Authors: Joseph Tirella
Brooklyn CORE and its allies were in disarray. Arnold Goldwag was arrested at the Willet Points subway station just outside the Fair on a court-issued bench warrant (he had never bothered to appear in court to answer charges stemming from his arrest at the Downstate Medical Center). Herbert Callender of Bronx CORE appeared at the Elmhurst precinct, insisting he speak with the arrested activists, and was promptly arrested himself. Reverend Galamison appeared there, too, disappointingly telling reporters that he never doubted Brunson's “sincerity” but that the twenty-two-year-old auto mechanic “is no Bayard Rustin.”
Back at the World's Fair, as Farmer, Rustin, and their group were being hauled away, other activistsâmany of them white college
studentsâhad fanned out through the Fairgrounds. A group of fifty protesters targeted the Florida Pavilion, where they squared off with police. One attempted to scale the building's 110-foot orange tower as Governor C. Farris Bryant spoke with reporters inside. The protesters were arrested, including the would-be tower-climber, who required a quartet of officers to restrain him as he screamed and kicked, booting one policeman square in the face.
Some protesters carried signs and marched silently; others tapped their feet along with the music of the opening parade; still others took breaks from their picketing to do some sightseeing. “I've been running off to see something whenever I get relieved on the line,” said one New York CORE member before heading to the GM Pavilion. Another Maryland activist took a break from picketing his home state's pavilion to see the Ford show. “I think it's an interesting Fair,” he said. “I hope I will be able to come back.”
The parade ended at the Singer Bowl, the newly constructed ten-thousand-seat open-air stadium where the Fair's VIPs and international dignitaries had gathered for the invitation-only opening ceremony. Sitting on the stage, underneath a blue-and-orange canopy, were former president Harry S. Truman, Governor Nelson A. Rockefeller, Mayor Wagner, and Moses. They were joined by the United Nation's Dr. Ralph J. Bunche and UN Ambassador Adlai Stevenson, eight state governors, eleven congressmen, and twenty-three ambassadors. As the audience took to their seats, doing their best to protect themselves from the rain, speakers took to the podium, decorated with the presidential seal, in anticipation of President Johnson's arrival.
It didn't take long before they began lavishing Moses with praise. Messages were read from former presidents Herbert H. Hoover and Dwight D. Eisenhower, who had awarded the Fair to New York nearly four years earlier. President Truman joked that there “is only one Moses and it's not the one in the Bible.” Governor Rockefeller lauded his most infamous employeeâ“the fabulous Bob Moses has done it again,” he said. Mayor Wagner poignantly predicted the Fair's opening day represented a historic event, a before-and-after moment that would grow in
importance over time. “Today,” he noted, “we may be marking the end of one era and the beginning of another.” The mayor had no idea of just how right he was.
Moses stood at the podium, hatless despite the chill and wearing his customary suit and tie and a thin raincoat. While obviously pleased with the accolades and verbal wreaths being laid at his feet, he acknowledged the silent shadow that hung over the Fair, lamenting the fact that President John F. Kennedyâwho had been assassinated exactly five months beforeâwasn't “here to give [the Fair] his blessing.” It was, uncharacteristically, a gracious note to strike, and one that Robert Kennedy expressed his thanks for in a handwritten note weeks later.
Representing the family of nations that were participating in the Fair was Indira Gandhi, the daughter of Indian Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru. As Gandhi, who in two years would be elected prime minister, spoke, Johnson's military green presidential helicopter swirled overhead, creating a commotion and bringing her time at the podium to an end. (The new president's handlers had made sure to fly directly from the airport just in case the stall-in clogged the highways.) Emerging from the helicopter as the band played “Hail to the Chief,” Johnson was surrounded by Secret Service. The events in Dallas were fresh in everyone's mind, nor was it lost on political insiders that President William McKinley had been assassinated at the 1901 Buffalo Fair.
