"People get calls from pay phones. It happens."
Justin exchanged glances with the other two, then said, "Well, we're bound to find the truth if we dig deep enough. In any case, there is one thing that sets Caldwell's murder apart from the others. He's the only one of the four who we can be reasonably sure saw his killer."
Obviously musing aloud, Kelly said, "I wonder if that means something. If the Caldwell murder is part of the series, then why was he killed so… directly? Face-to-face, I mean."
Justin said, "We're assuming that Luke Ferrier was either rendered unconscious by some drug while he was driving, and so accidentally drove into the water, or else was rendered unconscious beforehand, put into his car, and the car pointed at that bayou, right? That he probably had no opportunity to see his killer."
Kelly frowned at him. "Well, I'm assuming. There was no sign of a struggle, nothing to indicate that Ferrier put up any kind of a fight. So it only makes sense that either it was suicide or else he was out cold and couldn't struggle. And since he'd clearly been making plans to leave Silence, I'm not buying the suicide theory."
Justin nodded. "Okay. But if we assume the killer was there with Ferrier even if he wasn't seen, that he put the man in his car and pointed it at the bayou, then the only murder of the four that really sticks out in terms of how it was executed is the first one—the murder of Peter Lynch."
"The killer didn't see him die," Ethan realized. "If, that is, the poison was mixed in with his vitamins at some earlier point so there was no telling when he'd get to those particular pills."
"Not that we're certain it was." Justin sighed. "We're not certain of a hell of a lot."
Kelly shook her head. "Is anybody else getting the feeling this guy is just playing with us?"
"I've got that feeling," Matt said, dispirited.
"A direct challenge to us?" Justin considered, then shrugged. "Maybe. But it feels to me like he's got his game plan all laid out and means to stick to it, no matter what we do. Like each murder is designed as part of the victim's punishment. Peter Lynch, the health nut, is poisoned; Luke Ferrier, so proud of his college swimming trophies, is drowned; Randal Patterson, famous for his personal vanity, is electrocuted in his tub; and George Caldwell, who did community ads and school presentations on gun safety and owned an extensive collection of firearms, is shot in the head."
Kelly bunked at him. "Jesus, you're right. I never thought about it that way, but… it all fits."
Ethan was also eyeing him, and very thoughtfully.
As offhandedly as possible, Justin said, "It may fit, but it's just another theory and it doesn't help us a damned bit as far as I can see. We're still no closer to being able to either I.D. this guy or predict his next move or his next victim."
"But you think he's not done," Ethan said.
"I think it would be a mistake for us to assume that. Because even if his personal hit list had only four names on it, the truth is, he's getting away with murder—so far, at least. And whatever his reasons were for starting all this, success can only encourage him. If he's bent on punishing the wicked, the fact that we haven't been able to stop him is bound to encourage him to keep right on doing it. He might even decide he's been chosen by God to do just that. And we all know that if you look for wickedness, even in a nice little town like Silence, you're bound to find it."
"Shit," Ethan said. He sighed. "Okay, people— whether Caldwell's murder is part of the rest or not is something we need to know, and pronto. Find out."
Carefully neutral, Justin said, "It might be a good idea to talk to his widow. I know the timing's lousy, but—"
The sheriff swore again, but under his breath. "Do it. Talk to anybody you need to talk to, but find the truth."
"No matter what that is?" Justin asked.
"No matter what."
"You see what I mean?" Shelby indicated the photo she'd just placed on the butcher-block table in Nell's kitchen. "I got a couple of other shots of you, but this was the only one where something I couldn't explain showed up. Definitely what I'd call weird."
Nell bent over the picture, frowning. The word she would have picked to describe it was unsettling. To see herself walking down the courthouse steps, completely unaware of the shadow looming over her… She felt a little chill crawl slowly up her spine. The sense she'd had of being watched was beginning to feel like a lot more than nerves at being back home again.
