Read Nelson: Britannia's God of War Online
Authors: Andrew Lambert
This was, he admitted a guess, but it was based on careful calculation.
67
Other problems were looming, especially the possibility of war with Spain – not that he was behind in his preparations, having exploited a Spanish request to convey a cardinal from Majorca to Rome to obtain a full report on the defences and resources of the island. Pitt, satisfied that Spanish payments to France were a breach of neutrality, decided to force the issue. Orders to seize Spanish treasure ships were issued in mid-September, and on 5 October a brief action between four frigates from each nation in the approaches to Cadiz ended when one Spanish ship blew up and the others surrendered. Nelson did not think the situation had been adequately thought through, and would have preferred to be ready with an adequate force to seize Minorca.
68
This new war arrived just as he heard that his official request for leave had been granted. He decided to stay, and kept his leave a secret. Painfully conscious of his impaired vision, he was thinking about taking a seat at the Admiralty as overall director of the naval forces of the state. Nor was this a delusion, as many have argued following St Vincent’s acid asides. In truth, no one would have been better equipped to lead the officer corps by example and encouragement, rewarding merit and courage, rather than imposing harsh measures and blatant favouritism. Nor could any other officer have equalled his strategic insight and record of accurate analysis of complex situations.
The Spanish war had other consequences. With Nelson expected to return home on leave, the Admiralty despatched Sir John Orde to command a new station in the Atlantic approaches to Cadiz. He was Nelson’s superior in rank, but had a smaller command, fewer ships and less responsibility. As Nelson chose not to go home, it appeared that Orde had merely been sent to reap his ‘golden harvest’.
69
Having made a public complaint about Nelson being given the Mediterranean detachment in 1798 it would have been hard to pick an officer less likely to work well with him. He was not overly concerned about the money – ‘God knows, in my own person, I spend as little money as any man; but you know I love to give away.’
70
But it was the apparent lack of faith in his ability to handle the station that rankled, especially as he had taken immediate steps to meet the need: his reinforcement of Captain Strachan off Cadiz had led to the capture of two frigates before Orde arrived.
Orde soon tired of a position that everyone knew was false, and which he could not fill with dignity or ability equal to his rank. Complaining that Nelson was interfering, he asked to be relieved in March 1805, and was taken at his word by return of mail. Orde was the same petty-minded blockhead who had tried to fight a duel with St Vincent five years before. It seems he had been sent only to annoy the old Earl, who was refusing to go back to sea until Pitt apologised for his remarks in the House of Commons on Admiralty administration during the Addington Ministry.
71
Spain was no longer the sea power she had been in 1796. Her fleet had declined through capture and disaster and had not been adequately replaced. The national coffers had been emptied to buy off Bonaparte, while a terrible outbreak of yellow fever swept across southern Spain, hitting Cadiz and Cartagena particularly hard.
72
The situation was so bad that Orde was directed not to board any Spanish ships he might capture, but to take them into quarantine at Gibraltar.
73
Efforts to mobilise the Spanish fleet were crippled by the loss of craftsmen and seamen, the shortage of food and stores, and above all the lack of hard cash. Gibraltar too was affected by fever: over two thousand people died in a few weeks.
However, the French now demanded Nelson’s full attention. Vice Admiral Pierre Villeneuve, Nile escapee and Napoleon’s ‘lucky’ admiral, now commanded at Toulon. On 18 January he put to sea with eleven battleships, cruisers and six thousand troops. British frigates
quickly reported back to Nelson, who moved to cover Naples and Sicily on the likely track of the enemy. Taking into account the strong winds then blowing, they could only be headed east, so he ran down to the Italian coast, through the Straits of Messina, and by 7 February was off Alexandria. There was no sign of the enemy. By 18 February he knew that the French, crippled by the wind on their first night at sea, had straggled back into Toulon – masts shattered, rigging strained and basic seamanship skills in doubt. Villeneuve was dismayed by the experience; Bonaparte was dismayed by his lack of resolution. Nelson, meanwhile, was concerned that the poor state of the
Royal
Sovereign’s
copper made her too slow for such pursuits.
74
The fleet had suffered no damage in the storms or the pursuit, however, and was ready for another cruise only days after reaching Sardinia on 8 March. Realising Orde had not been sent out to supersede him, Nelson decided to stay until the movements of the French fleet were clear. He was still expecting a battle.
75
A few days later Nile veteran Rear Admiral Sir Thomas Louis joined the fleet with flag Captain Francis Austen, then the best known of the Austen family.
The underlying purpose of Bonaparte’s movements was unclear. Lying in Cawsand Bay, for a brief respite from the hard pounding off Brest, Collingwood recorded his view:
The sort of dilatory war that he is now carrying on against us, is a new system, and of deep policy: – It is war against our trade & finances – a war the object of which is to subject us to great expenses, and diminish our means of supporting them – but experience will teach him the fallacy of his system very soon.
