Authors: Janette Rallison
“Chrissy!”
Still nothing. It occurred to me that in the story of Cinderella the fairy godmother never came back to check on Cinderella, not even when the messenger came and her stepmother locked her in her bedroom. Really, what was the point of having a fairy godmother if she was never around when you needed her?
I laid my head back against the wall, trying to breathe as normally as possible with a gag stuck in my mouth, and wondered what the king would do with me. Perhaps he just wanted to punish me for ruining his best chance to get rid of the Black Knight.
I shivered and tried not to think of that possibility.
The stroke of midnight came and went. I knew because my dress turned back into a towel. Which was just 394/431
one more reason that I didn’t want to face the king. But eventually I heard voices on the stairs. Angry voices, like gears grinding into overdrive. Moments later King Roderick and Prince Edmond strode through the door. Edmond stopped just inside the doorway. He folded his arms and stared at me grimly.
King Roderick marched over to me, still panting from the climb. He raised his sword to my face. For a moment I thought he would slash me with it. I held my breath and shut my eyes tightly, but he only cut off the gag, then bent down and moved it away from my mouth.
After he’d straightened up he regarded me with fierce eyes. “You have many things to explain.” He took a step back from me, resting his sword at his side. “You are an enchantress?”
“No.” My mouth was dry and the word fell from my lips like chalk.
“But you are full of enchantments or your fine gown and jewels wouldn’t have disappeared.” I felt my cheeks go hot. “That’s not an enchantment, just some fairy magic for the evening. Something I wished for long ago.” I looked at Edmond, trying to see any sign of kindness in his face, but all of his earlier admiration for me was gone. He watched me with narrowed eyes.
395/431
King Roderick waved his hand in my direction as though erasing the subject. “I’m not concerned with fairy trinkets. Those mean nothing now. What I want is the identity of the Black Knight. You will tell us who he is.”
“I don’t know who he is,” I said.
“Pity. Then we’ll have to do things another way.” His grip tightened on the hilt of his sword. “Because you will help us to identify him.”
“How could I—”
But he didn’t give me time to finish. He bent down and grabbed my chin. “The Black Knight said you couldn’t tell a lie in front of him or your tongue would burn out of your mouth. This is true?” I didn’t answer, just gulped. I was beginning to understand what he wanted.
Still grasping my chin, King Roderick said, “I will drag every nobleman, farm boy, and merchant from the entire kingdom into this room. One by one you will lie to them. And when your tongue burns out of your mouth, we will know who the Black Knight is.” He let go of my chin and turned to his son. “Tell the guards and the scribes what I want them to do. We’ll start with the castle household and move on from there.
How many guests do we have staying the night?”
“Enough to keep us busy till daybreak,” Edmond said.
396/431
“Start with the guardhouse.”
They walked toward the door, making plans. They’d almost gone before I called out, “Edmond!” He paused at the doorway and looked back at me.
“Edmond, don’t do this.” I pulled at the rope around my wrists, even though I knew it was pointless. “Just hours ago you wanted to marry me.” His gaze ran over me with cold calculation. “And you’re just as beautiful now as you were in jewels and a gown. It’s almost enough to make me think that I could overlook your odd behavior at the ball.” He shook his head slowly. “But you kissed the Black Knight—my enemy. And
that
I could never forgive.” The door shut with a thud. I was left alone in the room, my heart beating as quickly as if I’d just run a mile.
I had to get away, but I’d already tried and I couldn’t.
No, I had to figure out who the Black Knight was so I didn’t have to lie to men until my tongue burned away.
There had to be clues. He said he was young and handsome. What else did I know about him?
He was a knight. Knights needed help getting in and out of their armor so he had to at least have one other person somewhere helping him . . . and he was a good kisser. That probably wasn’t helpful. What else?
397/431
My mind was blank except for the panic that gnawed at the edges of my thoughts. I didn’t know enough.
Back at the inn, Chrissy said I was smart enough to figure it out—okay, actually she’d been talking about the stolen poison, and I hadn’t figured that out either.
