The Lie Detectors (41 page)

Read The Lie Detectors Online

Authors: Ken Alder

541
"paranoid emotional core":
Richard M. Brickner,
Is Germany Incurable?
(Philadelphia, Pa.: Lippincott, 1943), 263.

542
"Democracy":
Henry W. Ehrmann,"An Experiment in Political Education,"
Social Research
14 (1947): 304–320, quotation, 319.

543
"militarists":
NARA/RG389/439A/48: Maxwell McKnight, "Memorandum for Chief, Field Service Branch," 6/7/45.

544
"sold someone a bill":
NARA/RG389/413.6/1643: Maxwell McKnight to Colonel Powell, 7/27/45.

545
"pro-communist in scope":
Robin,
Barbed-Wire College,
143.

546
Keeler found that 36 percent:
NARA/RG389/319.1/1627: L.K., "Report [POW Screening Project]," 9/12/45.

547
"those with a sincere":
NARA/RG389/439A/40: R. W. Pierce, "Report on Screening of German Prisoners," 8/30/45.

548
"We often were told":
NARA/RG389/1629: Siegfried Cammann to [Intelligence Officer], 10/12/45.

549
"a habit not desirable":
NARA/RG389/1629: Alpheus Smith to Edward Davidson, 11/9/45.

550
While only 6 percent:
Robin,
Barbed-Wire College,
162–163. See also Arthur L. Smith, Jr.,
The War for the German Mind: Reeducating Hitler’s Soldiers
(Providence, R.I.: Berghahn, 1996).

551
Oak Ridge was a city:
James Overholt, ed.,
These Are Our Voices: The Story of Oak Ridge, 1942–1970
(Oak Ridge, Tenn.: Children’s Museum of Oak Ridge, 1987). Russell B. Olwell,
At Work in the Atomic City: A Labor and Social History of Oak Ridge, Tennessee
(Knoxville: University of Tennessee Press, 2004).

552
"insofar as possible"
and
"stolen product":
NARA/RG326/148: AEC, "Use of Lie Detector at AEC Installations," 3/24/53; with information on Keeler’s work of 1946. For an explanation of the "thefts," see NARA/RG326/149: AEC, "In the Matter of ‘Lie-Detector’ Panel Meeting," 1/24/52, p. 42. For a description of the Oak Ridge program by someone with access to the private records of the examiners, see John G. Linehan, "The Oak Ridge Polygraph Program,"
Polygraph
19 (1990): 131–137.

553
"heavily infested":
J. Parnell Thomas and Stacy V. Jones,"Reds in Our Atom-Bomb Plants,"
Liberty
(6/21/47): 15, 90–93. See local and national coverage:
Knoxville Journal,
6/5/47;
WP,
7/12/46, 6/5/47, 7/15/47. For context, see Wang,
Age of Anxiety,
149–180; Richard G. Hewlett and Oscar E. Anderson, Jr.,
A History of the United States Energy Commission,
vol. 2,
Atomic Shield,
ed. Richard G. Hewlett and Francis Duncan (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1990), 92–93.

554
By the early 1950s:
NARA/RG326/149: AEC, "In the Matter of ‘Lie-Detector’ Panel Meeting," 1/24/52.

555
"Q: Have you belonged":
LKP-DoD: Arnold Cohen,"Lecture," 2/12/54.

556
"friends or relatives":
NARA/RG326/148: AEC, "Use of Lie Detector at AEC Installations," 3/24/53.

557
"liberal thoughts":
NARA (Southeast)/RG326: F. P. Callaghan to J. S. Denton, 5/28/51.

558
That the test uncovered:
National Academy of Sciences, ed. Fienberg,
Polygraph,
48.

559
"on the ball"
to
"so to speak":
NARA/RG340/1: Paul V. Trovillo,"Report on a Survey of…Polygraph Program at Oak Ridge," 4/14/51.

560
"mental relief from worry":
ORP: J. C. Franklin to Carroll Wilson, 10/10/47.

561
By 1952 some 50,000:
R. Chatham, "Public Employee Screening," in "Selected Papers on the Polygraph,"
Conference on Criminal Interrogation and Lie Detection,
New York University, 11/8/1952 (N.p.: Board of Polygraph Examiners, 1956), 46. See also
Oak Ridger,
4/14/53.

562
"almost universal":
Dr. Richard Meiling, "Military Medical Problems,"6/27/51, quoted in Advisory Committee on Human Research Experiments,
Final Report
(Washington, D.C.: GPO, 1998), ch. 10, http://www.eh.doe.gov/ohre/roadmap/achre/.