Addressing the crowd, President Johnson spoke of the dual paths that stood before the world, “abundance or annihilationâdevelopment or desolation,” and characterized the World's Fair as “the promised land of Mr. Moses,” borrowing poet Ogden Nash's phrase. The president and the VIPs then moved to the US Federal Pavilion, where Johnson dedicated the Charles Luckmanâdesigned modernist structure that his predecessor had taken such a personal interest in (and the planning for which had elicited so many complaints from Moses). One set of protesters sat down on the rain-soaked grass on either end of the building while the president declared, “Peace is not only possible in our generation but I predict it is coming much nearer.”
What Johnson didn't know was that the protests were already under way while he was speaking to the VIP crowd inside the Singer Bowl; during his first speech a few hundred protesters, mostly college students, carried signs and shouted “Jim Crow Must Go!” whenever they heard his Texas twang broadcast over the Fair's PA system. Now the demonstrators, held at bay by a throng of police, shouted “Jim Crow Must Go!” and “Freedom Now!” directly at the president, often drowning out his amplified voice. Three of the college activists sat on the shoulders of their peers and held up signs that were visible not only to Johnson, but for the entire crowd of politicians to see.
A World's Fair Is a Luxury but a Fair World Is a Necessity
read one;
See New York's Worse FairâSegregated Schools for Negroes, Puerto Ricans and Rats
read another.
For Moses and Wagner, this might have been worse than an actual stall-in. They could do nothing but sit and watch helplessly as scores of college students drowned out Johnson, who was making one of his very first public speeches since an assassin's bullet had made him the thirty-sixth President of the United States.
Another group that arrived from nearby Queens College, where Louis E. Lomax had first floated the idea of the stall-in the year before, reinforced the activists who had arrived with Farmer. Queens was a politically active campus with a CORE chapter, including a twenty-year-old activist named Andrew Goodman, who arrived in time to continue on the “official” CORE protest after Farmer and Rustin had been carried off.
Ignoring the rowdy crowd that was shouting him down as if he were some local City Council speaker as best he could, Johnson laid the groundwork for a vision of what by the following month he would call “the Great Society”: an America in which “no man need be poor” and where “no man is handicapped by the color of his skin or the nature of his belief.” When the college students heard this, they laughed out loud, openly mocking President Johnson for all to see. The crowdâincluding Moses, Wagner, ambassadors, congressmen, governors, and foreign dignitariesâwas horrified at this generational display of disrespect.
The activists looked every bit the part of young collegiate rebels: Some wore jeans and collared shirts, affecting the plebeian look that would make Pete Seeger proud; others affected longish hair a la the Beatles. The most rebelliousâand hipâamong them were decked out in suede jackets and jeans, their angry eyes hidden by shadesâa look that Bob Dylan would soon make famous. Some, perhaps less image-conscious, looked earnest in their black horn-rimmed glasses and pleated skirts.
The new president, who was congenitally sensitive to public embarrassment, could only mask his outrage. Lacking the polished grace and wit of his predecessor or the respect of the Free World commanded by Eisenhower, the former Supreme Allied Commander of WWII, or even Truman's down-home, tell-it-like-it-is charm, Johnson seemed remarkably un-presidential. Hailing from humble origins, Johnson desperately wanted to win the White House on his own and emerge from the slain Kennedy's shadow. He wanted to prove to all the naysayersâthe Eastern establishment that never accepted him, the Northern liberals who were horrified that this rough 'n' ready Texan was now the keeper of the Camelot flameâthat he, Lyndon Baines Johnson, Landslide Lyndon, as the local reporters dubbed him after the extremely narrow (and stolen) election of 1948 that sent him to the US Senate, was indeed a liberal New Dealer at heart. He would muster all his Machiavellian strategies to accomplish what Kennedy and every other president had failed at: He would sign the most far-reaching piece of civil rights legislation into law.
Yet, here he was, in working-class Queens, province of labor union workers, immigrants, and blacksânatural Democratic votersâand he was being embarrassed and ridiculed by nearly two hundred socially engaged college students, who also should have been his natural constituents. And they were doing it to him at the World's Fair in front of the national and international press; members of the political elite, and one of his potential Republican rivals for the White HouseâNelson Rockefeller.