The poison . . . For a moment it took center stage in my mind. Who had Simon stolen it for? Perhaps Queen Neferia— she had an apple to poison. But she could have bought it right from the wizard. Why would she have needed Simon to steal it and sell it to her?
No, it had to be for someone else, which led me back to the first suspect, Margaret. She was involved with both Simon and the Black Knight. But how and why?
The three of them circled in my mind. If she was in love with the Black Knight, why not just leave with him?
No one could stop her. Tristan had said he’d heard her tell a lady’s maid that she didn’t care if a man was lowborn as long as he was ambitious.
Certainly he was ambitious enough. He kept challenging Prince Edmond. But if he was trying to take over the kingdom, why didn’t he just challenge the king?
Wouldn’t that have been the thing to do? Even if he killed Prince Edmond, he wouldn’t be king. Roderick still would be.
398/431
Did he have a grudge against Edmond? There had been that whole matter of the peasant rebellion he’d put down.
And how did Simon work into all of this? Did he just have a business arrangement with Margaret—selling her stolen potions—or was there something more to it? My mind jumped at the thought—could he be the Black Knight? He was young and handsome. He had access to magic and was stealing things from the wizard, so he might have been able to come up with the invincibility enchantment. Margaret could be in love with him. He was around the castle enough to form an attachment with her. It all fit . . . except that he was a goat now.
Oh, and I guess he wouldn’t have stood there and let the wizard give me the switching potion if he was the Black Knight.
But . . . he hadn’t had a choice about that. It was the wizard who sold me the switching potion, and Simon hadn’t looked happy about it at the time. If he was the Black Knight—no, he wouldn’t have cared if I’d taken switching potion if he’d been the Black Knight because he would have known not to kiss me—but if Simon was in league with the Black Knight, then he would have been worried about me taking away the knight’s enchantment.
399/431
This seemed to fit, to make sense. After all, the Black Knight had truth potion on him when I’d met him. He had to be working with some wizard. And Simon had sold me a vial of something and told me to drink it when I saw the Black Knight. Poison would have taken care of any threat I’d posed.
The knowledge spun around in my mind, fear mixing with excitement. I’d been right the first time. The poison had been for me.
So they were both in league with the Black Knight—
Margaret and Simon—but who was he?
The door swung open. A guard came inside, followed by King Roderick. My time was up, and I still hadn’t figured out who the Black Knight was.
The king had his sword drawn; the guard didn’t have one. He stood at attention, looking stoic and uncomfortable at the same time. King Roderick motioned to me.
“Well, be quick about it. Tell a lie and let’s see what happens.”
“I’m not going to sit here and lie until my tongue burns away.”
The king stepped toward me, examining my face. “I assume you meant that as a lie, because you
are
going to sit here and do just that.”
I fingered the fireplace stones beneath my fingers, wishing I could break the rope. “You’re a tyrant.” 400/431
“I’ll take that as a lie and not an insult, but why don’t you try one more time just to make sure that Henry here is not the man I’m looking for.” He lifted his sword, held its tip against my cheek, and moved it down to my neck slowly, precisely. He didn’t mean to draw blood, not yet.
When he spoke, his voice was deceptively soft. “You will do as I say, or you’ll lose much more than your tongue tonight.”
“Ask your daughter who the Black Knight is. She knows.”
The blade pressed harder against my neck. “More treason. You will not speak ill of my daughter. She knows her place. I suggest you learn the same.” It was then that I remembered something about fairy tales. Hansel and Gretel, the smallest billy goat gruff, Puss in Boots— they never conquered through strength.
It was always through outwitting those who were stronger than they were.
I drew in a careful breath. “I have a better way to help you find the Black Knight, but you’ll have to untie me first and give me some clothes.” The king shook his head. “I think that’s too subtle of a lie. Why don’t you say something along the lines of, ‘I am a spotted bird.’ Try that one, and let’s see what happens.”
401/431
I leaned forward, trying to show him I meant it. “I can find him for you.”
“You said you didn’t know who he was.”
