Most of the time, of course, nothing made sense at all. As the heat spell broke but our money continued to melt away, Jack grew petulant and unpredictable. He told me a thousand times and occasionally in tears that our lives weren’t the way he’d planned them, but I still found myself watching him too carefully and working too hard to predict his reactions. If I’d stopped to think about it, I would have realized that all of that work was more than a little like living with Raeburn again, except this time I didn’t have my brother to catch me when I fell down on the job. But I didn’t stop to think about it. Sometimes he said that coming to get me was the best thing he’d ever done and sometimes he said it was the worst. I was never afraid of him the way I was of Raeburn. He was just angry, and I was just in the way.
One night, when our bankroll had shrunk to a couple of crumpled bills at the bottom of a coffee can, Jack brought home a bottle of cheap rotgut whiskey. He drank his straight; I mixed mine with watery lemonade from a plastic jug. After I’d had two drinks and Jack had slugged most of the rest straight from the bottle, he watched as I took a used coffee stirrer and mixed round three in a plastic cup.
“How the hell can you drink that?” he asked.
“There’s pretty much nothing I can do to it that will make it taste any worse than it does on its own.” I wasn’t really complaining, but Jack was drunk, and snide.
“Sorry,” he said. “Sorry we can’t afford Chivas this week, prima donna.”
“Relax. We’ll drink Chivas next week.”
“How magnanimous of you, princess.” He took the bottle back from me.
I stared at him. In my plastic cup, the yellow liquid swirled and sloshed. “You’re the one who wanted to come here,” I said.
“Not like I had a whole hell of a lot of options, having to drag you around with me, did I? In fact”—his voice grew fake-bright—“I seem to remember that it wasn’t until I went and got you that my problems started.”
Sure, shacking up with Becka was the high life, I wanted to say. Instead I said, “Come on, Jack,” and threw the stirrer out the open window.
Without speaking, he stood up and went to the sink. The apartment was stifling and hot. He turned on the water, leaned over, and splashed handful after handful on the back of his neck. Outside, there were car horns honking and people shouting.
I rose as quietly as I could and went to him. But when I tried to touch his shoulder he wheeled around and slapped my hand away, hard.
“Say it, little sister. Fucking say it.” He was livid. “I came along and ruined your life, didn’t I? You were happy as a little princess with Daddy on the Hill and I waltzed in and now you’re living in squalor. And that’s all my fault, isn’t it?” Water stood out in beads on his skin. He pushed past me and grabbed the whiskey bottle again.
“Prima donna,” he muttered. He tipped the bottle to his lips, found it empty, and hurled it against the wall. It didn’t break. “Fucking prima donna.”
My hands clenched into fists. “Okay,” I said, “you ruined my life. But all you ever talk about is how great life was when you were on your own—how easy and fun it all was, how many girls you had—so I guess I ruined your life, too, didn’t I? You ruined mine, I ruined yours, and it’s all my fault. Except for the fact that it wasn’t me that moved in with Becka Capriola, and it wasn’t me who got us kicked out.”
“You didn’t help.”
“I didn’t beat her up, either,” I said, and he hit me.
It was only a slap across the face. It stung but it wasn’t even hard enough to unbalance me. Wildly, I thought, is this real? Did that happen? Is this real?
Jack was staring at the hot place on the side of my face. Suddenly he sprang back as if he were the one who’d been slapped. “Oh, sure. I’m the violent son of a bitch who beats up his poor little sister. Everything that’s wrong with the world is my fault.” Veins stood out in cords on his wrists; he didn’t seem to see me anymore. His eyes were alive with rage. I realized that Jack was in a different world now. Whatever was wrong with him, I had to get out of his way until it was over, so I ran.
I had never needed to run from my brother before. For two hours I walked aimlessly past streetlights and police cars and panhandlers, past arguing couples and kissing couples. I saw them, registered them as obstacles, and avoided them, but my mind was caught on things like the keys I’d left behind, and why we had only one set, and why I hadn’t had my own set made. Towels. Why didn’t we have more than one towel? We should have more towels, and sheets, too. Even though we didn’t have a bed yet. We would someday, and we’d need sheets. We had separate toothbrushes, but only one pillow. We weren’t prepared for this at all. Of course, we hadn’t exactly planned anything. Why hadn’t we planned anything?
