘Wait and see.’
‘For God’s sake, Susan, I’m telling you what to do. Suspend mark to market! Suspend it now!’
Grey was desperate. He was down on his knees. Literally, in his apartment, the phone shaking in his hand. This wasn’t what he had rung to say but it burst out of him. It was his only chance of survival. ‘Suspend it, Susan! Suspend mark to market!’
Opitz listened to him in distaste. Grey was sobbing.
‘Suspend it. Please! Please! For God’s sake–’
‘We’ll do what we have to do,’ said Opitz, and she put down the phone.
LIU’S VOICE WAS agitated. There was no small talk or introduction. The first words out of his mouth after Ellman picked up the phone were an abrupt, direct question.
‘Marion, why are you doing this?’
Ellman closed her eyes for a moment before replying. ‘The US government believes this is the right thing to do.’
‘The resolution won’t pass.’
‘Simon, that’s up to you.’
‘Not only us. There are others.’
That wasn’t quite right. Marion knew that the UK had the votes to pass its South Africa resolution on the numbers. It was only a veto that would stop it.
The agitation in the Chinese ambassador’s voice became greater. ‘Marion, I don’t understand what your president thinks he is doing. Do you understand? Can you explain to me?’
Ellman didn’t respond.
‘You need our help. You need our help on your economy. You need our help on your soldiers in Sudan. But all we get are demands. Is this the way one asks for help?’
There was no point telling him that she didn’t think it was much of a way to ask for help either. The president wasn’t going to change his approach.
‘Simon, we see these issues as so clear cut. I don’t think we see these as demands. We see these as what any member of the international community ought to do for the sake of any member it regards as a friend. Help get its soldiers who are being held illegally. Help restore confidence in its economy. Why wouldn’t you do these things if you’re our friend?’
‘Do we not regard you as a friend? Show me what we have done that says we are not a friend.’
‘These are the things. These things we’ve been asking about.’
‘No,
you
are not a friend. A friend does not make demands in public without even giving the other the chance to act first. A friend waits. A friend trusts that the other one will act and lets him act without speaking in public.’
‘Simon, come on. We asked privately. Secretary Opitz spoke to Minister Bai weeks ago. That wasn’t public. That was private. Like friends. And nothing happened.’
Liu was silent for a moment. She could hear him draw a deep breath.
‘Marion, I’m speaking personally. I shouldn’t do this, but I will. This is not for your government now, this is for you. All we see are demands coming from your president. One demand after the other, in private, in public, everywhere. No one on your side seems to understand this. I’m telling you so you can understand. No one in Beijing can understand how another power can want for help and issue such demands.’
Ellman resisted the temptation to retort that these things only turned into demands because the Chinese government failed to act without being pushed. ‘Simon,’ she said, ‘there’s a simple way to deal with that, and that’s to do what you should do, what any friendly country should do. Instead you threaten to dump our bonds.’
‘Because you threaten to make restrictions. Who made the first threat?’
‘It wasn’t a threat, it’s reality. What choice do we have?’
‘And what choice do
we
have? If you say to someone who owns your assets, we will restrict you, he will sell them! He will sell them while he can!’ Liu’s voice had risen. ‘And now this! This resolution. It will not pass. You know that. If you are in any doubt of it, let me assure you now. It will not pass. What do you think you will achieve?’
‘Simon, it’s a matter of principle. For the United States, democracy is a matter of principle.’
‘And the principle for the United States seems to be,
hit
China whenever you can.’
‘That’s not what it is.’
‘That’s what it looks like. Marion, I am speaking to you out of friendship. I am not authorized to tell you this, but I am telling you. Do you understand, in Beijing, that’s what it looks like? After such a speech from your president! We must lose face everywhere. With other countries. In our own party. With our army. President Zhang cannot lose face like this.’
Marion narrowed her eyes. ‘Simon, what’s going on?’
Liu was silent for a moment. ‘I don’t understand how your president doesn’t see what he is doing. Does no one tell him? Does Secretary Livingstone not tell him?’
‘Simon, if your government would just do the couple of things it needs to do … If it would help get our men out, if it would just say it didn’t manipulate Fidelian … That’s all you need to do. Things of simple decency. Your president could get our guys out of Sudan tomorrow.’
‘Do you think so?’ demanded Liu. ‘Is it so simple?’
Marion was stumped at that, wondering if it was possible that the Sudanese government wouldn’t respond to a demand from Zhang. They were almost entirely dependent on the Chinese for their foreign income.
‘Why does he care about your men who you sent in without consultation?’
‘Simon, come on, we passed a resolution–’
‘Only because we let you!’
‘He could get up and make a speech about Fidelian tonight. Just two minutes, that’s all it would take.’
‘Why should he do it?’ There was incredulity in Liu’s voice. ‘Why should he? Marion, it is not so simple.’
‘Simon, you keep saying that. What do you mean?’
‘Why does he care about your bank if you can’t manage your own system? Why should he help someone who makes such demands? And now someone who brings this vote.’