76
This was a typically lucid and penetrating analysis by a master of war. Collingwood was Nelson’s best friend in the service because he was one of the few men to view the world from the same level, and with the same clarity. Nelson agreed, regretting that Orde’s command had broken up his system of Mediterranean trade protection, leading to the loss of one convoy, and risking many more.
77
By this time Bonaparte had switched from trade attack to deception plans to facilitate an invasion, and he continued to change his mind throughout the 1805 campaign. He might outwit Orde, but not Collingwood or Nelson.
Nelson stressed that the key to success in this titanic conflict lay in striking blows in Europe, not frittering away the national resources on ‘buccaneering expeditions’ to the Spanish empire.
78
According to the fleet surgeon’s report, Nelson needed rest and the assistance of an
oculist.
79
Nelson himself complained of ‘heart’ spasms, though they were later diagnosed as indigestion, brought on by tension, lack of exercise and poor diet – but he was worried that a return might be misinterpreted:
The moment I make up my mind the French fleet will not come out this summer, I embark in the
Superb
. My health does not improve; but because I am not confined to my bed, people will not believe my state of health.
80
By the time he wrote, however, the French were already at sea. The final campaign had opened.
1
Nelson to Davison; to St Vincent 6.5.1803; Nicolas V p. 63
2
Admiralty to Bickerton 1.2.1803; ADM 2/1360
3
Admiralty to Bickerton 7.3.1803; ADM 2/1360
4
Admiralty to Bickerton 7.5.1803; ADM 2/1360
5
Ziegler, pp. 197–8
6
Admiralty to Nelson 18.5.1803 Secret; ADM 2/1360. The next Admiralty letter was sent on 9.11.1803
7
Nelson to St Vincent 22.5. to Admiralty and Cornwallis 23.5.1805; Nicolas V pp. 71–5. Cornwallis to Nelson 25.5.1803; CRK /2
8
Nelson to Emma 20.5.1803; Morrison II p. 210–1. 23.5.1803; Nicolas V p. 73
9
Scott to Emma 3.6.1803; Nelson to Emma 10.6.1803 Morrison II pp. 212–13. See Nelson to Emma 4.6.1805: Pettigrew II p. 473 and compare with Monmouth EL167 to see how far Pettigrew removed the passion that distinguished this correspondence from that with Fanny.
10
Nelson to Acton 10.6.1803 Public and private letters; he also wrote on the same day to both the King and the Queen; Nicolas V pp. 81–5
11
Nelson to Acton 19.6.1803; Nicolas V p. 92
12
Ferdinand to Nelson 20.6.1803; CRK/3
13
Nelson to Jackson 10.6.1803; to Drummond
c
.11.6.1803; Nicoals V pp. 85–7
14
Nelson to Addington 4.6.1803; Nicolas V p. 79
15
Nelson to Hardy and Admiralty 1.7.1803; Nicolas V pp. 112–14
16
Lord Hobart to Nelson 23.8.1803; Nicolas V pp. 220–1
17
Nelson to Davison 27.7.1803; Nicolas V pp. 143–4
18
Nelson to St Vincent; to Moira 2.7.1803; Nicoals V pp. 114–15
19
Nelson to St Vincent 4.7.1803; Nicolas V pp. 116–17
20
Nelson to Captain Richardson HMS
Juno
26.6.1803; Nicolas V p. 103
21
Nelson to Elliot; to Acton 25.6.1803; there were public and private letters to both men. Nicolas V pp. 95–101
22
Nelson to Villettes 26.6.1803; Nicolas V pp. 104–5
23
Nelson to Clarence 6 and 17.4.1803; Nicolas V pp. 57–9
24
Troubridge to Nelson 27.6.1803; CRK/13
25
Melville to Nelson various; CRK/8. Nelson to Henry Duncan 4.10.1804; Nicolas VI p. 216. Lord Duncan to Nelson 18.7.1803; CRK/4
26
St Vincent to Nelson various 1803–04; CRK/11. Admiral Sir Peter Parker to Nelson 20.8.1803; CRK/10
27
Layman to Nelson 27.6.1803; Add. 34,919 f.173
28
James Duff at Cadiz, Price at Cartagena and Hunter at Madrid all provided vital evidence while Spain remained neutral; CRK/4 /7 /10
29
Duff to Nelson 8.10.1803; CRK/7
30
Foresti to Nelson 2.7.1803; CRK/5. Hawkesbury to Nelson 8.7.1803; CRK/6
31
Noble to Nelson 4.7.1803; CRK/9
32
Wellesley to Nelson 9.11.1803; CRK/13
33
List of books June 1803; Add. 34,919 f. 180
34
Nelson to Davison 24.8.1803; Nicolas V p. 175.