She said, "And there's nothing you can find to account for it? It isn't just a shadow of something, some object, outside the frame, or a problem with the lens, or—"
Shelby shook her head, bright-eyed. "Nope. I've considered every possibility that might account for it, and none of them fits. That shadow was not visible to the naked eye—only the eye of the camera. And it is definitely there. So unless you believe in ghosts… Do you, by the way?"
Nell smiled slightly without looking up. "As a matter of fact, I do. But according to everything I've heard on the subject, it's rare to find photographic evidence of a ghost outside in the open. Not unheard of, mind you, but rare."
"The scale's wrong too," Shelby said. "I mean, if we're talking the ghost of your average human being. My estimate is that the shadow is about seven feet tall. Or long. Whatever."
Nell traced that threatening shape with a finger, then sat back with a sigh, trying not to make it obvious that the slow chill was leaving icy tracks up and down her spine as if it meant to stay awhile. "And it's on the negative too?"
"Yeah." Shelby sipped her coffee, watching the other woman with those bright, speculative eyes. "This happened to be the only shot I took of you yesterday, so I have no way of knowing if the shadow was… following you around. Like Max was."
"Max I can handle," Nell said lightly.
"Can you?"
"You don't think so?"
Slowly now, Shelby said, "I think you and Max have a lot of history between you. And probably quite a few unanswered questions. But, Nell, what can be excused, even forgiven, of a seventeen-year-old girl isn't so easy to overlook in a woman pushing thirty. And Max isn't twenty-two anymore, forced by a very young girlfriend and her… unusual family to keep his distance and maybe not ask too many questions."
More briskly, Shelby added, "Of course, there were things he had to ask when you ran off. And since you weren't around for him to ask… From what I heard, he confronted your father that night. Did you know?"
"No." Nell refused to ask for more information about that, and a part of her hoped Shelby wouldn't offer it. But that was hardly Shelby's style.
"Max has never been one to complain publicly or tell his business to other people, we both know that. So everything I heard was second- or thirdhand. But my own father told my mother that Adam Gallagher bragged about how he'd kicked Max Tanner down his front steps. Literally."
Nell winced.
Watching her, Shelby said, "My own feeling is that Max wouldn't have fought back, not against your father, not if he couldn't be sure what had made you run away like that. He might have a hell of a temper, but Max doesn't strike out blindly. Maybe he even thought it was his fault, that he'd done something to drive you away. I know your father always claimed he didn't know why you'd run and blamed Max for it."
"It wasn't Max."
"No. I never thought it was. But some did, Nell. There were lots of theories, everything from date rape or an unplanned pregnancy to the idea that you found yourself caught between two domineering men and couldn't take it anymore."
Rather than answer the implied question of what had actually happened, Nell merely said, "It sounds like Max has… every right to be bitter."
"Yeah. But there he is." Shelby tapped the photograph with a finger, smiling faintly. "Couple of days after you're back in town, he's following you, maybe even watching over you. I guess he's the forgiving sort."
Again, Nell didn't answer the implied question of why Max might believe she could be in any kind of danger. "I guess he is. Or maybe he just wants a few answers."
"Maybe. And maybe you can handle him—at least this time around. But I'd be careful if I were you, Nell. Like I said, he isn't twenty-two anymore. And whatever he was twelve years ago, I don't think he's a man to be left behind now."
"He never was," Nell murmured. "Some things stay with you no matter how far you run." Before Shelby could pounce on that, she added in a stronger voice, "So maybe this… shadow… is following me, or maybe I just happened to pass by it yesterday. An old courthouse like this one is at least as likely as any other old building to house ghosts, I'd say."
"And the jail used to be in the basement," Shelby reminded her, accepting the change of subject without a blink. "I seem to recall at least one old story about an unjustly accused man committing suicide there. Aren't wrongful deaths supposed to be more likely to—inspire? create?—spirits?"
Nell dredged through the bits of knowledge and information her mind had absorbed in recent years. "Wrongful deaths. Sudden or violent deaths. Or people with some kind of unfinished work they desperately want to complete. At least, I think those are the most likely candidates to stay and make their presence felt rather than move on."