I turned a corner and found myself facing a broad highway. Across it, the lights of New Jersey sparkled in the Hudson River. I’d walked all the way across the island. I stared at the dark water for a long time. Then I turned my back on it and kept walking.
A week later Jack and I were standing under an awning at the corner of Thirty-fifth Street and Park Avenue while soft, heavy drops of rain fell onto the sidewalk. Jack had decided that we were going to be criminals.
He was holding a crisp new fifty-dollar bill against the wall of the nearest building. The fifty, along with the $7.61 in my pocket, was all the money we had in the world. We were in trouble.
“O ye of little faith,” he said and showed me the bill, on which he’d written, “Happy Birthday Josie!!! from your Loving Aunt Becka,” in a looping feminine script.
“Very funny,” I said. “This isn’t going to work.”
“You have a better idea?” I didn’t and we both knew it. He put the bill in his pocket and told me to follow him. “We’ve got to keep close, but not look like we’re together.”
I did as he said, following him into a well-lit coffee shop down the street. The shop was packed with people on their lunch breaks. Jack went ahead of me and bought a sandwich, which had to be made up behind the counter. I took my time at the refrigerator case next to the register, picking up cartons of yogurt and reading the nutrition information until his sandwich was wrapped and on the counter in front of him. Then I grabbed a carton at random and joined the line, two or three customers behind him.
The girl at the counter was busy and frazzled. Jack used the marked fifty to pay for his sandwich, and then walked out of the store without looking at me, heading toward the river and the park where we’d agreed to meet. I would pay for my purchases with the five I had in my pocket, and then tell the clerk that I’d given her the fifty with the phony birthday message on it. The bill would be in her drawer; she’d have no reason not to believe in my Loving Aunt Becka, so she’d give me change for the fifty and I’d leave more than forty-five dollars ahead.
Jack had come up with the idea. I thought it was absurd. Worse than absurd: it was reckless and doomed to fail, and it reeked of desperation. But that stench had been too strong lately, so Jack’s plan had to work. And because I was younger, and a girl, and more innocent-seeming, I had to make it work.
The cashier took the five from my shaking hand and made change without ever really looking at me. I was grateful for that.
“Next,” she said.
I stared into my hand for a second, as Jack had told me to, and then smiled sheepishly and said, “Excuse me,” thinking, this is insane, this isn’t going to work, why am I the one who has to do this?
The cashier was ringing up the next customer. Stuffing the change from the five into my pocket and walking out would have been the easiest thing in the world. I would tell Jack that I hadn’t been able to convince her that the fifty was mine.
“Excuse me,” I said again, louder. “I gave you a fifty.”
The girl glanced up briefly. “You gave me a five.”
“Look,” I said, “I’m sorry, but I’m sure it was a fifty.”
Finally she looked at me. Her hair, which had obviously been twisted up neatly and with great care that morning, was falling around her ears.
“You gave me a five, miss,” she said.
“You put it under your cash tray.” I tried the embarrassed smile again and said, “This is stupid, but my aunt sent it to me. I think she wrote a message on it—happy birthday or something. Take a look.”
She jerked the cash tray roughly out of the drawer. There were three fifties sitting there, one of which was Jack’s.
“She always uses purple ink,” I said.
She swore under her breath, quickly counted out forty-five dollars from the tray, and shoved the wad of cash toward me.
“Sorry about that. Next,” she said with finality.
“No problem,” I said, and a few steps later I was outside. A man in a suit was holding the door open for me, waiting impatiently for me to step out so he could enter. The drizzle had stopped. It was over. I’d done it.
I half-ran the few blocks to the deserted playground where Jack sat in the shelter of a wooden climbing structure, waiting for me next to a sign that said, “Adults are not allowed beyond this point unless accompanied by a child.” Half of his sandwich was sitting neatly on its paper in front of him. He grinned when he saw me and I felt myself smile back. It had worked. We had money. Jack was going to be impressed. More than impressed: proud.
“Here,” he said and pushed the sandwich toward me. I ducked under the structure, just as a voice over my shoulder said, “That was dumb.”
I turned.