Attempting to reclaim the moment by addressing the students' concerns, Johnson told them that American freedom was an act-in-progress:
“We do not try to mask our national problems. We do not try to disguise our imperfections or cover up our failures. No other nation in history has done so much to correct its flaws.” He was met with more contemptuous laughter from the activists. Johnson had been looking forward to the New York trip to open the World's Fairâit was one of the most nonpartisan acts a president could performâand they made a laughingstock out of him.
“I felt sorry for them,” he said the next day after returning to Washington, where the White House press corps questioned him about his teenage torturers. Sounding like the disapproving father of the nation's wayward youth, Johnson said that their disruption of his speech served “no good purpose . . . of promoting the cause they profess to support.” New York Senator Jacob K. Javitz, a Republican, was so horrified by the demonstrators that he apologized personally to the president.
The mayor apologized publicly, saying that “as the city in which this took place, we must be ashamed.” But of all the officials who witnessed the public humiliation of a president, only Police Commissioner Murphy seemed to grasp the real significance of the
historical event. He noted that the Fair's opening day was “a day in which the President came to the world of fantasy and encountered the world of fact, a day millions will never forget.”
Although Moses
had
predicted that more than 250,000 attendees would pass through the Fair's ninety-five turnstiles on opening day, the official tally was only 92,646âand of those, only 63,791 actually paid the $2 price of admission (the others being well-connected and/or VIPs). Never one to admit a mistake, Moses blamed the low turnout on the Novemberlike weather, the weather being one of the few aspects of life in Gotham that even the Master Builder could not influenceânot that he didn't try. Moses would write to local news stations urging them to downplay gloomy weather reports in their nightly broadcasts so that Fairgoers wouldn't be scared off.
But the weather was only half the story. The proposed stall-inâeven though it hadn't actually happenedâhad done its job: Tens of thousands of people had stayed away from the World's Fair. The myriad
demonstrations that had transpiredâon the subway, the Farmer-led sit-ins at the New York State Pavilion, and the shouting down of an American president in front of political leaders and television camera crewsâwould not have happened had not a small group of militant Brooklyn CORE activists, with nothing more than bravado and homemade flyers, upped the ante. Although their planned stall-in failed, the day was hardly a failure for the group. President Johnson, Moses, Mayor Wagner, and Governor Rockefeller had all heard their message, even if the Brooklyn activists themselves had not delivered it.
What they and the nation heard that day was that for some civil rights activists, the time for deliberation was over; now was a time for action. “Freedom Now!” was not a polite request; it was a demand. “Jim Crow Must Go!” was not a wish; it was an order. “Peace Through Understanding” was a worthy slogan, but they were empty words against the backdrop of the nation's tumultuous political and psychic landscape. There would be no peaceânot at the World's Fair, not in New York City, and not in Americaâuntil their voices were heard.
Outside the gates of Flushing Meadow, America was changing far more rapidly than Moses or any of his allies could fully comprehend. The 1964â65 World's Fair marked the beginning of the end of an epoch in American history, the final vestige of the black-and-white conformity of Eisenhower's 1950s and the brief so-called Camelot of Kennedy and his New Frontiersmen. It was all slipping away into the past and being replaced by the new vividâand even garishâTechnicolor of the 1960s.
The future had arrived.
22.
The 1939 fair was a promise. The 1964 fair is a boast. . . . And somehow, in its jostling, heedless, undisciplined energy, it makes a person happy to be alive in the 20th century.
â
Time,
June 5, 1964
Â
Shortly before the World's Fair opened, Robert Moses and a reporter from the
Saturday Evening Post,
then one of the nation's most popular magazines, stood on top of one of the Fair's tallest buildings. The Master Builder, obviously pleased with himself and his handiwork, looked around, surveying the mesmerizingly diverse assortment of pavilions and space-age structures that now stood erect in Flushing Meadow Parkâwhich, as he reminded many a journalist, he had created after clearing the soiled wetlands of the debris and garbage of Brooklyn. Then he spoon-fed his interviewer the article's opening. “Well, I guess they'll just have to say, âThe old SOB did it again,'” he said.
