Read The Jews in America Trilogy Online

Authors: Stephen; Birmingham

The Jews in America Trilogy (176 page)

Sam Goldwyn.

The second generation: Edgar Miles Bronfman, to whom his father's mantle has been passed.

Benny “Bugsy” Siegel.

Acknowledgments

This book has been in various stages of preparation of more years than I care to count, and the list of individuals who have contributed thoughts and impressions to it is long. But there are a few people to whom I would like to extend a special word of thanks.

For their recollections of the great, gone motion picture moguls of Hollywood, I am grateful for the hours I was able to spend with George Cukor, King Vidor, Adolph Zukor, Minna Wallis, Roddy McDowall, Lucille Ball, Sam Marx, Ava Gardner, John Huston, Gail and Howard Strickling, Lillian Hellman, Elizabeth Taylor, and, most particularly, Frances Howard Goldwyn.

In New York, one of the few remaining people to have a tenuous impression of the sad-fated Rose Pastor Stokes was Mrs. Lettice Sands Stokes. I am also grateful to Mr. and Mrs. Richard Roth, Sr., who supplied me with the unpublished memoir of Mr. Roth's father, Emery Roth, which is herein quoted. Other New Yorkers who deserve thanks are Mrs. Anna Potok, Jack Rosenthal, John Schiff, the late Walter E. Sachs, Robert La Vine, Ralph and Ricky Lauren, Peter Carlsen, John L. Loeb,
Jr., Ruth Proskauer Smith, Patrick O'Higgins, Theoni V. Aldredge, Dina Abramovicz of YIVO, and the particularly helpful Rabbi Ronald B. Sobel of Temple Emanu-El.

A special word of thanks to Phillip Applebaum of Detroit. Although I have had personal and business dealings with members of the Bronfman family over the years, I am indebted to longtime Bronfman observer Peter C. Newman of Toronto, who was generous with insights and whose book
Bronfman Dynasty
(published in the United States as
King of the Castle
) was an important source. This book also owes much to Allen and Beverley Gasner of Bethesda, Maryland; to Robert and Helen Gould of Cincinnati; to Isaac and Dian Levine, also of Cincinnati, for their recollections of Dr. Levine's father, Calman Levine; to Rabbi Alfred Gottschalk of Hebrew Union College; to Mrs. Meyer Lansky of Miami Beach; and to Dr. Edward Lahniers, for psychological insights. In the process of its preparation, the book was fortunate to be taken into the hands of two splendid editors at Little, Brown: my late friend Harry Sions, and the superb Genevieve Young. I would also like to thank Kate Bourne of Little, Brown for many hours of diligent and thorough picture research. As always, I am indebted to my friend and agent, Carol Brandt, for her cool guidance and support of the project from the beginning. While all of these people have helped enormously with the book, I alone must be held responsible for any errors or shortcomings.

S.B.

Source Notes

PREFACE

x-xiii

Figures on Christian and Jewish wealth:
Jewish Living
, vol. 2, no. 3 (Sept./Oct., 1979), pp. 41–47; reprinted in Siegel and Rheins, pp. 98–103.

xii

Mr. Annenberg's fine: Siegel and Rheins, p. 59.

xiii

Lansky's worth:
Jewish Living
, p. 47; reprinted in Siegel and Rheins, p. 103.

xiii

Mayer's worth: Howard Strickling to author.

1. UPTOWN FIREBRAND

4

Jewish migration figures: Liebmann Hersch, “International Migration of the Jews,”
International Migrations
, vol. 2 (New York: Macmillan, 1931), pp. 490, 496, 501, 504, 507.

4–5

The Adenoids Riot:
New York Tribune
, June 28, 1906; reprinted in Schoener, p. 132.

5

“excitable, ignorant Jews … nearest ‘Yiddisher'”: ibid.

7

“Julia, I'm pretty … will know my name”: memorial pamphlet by Addie Richman Altman and Bertha Richman Proskauer; privately printed; no date.

7–8

“Julia, take everything off”: ibid.

8

“But we can't do anything”: ibid.

10

“It is much easier”: ibid.

10

“Every time she visits”:
Jewish Daily Forward
, Feb. 12, 1911.

11

“years of”: Altman and Proskauer pamphlet.

14

“the dominion of reason”: Rabbi Alfred Gottschalk to author.

15

Population figures: Howe, p. xix;
Universal Jewish Encyclopedia and Reader's Guide
(New York: KTAV Publishing, 1944), vol. 7, p. 547.

16

Population figures: Oscar Handlin,
Adventure in Freedom
(New York: McGraw-Hill, 1954), p. 84.

18

Population figures: Report of the U.S. Immigration Commission, vol. 15, 1911, pp. 476–477.

20

“Rent money and landlord”: Applebaum, p. 10.

20

Baron de Hirsch fund: Manners, p. 193.

22

Schiff's contribution: ibid., p. 97.

23–24

“peace, liberty … Occidental Civilization”: Rabbi Ronald B. Sobel to author.

24

“Are we waiting”: ibid.

24

“thoroughly acclimated American Jew”: ibid.

25–26

The 1907 syllabus: Howe, p. 276.

26

Jewish school population: ibid., p. 274.

26

“thirst for knowledge … debatable questions”: ibid., p. 276.

28

Pushcart licenses: Manners, p. 239.

