Reed, Erika - Something Worth Waiting For (Siren Publishing Ménage Amour) (9 page)

She couldn’t believe how these men could make her think of having sex again. Jenna felt her panties dampen in that thought. She couldn’t wait until they took her together. She wanted to experience the feeling of Nick pounding into her pussy as Tyler fucked her from behind.

Chapter 16

The day seemed to be turning into a perfect one. Jenna, Tyler and Nick enjoyed a delicious breakfast that morning. The three of them cleaned the kitchen together and ended up taking a walk along the lake after breakfast. Jenna had forgotten how beautiful her childhood town was. They had to go into town in the afternoon so the guys could grab some blueprints that had to be approved. Jenna was impressed at how well they had built their business. Tyler and Nick were very successful.

“I would like to walk around Main Street while you tie up some business. I will meet you back in, let’s say, an hour.”

“That should be plenty of time, baby. Why don’t you stop in at Beth’s Boutique? Buy yourself a pretty dress and something sexy to go underneath. We have a surprise for you tonight.”

“Oooh, I like surprises.”

Jenna looked in the windows of some of the very stores she used to go in all the time when she was younger. Some of the business owners remembered her right away, some she had to remind them of who she was. Many of them said their condolences to her about the loss of her father. A few asked how her mother was holding up. Jenna was going to miss her dad. She thought she never would have come home if it weren’t for his passing. Jenna thought it was his way of bringing her home once again.

Beth’s Boutique had a little of everything, cocktail dresses, casual wear, shoes for all occasions, and lingerie. She was in love with the store the minute she walked in.

“Can I help you find anything in particular?” a woman said from behind Jenna.

“I need to find a dress for this evening. I was also told to find something sexy to wear beneath it,” Jenna said with a smile.

“I don’t believe we’ve met. I own this store. I’m Beth.”

“Nice to meet you. I’m Jenna.”

“Oh my, you’re that girl that got hit outside of the diner earlier this week. Did you break your arm?”

“No, it’s just dislocated. I have to wear this thing for a few more weeks till the doctor says I can take it off.”

“Your mother comes in here frequently to buy some things. Are you shopping for her?”

“No, I’m staying with some…friends, and they told me to go buy these things. They have something special in store for me tonight.”

“Male friends? I’m quite aware of who your male companions are. Nick and Tyler are two of the most eligible bachelors in town. They’ve never shown as much interest in any other woman I town as they have with you.”

“Well, I won’t be staying in town for much longer. I live in California and need to get back as soon as the doctor will let me.”

“What do you do in California?”

“I’m a web designer.”

“Oh my, my website is so old and outdated. Maybe while you’re here you can help give mine a makeover, if you have the time, of course?”

“Sure, I would love to. I’m so bored sitting around the house. I could use a distraction.”

“I find it hard to believe that you are bored being around Nick and Tyler. I’m sure they keep you very busy.”

“Yes, well, it’s only temporary till I can get home.”

“Sweetie, why would you want to leave those two hunky men behind when they seem so head over heels for you?”

* * * *

Nick and Tyler found Jenna sitting on a bench in front of the ice cream store licking her sweet treat. Nick walked up and sat beside her.

“Hi, want a lick?” Jenna said with a wicked look in her eye.

“More than you know, honey!” Tyler laughed on the other side of Jenna. “I see you went to Beth’s. Did you find something there?”

“Yes, I hope it will be okay. You never gave me a clue as to what I would need it for. She helped me pick out a rather fancy dress. You have piqued my interest about what you two have in store.”

“Let’s get home, and we’ll show you.” Tyler led Jenna back to the truck and helped her in.

“Did you like Beth, baby? Did she help you find something really pretty?”

“I liked her. I’m going to help her design a new web page this week. I hope she’s not a woman from your past. I wouldn’t want to kill her.”