Despite the relentless hyperbole emanating from Flushing Meadow (“the single greatest event in history!”), few would dispute that Moses had essentially delivered on his promise to create a World's Fair that had “something for everyone.”
From Michelangelo's Renaissance masterpiece
La PietÃ
to the Walt Disney Audio-Animatronics that brought the past to lifeâJurassic age dinosaurs, wheel-building cavemen, and the slain sixteenth US president, Abraham Lincoln, the last of which was so lifelike that when it stood up to speak, one shocked five-year-old shouted, “But Daddy, I thought you said he was dead!”âto introducing the latest in consumer products, including color television, the Picturephone (preceding Skype by almost fifty years), and an IBM computer, something few people had ever seen up close before, the past and the future could be seen at the Fair. And right from the start the Fair seemed to be on solid financial ground: The exhibition had sold $35 million in
advance tickets, making many New York officials involved with the projectâMoses in particularâwonder if their stated goal of seventy million visitors was too low.
There was much to choose from at the Fair. Despite the earlier outcry of critics, there was plenty of art representing several centuries and an impressive variety of styles: the aforementioned Michelangelo; Spanish old masters like Goya, Velázquez, and El Greco; modernist icons like Picasso, Miró, and Matisse; the landscape romanticism of the Hudson River School painters (which fittingly decorated the interior of the New York State Pavilion); a healthy sampling of the abstract expressionists; as well as the pop art stylings of Robert Rauschenberg, Roy Lichtenstein, and John Chamberlain, whose workâpreoccupied with consumer culture as it wasâseemed right at home among the Fair's corporate pavilions.
There were nearly seventy foreign nations (eighty including municipalities like West Berlin and city-states like the Vatican) that truly represented the worldânot just the West. With most of the major European nations, including America's key NATO allies (the United Kingdom, France, Italy, West Germany), sitting out, as well as its Cold War antagonists staying home (the USSR and its Warsaw Pact puppet states of Central and Eastern Europe), and other Communist enemies uninvited (the People's Republic of China was off-limits, as was Cuba), the free nations of Asia and Africa, South and Central America, the Middle East and the island nations of Oceania, all answered Moses' call to come to the Fair.
Many of these countries were newly independent nations; some had just recently overthrown former colonial European masters. The 1964â65 New York World's Fair presented the world in all its multicultural splendor: Korea, Japan, Hong Kong, Taiwan (then called the Republic of China), Indonesia, Polynesia, the Philippines, and Samoa all built pavilions, as did Venezuela, Honduras, Panama, Mexico, and a slew of Caribbean countries which gathered under one roof in the Caribbean Pavilion. Other South American countries wanted to participate but were made to feel unwelcome. Moses all but kicked out Argentina when he discovered that the main investor was a Canadian company (he never
forgave America's northern neighbor for sitting out the Fair, in particular since the US government had decided to build at pavilion at the upcoming Montreal Expo '67). Chile had intended on coming, but after Charles Poletti embarrassed their delegation at a press conference, the offended South Americans decided to stay home.
Saudi Arabia, Jordan, Lebanon, India, Pakistan, Sierra Leone, and Morocco were represented, along with fifteen other independent African republics which united to form the African Pavilion, a project in which Moses took a personal interest. “We've devoted a lot of time to the new republics,” Moses said at a ground-breaking ceremony for the American-Israel Pavilion in 1963. “They are new, they are ambitious, they are enthusiastic. They want to send their new image around the world.”
A few European nationsâAustria, Denmark, Switzerland, Sweden, Ireland, and Greeceâignored
the Bureau of International Exhibitions' boycott of Moses' Fair and built pavilions anyway, most of which were sponsored by private, nongovernmental organizationsâchamber of commerceâtype groupsâpassing through a technical loophole in the BIE's bylaws.
One major European nation that did not care about the BIE or its laws was Spain, which at the time of the Fair was still under the rule of the fascist regime of General Francisco Francoâformer ally of Hitler and Mussolini (and now a staunch ally of the anti-Communist West). Franco, anxious to strengthen his political and economic ties with the United States, spared no expense in creating the celebrated Spanish Pavilionâhailed as one of the Fair's architectural masterpiecesâand filled it with cultural and artistic treasures ranging from Spain's Golden Age to its twentieth-century masters.