The girl standing behind me had a wide mouth painted bright red and tiny ferretlike ears. The pale blond hair that curled behind them obviously hadn’t been that color to begin with, and her brilliant eyes matched her high black boots. She was wearing a ridiculous raincoat—clear plastic with silver glitter embedded in it—over something fuzzy and pink.
Jack’s eyes widened slightly. Then he gave the girl a sleepy, innocent look. “What?”
“Stupid,” the girl said. “I saw the ink when you paid. You shouldn’t have used purple—too bright.” Her tone said, quite clearly, that she would have caught us; we never would have gotten past her.
“Leave us alone, why don’t you,” I said.
Her eyes measured me coolly. Then she stepped forward. Ducking, she joined us under the structure. Jack moved to make room for her.
“Why should I?” She shook the rain from her sparkly raincoat.
I looked her over, from the tips of her bleached hair to the pinched toes of her expensive boots. There was nothing I liked about her.
But Jack was smiling and he said admonishingly, “Be nice, Jo.”
“Don’t be an idiot.” I was trying to warn him.
“That’s not being very nice, Jo,” the girl said, in the same tone Jack had used.
I moved to my brother’s side and touched the small of his back unobtrusively. “Jack, let’s go. Let’s get out of here.”
“Jack,” the girl said, and then said it again, slowly, as if she were holding his name in her mouth and waiting for it to dissolve like candy. She stepped forward, held out one slender, white, carefully manicured hand. “I’m Lily, Jack.”
I said, “Can we go?” and Jack said, folding his tanned hand over hers, “I’m Jack, Lily.”
My brother had beautiful hands. They were slender and long-fingered, with strong bones hidden under the skin like roots in the earth. His hands adjusted spark plugs, solved equations in Greek letters, and lifted bottles to his lips with the same uncanny grace—as though they were independent and alive, moving like caged things, like beasts. I have a catalog of mental snapshots of my brother that I flip through when the world seems too alien; I think of his hands, and thinking of his hands always leads to that humid, drizzling day and his hand closing over Lily’s like a sea creature over its small, defenseless prey.
Jack and Lily were the same kind of animal. Watching them together was like watching two cats that haven’t decided whether to fight or mate. When she took us to dinner that night, she took the best table, right in front, without waiting for the waiter to lead us there, and ordered wine by the label without even looking at the list. It was a good restaurant; I was wearing my newest-looking sundress and my sandals, the nicest clothes I had, and I felt cheap and shabby. Jack was wearing a T-shirt and jeans and he looked wonderful.
“You should have the sea bass in peanut sauce,” she said to me, leaning in as though we were girls sharing secrets. We’d spent most of the day sitting in coffee shops with formless, atonal music and fabric-covered walls. Once she knew that Jack was my brother, she started to treat me as his harmless little sister instead of a threat. I’d made no such decision about her. But Jack had asked me very nicely while she was getting more steamed milk for her latte if I didn’t think I could be a little bit less of a hostile bitch. I was trying.
Now she tapped the menu with one glossy, white-tipped fingernail. “It’s not on the menu. Or, rather, it is, but with chicken. It’s better with sea bass.”
“Will they do that?”
“Of course they will. I don’t eat chicken, anyway. No chickens, no pigs, no cows, no ducks.”
“But you’ll eat sea bass,” Jack said.
Her scarlet lips curled in a coy smile. “I’ve eaten fish while they were still flopping. Fish don’t feel pain.” She stared at him over the rim of her wine glass.
I said, “That can’t be true. I don’t think that’s true.”
There was a thin silver case sitting on the table. She took a cigarette from it and lit it, letting the match burn all the way to her fingers and taking a long, deep drag before answering me.
“Of course it’s true.” She sounded bored and petulant. Twin wisps of smoke drifted from her nostrils. She seemed to smoke solely for punctuation. “They’re too stupid.”
After dinner, we went to a bar where everyone seemed to be a friend or a friend of a friend of Lily’s, and then to another bar, and then another. All of them were dimly lit and crowded and all the friends and friends of friends drank bright pink cosmopolitans with yellow lemon peels in them like floating scabs, and after half a dozen drinks I stopped noticing when we moved on. Lily seemed to have friends everywhere, but maybe we only went to the places where she had friends. Everywhere we went, she took my brother’s hand and whisked him off to meet somebody or other, and I followed. Jack was charming, I was ignored, and very quickly I was drunk.