Shelby pursed her lips thoughtfully. "So this is just a ghost hanging around the courthouse, is that what we're saying?"
"Could be."
"Mmm. And are ghosts like that prone to loom over passersby in a threatening manner?"
"I'm not an expert, Shelby."
"Aren't you?"
"No."
"You don't have a crystal ball?"
"I'm afraid not."
"No tarot cards?"
Beginning to smile, Nell answered, "Sorry."
"Well," Shelby said in mock disgust, "of all the disappointments. And here I was expecting wild and mystical things of our returning witch."
"Yeah, Max told me that was the general attitude."
Shelby grinned at her. "Don't tell me you thought this town might have changed. Oh, no. Still narrow-minded and frightened of anything perceived to be too different, that's Silence. Or most of Silence, anyway."
"I'm surprised you choose to stay here," Nell offered.
"Are you? It's not so surprising, really. I'm perceived to be different—but not too different to present a threat. I like it here, all things considered." She cocked her head to one side like an inquisitive bird. "What about you? Any yearnings to stay put now that you're back home?"
"I've thought about it once or twice." Nell shrugged. "But I don't much like knowing I frighten people. Even ignorant people, afraid I'll put a curse on them or something."
"But you are psychic," Shelby said matter-of-factly.
In the same tone, Nell said, "Lots of people are psychic."
"I'm not."
Nell laughed under her breath. "Has it occurred to you that this shadow being visible might have had nothing to do with me and everything to do with you?"
Shelby frowned briefly, then shook her head. "No, because if that were so, I'd have seen something like it show up in my pictures long before now."
"Maybe. But psychic ability isn't always obvious from childhood, you know. Sometimes it… appears… fully blown in adulthood."
"Really?"
"So I've heard."
"Appears out of nowhere?"
Nell hesitated, then said, "Well, there's usually a trigger. A shock or some other kind of trauma."
"I haven't had anything like that," Shelby said, more disappointment than relief evident in her voice. "I've had a pretty boring and uneventful life, on the whole. And since this hasn't happened before, I think we can safely assume this shadow appeared on the picture because you were in it, not because I took it."
Giving in, Nell said, "Well, if we assume that, the question becomes—why? Why did this particular shadow appear in this particular shot on this particular day? Am I being haunted? Because I never have been before. Is it the courthouse being haunted? If that were true, it's at least possible you would have seen a shadow on other pictures before now. You have photographed the courthouse before?"
"Lots of times. With and without people. But I've never gotten a shadow like this one before."
Nell studied the photograph, trying to see some identifiable shape without imposing one created by her uneasy imagination. The shape was vaguely manlike but elongated somehow, distorted. And Shelby was right, it did almost seem to… loom over her.
A charitable soul might say the shadow curved over her almost as though sheltering her.
Nell thought it looked more threatening than protective.
"It gives me a bad feeling," Shelby said.
Hearing the seriousness in that statement and sharing the sentiment, Nell nevertheless said, "A shadow can't hurt me."
"If that's what it is. But there's nothing there to cast a shadow, Nell. Nothing with a physical presence, that is. So maybe it's something else. And maybe it can hurt you." She frowned. "I didn't want to say anything before, but you're looking a little… brittle today."
"I didn't sleep well, that's all."
"Just last night, or since you got home?"
Nell shrugged, the gesture itself an answer.
Grave, Shelby said, "Is that why you believe in ghosts? Because if so, I have a very comfortable guest room you're welcome to."
"No, this house isn't haunted." Nell grimaced slightly. "No footsteps on the stairs or chains rattling in the night or unexplained cold spots. I haven't seen or heard anything—out of the ordinary." She wasn't about to mention the vision of her father here in this room or admit that several times she could have sworn someone had whispered her name; there were no ghosts in this house, she was sure of that.
Besides which, though Shelby had been the closest thing to a female friend she'd had as a kid, her own secretive nature had prevented her from confiding much at all of her life or her abilities, and she wasn't willing to go into any of that now.