The world's religions held court, too: The riches of Catholicism were on full display at the Vatican Pavilion thanks to Pope John XXIII, who had died in June 1963. John's successor, Pope Paul VI, was equally enthusiastic about the World's Fair and its potential for fostering cooperation among the nations of the world. The Protestant and Orthodox Pavilion showcased a number of Christian sects, and Billy Graham, the most famous and beloved preacher in the United States, had his very own
pavilion, where every night, seven days a week, he held court, trying to win hearts for Jesus. The Mormons built a scaled-down replica of their Salt Lake City Tabernacle, which represented a major public relations push for the enigmatic Utah-based church.
The ancient culture of Judaism and its millennia of history were represented at the American-Israel Pavilion, a joint venture of American Jewish organizations, which symbolized the special relationship between the two nations. The pavilion also commemorated a bit of local history: In Flushing Meadow Park, Queens, in 1948, while its Manhattan headquarters was completed, a nascent United Nations made its historic vote to recognize the fledging state of Israel, just three years after the demise of Hitler's Third Reich. The UN's temporary housing was the old New York City Pavilion from the 1939â40 World's Fair.
Nearly half of the US states built pavilions for the World's Fair. The South was represented by Louisiana, Texas, and Florida; the West by Oregon, Alaska, Montana (which sent an old steam locomotive carrying $1 million of gold across country to Flushing Meadow), and New Mexico; the Midwest by Wisconsin, Minnesota, and Missouri; the East by New Jersey, Maryland, and the various states that formed the New England Pavilion.
But, by far, the most popular and celebrated state pavilions were those from Illinois and New York. The first featured the pride of Disney's technical staff, President Lincoln's robotic doppelgänger, and the latter was an example of Philip Johnson's postmodern architecture, a series of circular shapes with its three towers, the tallest of which allowed vistas of the entire Fair (and Queens) from 212 feet in the sky and was accessible by outdoor elevators. Even Mosesâno fan of postmodernism in any formâwas taken with the structure and earmarked it for his post-Fair park. “An outstanding example of originality in design, structural, and material experimentation and ingenuity in the selection and display of exhibits,” he proclaimed in front of the thousand invited guests at the pavilion's official opening on the second day of the Fair.
While the world and all of its racial diversity were exhibited at the Fair, corporate America and the gospel of consumerism it preached were
really the stars of the show. This was, of course, the height of America's postwar boom, and the American economy and its seemingly limitless horizons were the envy the world over. Many of the biggest names in American industry created eye-popping attractions, such as the IBM Pavilion, which looked like a huge industrial egg nestled among a forest of metallic trees. The structure was a collaboration between Finnish-American architect Eero Saarinen (who famously created the TWA Flight Center at John F. Kennedy Airport, a paean to space-age architecture) and Charles Eames, the designer, architect, and filmmaker, who conceived of the pavilion's “People Wall,” a five-hundred-seat indoor theater that, once “loaded” with an audience, lifted the crowd fifty feet into the air, where they were entertained by a multiscreen film.
The Travelers Insurance Pavilion looked like a flying saucer from a 1950s sci-fi film, while US Royal Tires decided to make their product into an amusement park ride: a six-story Ferris wheel shaped like a gigantic rubber tire, a bit of marketing savvy and at the same time a nod to the baser commercialistic aspects of pop art. (Perhaps corporate executives understood Andy Warhol and his contemporaries better than some leading art critics.) Electric Power & Light's Tower of Light was a series of rectangular panels that bore a striking resemblance to a child's building blocks. However, once darkness fell, the scores of panels were illuminated in a rainbow of pastel hues that equaled some twelve-billion candlepower, reportedly the world's largest (and presumably, most expensive) searchlight.