35
Davison to Nelson various; CRK/2
36
Nelson to Emma 5 and 8.7.1803; Nicolas V pp. 117–20
37
Nelson to St Vincent 8 and 13 7.1803; to Villettes 9.7.1803; Nicolas V pp. 122–36
38
Nelson to Elliot 11.7.1803; Nicolas V pp. 129–30
39
Nelson to St Vincent 5.10.1803; Nicolas V p. 223
40
Nicolas prints a sample section for 25–31.10.1803; Nicolas V p. 273
41
Mahan,
Nelson
,
2nd edn. pp. 572–3
42
Nelson to Ball 16.9.1803; Nicolas V pp. 203–5
43
Nelson to Addington 16.7.1803; to St Vincent 21.7.1803; Nicolas V pp. 136–8
44
Drummond to Nelson 22.7.1803; CRK/4
45
This was his ‘Guardian Angel’, painted in Dresden by Schmitt for Hugh Elliot, then British Minister at the Saxon Court..
46
Gatty,
Recollections
of
the
Life
of
the
Reverend
A
J
Scott
DD
Lord
Nelson’s
Chaplain
.provides first-hand testimony, although more interested in the picturesque, and doubtless somewhat censored by contemporary views on the role of intelligence gathering, and Nelson’s private affairs. Reprinted as
Nelson’s
Spy?
in 2003, a title reflecting modern taste.
47
Nelson to Ryves 2.11.1803; to Ball 7.11.1803; Nicolas V pp. 277–8 and 282–4. See Add. 34,919 for a range of Nelson’s chart and intelligence papers, including Ryves’ report.
48
Nelson to Admiralty 12.7.1803; Nicolas V pp. 133–4
49
Baird to Nelson 30.101803; CRK/1
50
Nelson to Moseley 11.3.1804; Nicolas V pp. 437–8
51
Crimmin, ‘Letters and Documents relating to the Service of Nelson’s Ships’
52
Nelson to Minto 11.1.1804; Nicolas V pp. 365–7
53
Mackesy,
War
in
the
Mediterranean
p. 62
54
Nelson to Cornwallis 31.7.1803;
Manuscripts
of
Cornwallis
p. 399
55
Admiralty to Nelson 13.1.1804 (Secret); ADM 2/1362
56
Nelson memo. 28.4.1804 and Sailing Direction for Leghorn nd. Nicolas V pp. 519–21
57
Nelson to Sir William Bolton 3.5.1804; Nicolas VI pp. 2–3 is typical of his mastery of local detail.
58
Nelson Disposition of the Fleet 21.6.1804; Nicolas VI pp. 79–81
59
Nelson to Lord Melville 10.3.1805; Nicolas VI p. 353. This is the letter that inspired Nicolas to compile his edition. It concerns the unfortunate Captain Layman, who had lost two ships in quick succession, and been censured for the second loss, much to Nelson’s dismay, as Layman was a very successful intelligence officer.
60
Nelson to Emma 2.10.1804; Morrison II pp. 240–1
61
Nelson to Berry 8.8.1804; Nicolas VI p. 146
62
Captain Capel to Nelson 20.11.1804; CRK/3
63
Nelson to Emma 12.8.1804; – Melville and to Elliot 15.8.1804; Nicolas VI pp. 152–7
64
Nelson to Elliot 7.10.1804; Nicolas VI pp. 221–2
65
Nelson to Ball 3.8.1804; Nicolas VI p. 131
66
Nelson to General Villettes (Malta); Nicolas VI pp. 189–90
67
Nelson to Ball 6.9.1804; Nicolas VI pp. 191–3
68
Nelson to Emma 23.11.1804; Nicolas VI p. 278
69
Nelson to Ball 15.12.1804 Nicolas VI pp. 285–6
70
Nelson to Davison 29.12.1804; Nicolas VI pp. 306–7
71
Orde to Admiralty 27.3.1805; Nicolas VI pp. 383–4. Orde was never again employed.
72
Hunter to Nelson 1804; CRK/7. Trigge to Nelson 27.10.1804; CRK/12
73
Admiralty to Orde 15.11.1804; ADM 2 /1362
74
Nelson to Admiralty 29.1.1805,18.2.1805. Nelson to Ball 11.2.1805; Nicolas VI pp. 332–4
75
Nelson to Admiralty 13.3.1705; Nicolas VI p. 357
76
Collingwood to Nelson 13.12.1804; CRK/3
77
Nelson to Collingwood 13.3.1805; Nicolas VI p. 35
78
Nelson to Lord Moira n.d.; Nicolas VI p. 310
79
Gillespie to Nelson 12.4.1805; CRK/6
80
Nelson to Admiral Lord Radstock 1.4.1805; Nicolas VI pp. 391–2