28

“You don't want to be too hard”: ibid., p. 240.

29

“It is not astonishing”: Theodore A. Bingham, “Foreign Criminals in New York,”
North American Review
, Sept., 1908, pp. 383–394; quoted in Howe, p. 133.

29

Harper's Weekly
article: issue of Nov., 1907.

30

“sensational methods”: Manners, p. 243.

30–31

“a Jacob Schiff” and other
Tageblatt
quotes: Manners, pp. 244, 241–242.

31

“Dear Mr. Editor”:
Jewish Daily Forward
, Feb. 8, 1906; reprinted in Schoener, p. 247.

32

“In the old country”: Dr. Isaac Levine to author.

2. WHY THEY CAME

33–35

Gelbfisz's boyhood and emigration: Frances Howard Goldwyn (Mrs. Samuel) to author.

37

“The purpose in educating”: Lucy Dawidowicz,
The Golden Tradition: Jewish Life and Thought in Eastern Europe
(New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston, 1967), p. 30.

38

Jews arrested or exiled: Howe, pp. 6–7.

39

The cossacks at the station: Lyons, p. 24.

41

Harris Rubin's story:
American Jewish Archives
, vol. 33, no. 1 (Apr., 1981), pp. 10–11.

42

“a sweeping plague”:
New York Times
, Jan. 29, 1905; reprinted in Schoener, p. 28.

43–46

Isaac Don Levine's impressions: “Letters of an Immigrant,”
American Jewish Archives
, vol. 33, no. 1 (Apr., 1981), pp. 53–61.

46

immigration figures: Oscar Handlin.
Adventure in Freedom
(New York: McGraw-Hill, 1954), p. 84; also
Encyclopaedia Britannica
(1957), vol. 15, p. 466

47

oysesn: Jewish Daily Forward
, July 14, 1903.

47

Vacations “have become a trend”: ibid., June 30, 1904.

48

“God sent us the Victrola”: ibid., May 9, 1904.

48

“There are pianos”: ibid., Oct. 16, 1904.

3. A JEWISH CINDERELLA

54

“Some pray to marry”: John Bartlett,
Familiar Quotations
, 13th ed. (Boston: Little, Brown, 1955), p. 906.

55

Rose's aphorisms:
Tageblatt
, Aug. 13, 1903, Oct. 25, 1905.

56

“Mr. Stokes is a deep, strong thinker”: quoted in
New York Times,
Apr. 6, 1905.

57

“If I thought as much”: ibid.

57

“love at first sight”: ibid.

58

Stokes telegram exchange: Cleveland Amory,
The Last Resorts
(New York: Harper and Brothers, 1952), p. 16.

58

“a descendant of families”:
New York Times
, Apr. 6, 1905.

59

“She might have been the model”: Lillian Baynes Griffin, “Mrs. J. G. Phelps Stokes at Home,”
Harper's Bazar
, Sept., 1906.

60

“I wish the Times would correct”:
New York Times
, Apr. 6, 1905.

60

“inspired religion … teacher and guide”: Griffin in
Harper's Bazar
, Sept., 1906.

60

“The only difference”: ibid.

61

“As she talks”:
New York Times
, Apr. 6, 1905.

61

“very interesting”: ibid.

61

“It was a hard struggle”: ibid.

62

“If our life”: Griffin in
Harper's Bazar
, Sept., 1906.

63

“we have no definite plans”:
New York Times
, July 20, 1905.

64

Hebrew Standard
editorial: reported in ibid.

64–65

“closer to the Christian sentiment”:
Hebrew Standard
, July 21, 1905.

65

“Fame!”: Rose Harriet Pastor,
Tageblatt
, July 26, 1903.

65–66

Description of Stokes apartment and interview with Rose: Griffin in
Harper's Bazar
, Sept., 1906.

69

“For the future”:
Universal Jewish Encyclopedia and Reader's Guide
(New York: KTAV Publishing, 1944), vol. 10, p. 67.

70

production of shirtwaists: Howe, p. 298.

71

“I am a working girl”: ibid.

71

“If I turn traitor”: Barbara Mayer Wertheimer,
We Were There: The Story of Working Women in America
(New York: Pantheon Books, 1977), p. 301.

72

“The girls”: McAlister Coleman, “All of Which I Saw,”
Progressive
, May, 1950, p. 25.

72

“You are on strike”: Howe, p. 299.

73

“A common social and cultural background”: Will Herberg in
American Jewish Year Book
(Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society, 1940), p. 36.

75

“to make room”: memorial pamphlet by Addie Richman Altman and Bertha Richman Proskauer; privately printed; no date.

75

“[The fire] taught”: Julia Richman and Isabel Wallach,
Good Citizenship
(New York: American Book Company, 1908), p. 76.

75

“The desire to save money”: ibid., p. 93.

75–76

“worse … than slovenly”: ibid., p. 103.

Other books

The Road Home by Patrick E. Craig
On Solid Ground: Sequel to in Too Deep by Michelle Kemper Brownlow
Yes, No, Maybe by Emma Hillman
Star of Wonder by Angel Payne
Throb by Vi Keeland
The Forfeit by Cullum, Ridgwell
Going to the Chapel by Janet Tronstad
Fatal Convictions by Randy Singer
The Girls Club by Jackie Coupe