But perhaps no industry was better represented than Detroit's Big Three automakers. The Ford Motor Company chose the Fair to introduce its latest model, the Ford Mustang, which would go on to become one of the best-selling automobiles in American history, coupling it with the Walt Disneyâdesigned Magic Skyway ride. For its pavilion General Motors gave a nostalgic nod to its legendary Futurama exhibit from the 1939â40 New York World's Fair, proclaiming in an ad that their pavilion would transport customers to “Tomorrow-Land.” Millions of adults who had visited the earlier fair remembered being dazzled by its prediction of the futureâ“the World of Tomorrow” that, according to the exhibit,
would exist by 1960. Now inside its towering tailfin pavilion (a shape that would be recalled decades later in NASA's Space Shuttle) there was a new ride titled Futurama II, which offered 1964 audiences a newer, twenty-first-century vision of “the City of Tomorrow.”
According to GM, twenty-first-century cities would feature sleek modernist skyscrapers and smart superhighwaysâcomputers would regulate traffic and keep cars safely away from each other. But the great Metropolis of the future would allow for a relic of the past: A Gothic cathedral held a place of honor on one of the few people-populated plazas in the busy city. (Apparently, one of the few places that people walked to in the future was church.) Futurama II's Tomorrow-Land was a lot like the world as it already existed in 1964, only an updated version of the landscape that Moses had been building since the end of the Second World War.
Fairgoers sat three-abreast in slow-moving chairs as they viewed space-age daydreams of roving lunar vehicles, underwater hotels, and rotating space stations. They also saw an improbable gigantic highway-creating machine: a technological Leviathan that could convert Mother Nature, literally pulverizing earth and rock and tearing out trees, as it slowly crawled along its path, leaving only a smooth, paved highwayâan earth-eating computerized Moloch that would have given Lewis Mumford nightmares (and put Moses out of work).
This was the kind of sci-fi fantasy that fueled the very real Apollo missions to send a man to the moon and “return him safely to Earth,” as President Kennedy had declared. According to GM's vision of the twenty-first century, even deserts were overgrown with vegetation, as they became the beneficiary of rerouted and desalinated ocean water.
And if Fairgoers wanted to see what NASA was really up to, they simply had to walk over to the US Space Park. A fifty-one-foot-tall replica of the Saturn V Boattail rocket engine, the stage-one propulsion jet that would help various Apollo missions reach space, mesmerized crowds. NASA also sent a life-size Lunar Excursion Module, or LEM, the actual craft that
Apollo 11
astronauts would use to touch down on the moon's surface. If that wasn't enough for Fairgoers, the Transportation
& Travel Pavilion had a huge half-moon dome as its roof, complete with a crater-encrusted lunar landscape. Although it wasn't completed on opening day, the Hall of Science (which would eventually become a permanent museum in the post-Fair park) would continue the Fair's space exploration theme decades after the Fair permanently closed.
New Yorkers also got a glimpse of their own future: The World Trade Center and its “Twin Towers” were first displayed in miniature in the Port Authority Building, a modernist rectangular box that sat on four stilts, where the much-maligned “Top of the Fair” restaurant was held, its roof serving as a helipad. Designed by Japanese-American architect Minoru Yamasaki, who had created the US Science Pavilion for Seattle's Century 21 Exposition, the 110-story Twin Towers would have fit seamlessly into GM's Futurama II exhibit. Many critics would lambast the architect's Twin Towers when they were completed in April 1973. Moses, however, was a huge fan of them, marveling at their sleek modern design that seemed to recall the geometric abstractions of the Trylon and Perisphere, iconic symbols of the 1939â40 Fair.
Many showsâespecially Disney'sâwere sentimental and aimed to entertain, especially the swarms of children who attended. One such child was seven-year-old Caroline Kennedy, daughter of the recently slain president, who was so convinced that the puppy in the Carousel of Progress was real, she pleaded with her mother, former First Lady Jacqueline Kennedy, to take it home. Still grieving and clad uniformly in black, Mrs. Kennedy's visit to the World's Fair was one of the first public appearances she had made with her family since the murder of her husband in Dallas five months earlier. Her former brother-in-law, Robert Kennedy, in the midst of a Senate race (trying to unseat New York's Republican Senator Kenneth Keating), also visited the fair with his family. Ever the campaigner, Kennedy allowed photographers to snap away as he planted a kiss on each of his kids as they boarded a ride.