“I don’t, but I still can identify him. He kissed me, after all. You don’t think he did that without taking off his helmet, do you?”
The king let his sword fall back at his side and took a step away from me, considering. “How will you find him?”
“Bring all of the nobles, any man who is rich at all, to the ballroom.”
“And how do you know he is a rich man?”
“When he kissed me he didn’t smell bad. He’s wealthy enough to bathe regularly.”
The king nodded, pleased with this information. He walked to the guard, sniffing. “Well, Henry, it looks like you’re innocent by that account. Go tell all the guards to assemble our fine guests in the ballroom.” He turned back to me. “I’ll have clothes sent to you, but I warn you, if you try to escape, if you cross me in any way, I’ll cut off your fingers and use them as chess pieces. Do you understand?”
I nodded and shivered again. “Will you let me go once I’ve found him for you?”
He smiled at me. “Of course.” But even though I didn’t have any truth potion, I knew he was lying.
402/431
I had to find a way to escape.
King Roderick sent me a pale linen dress that probably belonged to Margaret. He also sent in three husky washerwomen to cut my ropes and make sure I didn’t escape while I dressed.
I changed quickly, wishing I had shoes. Tristan had my other slipper. Still, I couldn’t bring myself to leave the remaining glass slipper on the floor where it lay. I put it in my pocket. After that I walked to the ballroom, flanked on both sides by guards.
With every step I took I tried to think of ways to escape. It was too dangerous here in the heart of the castle. I’d never be able to make it outside without the guards cutting me down, but once inside the ballroom there was that terrace—the one with the balcony. If I could climb down the vines, perhaps I could lose them in the dark.
Of course, getting over the castle walls would present another problem and I didn’t really have an answer for that.
A guard opened the door and I saw dozens of men standing in a line against the wall. They still wore their finery—silk and velvet tunics, splashes of color against 404/431
the gray stone walls, but they no longer seemed festive.
Their swords had been taken from them and they stared at me silently. King Roderick paced back and forth in front of the men with his sword drawn. Prince Edmond and Prince Hugh were also there, swords hanging at their sides, as though they would contend with anyone who crossed the king. While they spoke to each other, Hugh glanced over at me with a cold stare. I supposed that Edmond had told him what I’d done.
Princess Margaret stood near them, her arms folded tightly across her chest. Two crimson patches of color flushed on her cheeks when she saw me. I wondered if the king had told her of my accusations.
The king saw me and motioned me over. “Here they are. Take a look. Which one is he?”
“I need to ask each of them a question,” I said. “It will take a few minutes.” Instead of giving the king time to protest, I walked to the first man at the end of the line.
He didn’t have the height to be the Black Knight, but still I said, “Answer me yes or no. Are you the Black Knight?”
His voice was clipped with indignation. “No.” I moved to the next man. “Are you the Black Knight?” He shook his head. “Of course not.” 405/431
The king came up behind me, hands on his hips. “This is how you’re going to identify him? You expect one of them to tell you yes?”
“One of them will tell me the truth. Be patient.” The king turned away from me, cursing, but he didn’t stop me. I went down the line asking the same question.
Each time the answer was no.
I listened to them, but half my mind was still trying to piece together what I knew. If Princess Margaret was in love with the Black Knight, they could have run off together long before now . . . so maybe it was Simon she loved. Back when I first met her, she had been waiting for someone who hadn’t come, and Simon wouldn’t have been able to meet her after he was turned into a goat.
Margaret wouldn’t have been able to marry Simon without her father’s permission, so perhaps the two of them had devised a plan with the Black Knight. Maybe Simon was supposed to defeat the Black Knight to win Margaret’s hand. But why hadn’t they done it before now? Why wait? There was still something about the Black Knight I was missing.
I came to the last man in the line. “Are you the Black Knight?”
He shook his head. “I’m certainly not.” The king strode up to my side, his lips set in an angry grimace. “And what was the point of that exercise 406/431
besides wasting my time? You don’t know whom he is at all, do you?”
But I did. It had all just clicked into place. I understood what it was the Black Knight wanted.