‘We’re not bringing it. The United Kingdom is bringing it.’
‘You could have stopped them.’
‘They’re determined to bring it.’
‘Then don’t support it!’
Marion was silent for a moment. ‘Simon, I still don’t understand why you keep saying this isn’t simple. Sure, it’s complicated, but it can be done. What’s going on?’
There was silence. Marion waited, frowning, to hear what the Chinese ambassador would reply.
‘Where is this ending?’ demanded Liu suddenly. ‘Does your president know that? Tell me, Marion, before he began to escalate like this, does he know where the exit is?’
‘There’s no escalation intended.’
‘No? Well, there is escalation. Let me say to you, the United States is not in the strong position. It is not China’s men who are captured in Sudan. It is not China’s economy that is in such trouble.’
‘If it’s our economy, it’s yours. There’s no separating them. You know that. If we suffer, you’ll suffer.’
‘Yes, but who will last the longer? Who will suffer the more? Is that what President Knowles wants to find out?’
‘Simon, this is not the way we should be talking. No one wants any suffering. This is not the way the president’s thinking.’
‘Good. Then do not support this resolution.’
‘Liu, there’s only so much I can do.’
‘You still have time. Speak to your president.’
‘Simon, I can’t–’
‘Marion, do not do this. Do not do it.’
‘Simon, is that you speaking, or your government?’
‘Listen to me,’ said Liu. ‘I have rung you to tell you this. Just listen to what I have said to you.’
There was silence for a moment, then the phone went dead.
Marion put it down slowly.
She sat back in her chair, a frown on her face. She brought her hands together under her chin. The frown deepened.
Liu could have been trying to manipulate her. When a diplomat said he was speaking personally, or confidentially, or on his own initiative, you always had to be wary. When he said he was speaking out of friendship, you had to be even warier.
It was possible that China didn’t want to be seen vetoing the South Africa resolution that the UK was about to bring to the Security Council. This could have been a last attempt on his part to prevent it reaching the chamber. And it had struck her the way Liu’s voice rose a notch when he talked about his government having no choice but to sell their assets once the US government talked about restricting ownership. Maybe that was what they were really worried about, having to sell assets that were plummeting in value. Maybe, if they got the US to back down on the South Africa vote, they could claim it as a victory and magnanimously – condescendingly – agree not to sell their assets as a favor to the US.
Or maybe he wasn’t manipulating her. Maybe he was genuine. Marion didn’t know him well enough to tell. And the part about Zhang losing face with the army and the party, and things not being simple … He must have been referring to internal tensions. Marion ran the words again in her mind, trying to be sure she had really heard Liu say what she thought she had heard. What was going on inside the regime that the US didn’t know about? A conflict like this would always be likely to bring tensions out. But was there anything new? Was Zhang in trouble?
Marion feared for the effect this vote would have. Liu could have been trying to manipulate her or not – it didn’t really matter. What mattered was that she agreed with him.
The first thing she would do would be to send an urgent report of this conversation to Bob Livingstone, Gary Rose, Director of National Intelligence Ryan Ferris and the president, highlighting Liu’s hints that Zhang was under pressure and her belief that the US position on the resolution should be reconsidered before the vote on the following day. Yet she knew there were no ears in the White House for that message or pretty much anything else that came from the State Department.
Ellman didn’t like the way this administration had begun to act over the past few months and the way Bob Livingstone and State were being shut out. She was a moderate Republican, at best, and she had the feeling that she was increasingly out of step with the forces driving policy inside the White House. There were too many compromises and she could only see them getting worse. Marion knew she would have to raise her hand in support of that vote tomorrow, despite the fact that she firmly believed the United States should have acted to prevent it being brought to the Council. That happened. Any diplomat has to expect to put arguments she doesn’t believe in from time to time. But as UN ambassador, she expected at the least to have a say in the debate. If there had been a debate, she hadn’t been part of it.
In the past few days, Marion Ellman had begun to wonder whether she should resign.
She knew that she was tired and overworked. She knew her state of mind might be influenced by that. It had been an intense and difficult fall. Christmas was only a week away and psychologically that had become a kind of target for her. She was hanging on for Christmas, and then, with a week off and some time with Dave and the kids, she hoped things would be clearer.
THE NEXT DAY, Marion Ellman entered the Security Council chamber and took her seat. Antony Seale, already present in the chair beside her, leaned over and welcomed her.
Her intervention in the debate was short. Seale had already made a long speech setting out the reasons for bringing a Chapter VII resolution calling for the immediate restoration of constitutional rule in South Africa and the holding of free and fair elections within three months, with the threat of sanctions if the ANC government failed to comply. There was little more for her to say than to set out the United States’ support for the British position.
Liu watched her. Every minute of the debate, she could feel his eyes boring into her.
When Mohammed Razak, the Malaysian ambassador who was serving as the Council’s president for the month, called for those who were voting in favor, she raised her hand. Liu shook his head and closed his eyes in despair.
A moment later Razak called for those voting no. Immediately Liu’s hand was in the air.