Nick chuckled. “No, honey, Beth was new into town after you left. She is a real nice woman that does a lot of charity work around town. She comes to us for donations time and time again. We’re always happy to help her out. Now, when we get home, we want you to run upstairs and take a bath and put that pretty dress on for us. We’ll meet you downstairs in forty-five minutes, okay?”

Jenna was so excited. When they got to the house, she told them that she would be fine getting ready on her own. She wouldn’t need their help bathing. She laid her royal blue floor-length dress on the bed. Beth had assured her the color looked amazing on her and her men would be damn fools if they let her get back to California.

* * * *

Jenna walked down the stairs after she had finished getting ready. There was a note waiting for her.

Jenna,

Come join us outside. We have something special waiting for you.

Love, Tyler and Nick

Jenna walked to the back door, and when she opened it, someone slipped his arm around her waist and put his other hand over her eyes so she couldn’t see anything. “What’s going on? I thought you were ready for me to come out?”

Tyler whispered in her ear, “Just walk a little further, baby. You’ll be pleased when we tell you to open your eyes finally.”

She was being led away from the house toward the water. Tyler stopped and said, “Open.”

Jenna couldn’t believe what she was seeing. The boat dock and gazebo overlooking the lake was transformed into a thing of beauty. White lights were strung all around. Fresh bouquets of flowers surrounded a white linen table. Candles were lit around the gazebo, and the table was set for three. There was a small corsage on the table as well. Jenna could hear the faint sound of music in the background. She turned around to look at them. They were dressed in identical black tuxedos. They were so handsome, she felt herself stop breathing for a moment. “This is absolutely breathtaking. When did you have time to do all of this?”

“When we dropped you off in town, Tyler picked up the tuxedos and flowers and I put this together outside,” Nick said as he put her wrist corsage on for her.

“Why did you go through all this trouble? What’s the occasion?”

“Baby, we never got to go to prom with our girl. We knew if we couldn’t take our girl, we didn’t want to go with anyone else.”

“Jenna, we wanted to have our own prom that we were robbed of so many years ago. Will you be our date tonight?” Nick said as he held out his elbow for Jenna to take. And Tyler did the same from her other side, being careful with her sling.

“I would love nothing more than to share that night with you both tonight.” Jenna felt as if she was going to cry. She knew if she did, her mascara would run, and she wanted to look good for them. They led her to the table, Nick held out her chair, and Tyler poured them some champagne.

Nick leaned over her and kissed her on her lips, “You look so beautiful tonight, Jenna. I’m glad you gave us the chance to make it up to you. We will make it worth your wait. We promise.”

Tyler sat beside Jenna and wrapped an arm around her waist, then kissed her on her lips the same way Nick had. “Jenna, you are the most beautiful woman I have ever known. As good as you look in that dress, I can’t wait to get you out of it.”

“I would like to enjoy some of my prom before we get each other’s clothes off.” Nick and Tyler both just chuckled beside her.

Dinner was delicious. Nick pulled out Jenna’s chair for her and asked her to dance. She couldn’t refuse. She wanted to get her hands on them since she saw them in their tuxedos. Tyler had asked to cut in and danced her around the table as Nick had. Jenna heard the song change and knew it was planned. Nick came to dance with her from behind. The song “Amazed” by Lonestar came on.

“I love this song. It always reminded me of us.”

“We remembered how much you liked this song in high school,” Nick said in her ear.

When the song ended, she felt Nick’s lips kissing her shoulders and neck. Tyler leaned his head down and let his fingers run through her hair so he could kiss her passionately on the mouth.

“Let’s take our girl upstairs now, Nick. What do you say?”

* * * *

Nick and Tyler had walked with Jenna hand and hand back to the house. Jenna had always wondered what it would have been like to go to the prom with them. She knew she couldn’t ask one and not the other. She never wanted to make that decision, ever. It was both of them or nothing at all.

The night was going so perfectly, she wasn’t ready for it to end. Jenna knew deep in her heart that the night was only beginning with these two.

Chapter 17

Jenna walked into her room to find yet another surprise. The bed had been turned down, and there were red rose petals thrown around the room with candles lit everywhere. “Yet another surprise from you two?” Jenna said with a smile.

“Sweetheart, we have a lot of things planned for you tonight. Our gift outside was just a taste,” Nick said in front of Jenna as Tyler lowered the zipper in the back.

Tyler feathered light kisses along her spine. Jenna felt herself shutter at the slight touch of his lips. Nick was helping roll down Jenna’s dress as he stopped to lick and then suck one of her nipples into his mouth. Jenna had to bite her lip to keep from making a loud noise.

“Honey, are you cold?”

“No, my nipples just seem to get tight when you play with them.” Jenna could vaguely hear them snicker. Nick switched from one breast to the other, giving them equal attention. She could feel Tyler pull her thong down her thighs and lift her feet to get it off. Tyler then used both of his hands to knead and rub her buttocks as he kissed them lightly.

“Baby, you have the sweetest ass I have ever seen. I can’t wait to bury my hard dick in it.”

Jenna felt someone lay her down across the bed and widen her legs. She opened her eyes to see Nick between her legs. “Jenna, we want to take it slow with you tonight and make love to you. However, I don’t think Tyler and I can wait for slow and easy right now. You have been driving us crazy all night. Turn over on your belly so you can suck Tyler’s cock while I prepare your ass for us.”

Jenna got up on her hands and knees to be faced with Tyler’s cock in her face. “I’ve wanted those lips wrapped around my dick all night, baby. Don’t take so long, Nick. I need to fuck her so bad.”

Jenna heard Nick open a bottle, and then he spread some liquid around her puckered hole. He then inserted a finger, and Jenna couldn’t help the shudder that went through her body then.

“Does that feel good, honey? Why don’t you show Tyler how good it makes you feel with your mouth around him?” While Jenna was sucking on Tyler’s cock, Nick continued the invasion by adding another finger to Jenna’s forbidden hole. “I think she’s ready to take us now, Tyler. Honey, why don’t you let Tyler lay beneath you on his back?”

Jenna sat on her heels as Tyler lay flat on his back. Tyler’s cock was standing straight in the air, begging for her wet pussy. Jenna crawled along his body and straddled his thighs.

“Grab my cock and put it inside you, Jenna.”

Jenna lowered herself on Tyler’s throbbing cock. He felt so good. Jenna wanted to deepen the penetration until she felt Nick press his hand to her shoulder.

“Lean forward, honey. Make room for me.”

Tyler kissed Jenna as she felt Nick penetrate where no man had ever gone. He eased in slowly. She could feel him break through the ring, and suddenly she felt so full.

“Don’t move, baby. Let us just enjoy being inside you. We’ve been waiting for this for so long. I want to remember this moment for the rest of my life.”

“Please. Someone move. I can’t stand this anymore.”

Jenna felt Nick move slowly in and out of her. Tyler would pull out as Nick would go in. It felt wonderful, so erotic. Jenna could feel her vagina walls tightening up.

“Yes. Oh God, please…I need to come, now.” Jenna could feel Nick grab her ass tighter as he started to pound into her faster and harder. Tyler’s hands gripped her hips tighter as he thrust into her.

“I’m going to come, baby.”

“So am I, Jenna,” Nick said in her ear as he thrust faster behind her.

Jenna could only hear herself scream out their names. The three of them exploded at the same time. Jenna heard Nick proclaiming his love to her as he spilled his seed inside her. They were each stroking her and murmuring sweet endearments in her ear. She had never come so hard in her entire life. Jenna felt Nick retreat and go to clean up in the bathroom. Tyler pulled himself out and just sat there holding her on his chest.

“You are so special, Jenna. You mean the world to me. I love you.”

Jenna was so thrilled to hear those words. Unfortunately, she couldn’t say them out loud without revealing her true feelings for them.