563
"atomic support":
Alfred Hausrath et al.,"Troop Performance on a Training Maneuver Involving the Use of Atomic Weapons," Operation Research Office, Johns Hopkins University, ORO-T-0, (3/52), 53–61. For an account based on an unpublished manuscript by Chatham and Trovillo, see John G. Linehan,"Historical Note: Polygraph Research Study of Fear in a Field Situation, Review of a 1951 Study,"
Polygraph
25 (1996): 152–158. See also Howard L. Rosenberg,
Atomic Soldiers: American Victims of Nuclear Experiments
(Boston, Mass.: Beacon, 1980), 41.

564
"men standing straight":
Paul Boyer,
By the Bomb’s Early Light: American Thought at the Dawn of the Atomic Age
(Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1994), 300.

565
fears of 46 percent:
Irving Gitlin, "Radio and Atomic-Energy Education,"
Journal of Educational Sociology
22 (1949): 327–330.

566
"others"
and
"lousy":
NARA/RG340/1: Trovillo,"Report on a Survey.".

567
"raising a fuss":
UCA/AORES/6: AORES, "It Is Time to Protest about Security," 9/7/47. See Truman,
NYT,
9/14/48.

568
"40 percent of senior physicists and chemists":
UCA/AORES/50: R. W. Stoughton to Senator Bourke Hickenlooper, 9/17/48.

569
"an instrument of third-degree":
"‘Lie Detector’ Doesn’t,"
Science News Letter
49 (3/30/46): 207.

570
"an unfavorable and sometimes":
NARA/RG326/148: AEC, "Use of Lie Detector at AEC Installations," 3/18/53.

571
"violent opposition"
to
"assur[ing] that":
NARA/RG326/149: AEC, "In the Matter of ‘Lie-Detector’ Panel Meeting," 1/24/52.

572
In December 1951:
Anthony Leviero, "U.S. Tests Staff by Lie Detectors,"
NYT,
12/20/51. See also the follow-up in
WP,
12/21/51.

573
"un-American":
Wayne Morse, "Use of Lie Detectors,"
Congressional Record
98(7), 1/17/52, pp. 258–262. Leviero, "Morse Denounces,"
NYT,
1/18/52.

574
"the examiner draws":
Fred Inbau, in NARA/RG326/149: AEC,"In the Matter of ‘Lie-Detector’ Panel Meeting," 1/24/52.

575
"In many respects":
NARA/RG59/16/ConferenceReport: Peter Regis, "Conference of Regional Security Supervisors," 4/53.

CHAPTER 16. PINKOS

576
"Such a hypothetical":
Isaac Asimov,
Second Foundation,
in
The Foundation Trilogy
(Garden City, N.Y.: Doubleday, 1953), 208.

577
"cover":
DDRS: Colonel S. Edwards to Director of CIA, "Project Bluebird, Memorandum," 4/5/50; Sidney Gottlieb, "Prospectus for Continuation of Research Project II on LSD," 6/9/53. See also John Marks,
The Search for the "Manchurian Candidate": The CIA and Mind Control
(New York: Times Books, 1979); McCoy,
Question of Terror.

578
Popular books:
Edward Hunter,
Brainwashing: The Story of the Men Who Defied It
(Farrar, Straus & Cudahy, 1956). For Hunter’s affiliation with the CIA and the origins of the term "brainwashing," see Marks,
Search for the "Manchurian Candidate,"
125–126. Even books with a different political orientation made comparable claims; see Joost A. M. Meerloo,
The Rape of the Mind
(Cleveland, Ohio: World, 1956).

579
As one British author:
William Sargant,
Battle for the Mind: A Physiology of Conversion and Brain-Washing
(Garden City, N.Y.: Doubleday, 1957), 192–196.

580
"we begin palely":
Joseph and Stewart Alsop, "Lie-Detector Piling Up Records,"
WP,
2/21/54.

581
"An illusion can become":
George Orwell,"England, Your England," in
Inside the Whale and Other Essays
(Harmondsworth, England: Penguin, [1941], 1957), 71.

582
Keeler’s former partner:
George Haney,"Report on…Polygraph…of Korean Nationals and Communist Chinese," Operations Research Office, ORO-S-85, 11/14/50, archived at http://antipolygraph.org/read.shtml.

583
"playing it cool":
Albert D. Biderman,
March to Calumny: The Story of American POW’s in the Korean War
(New York: Macmillan, 1963), 43–45. Compare this with Eugene Kinkead,
In Every War but One
(New York: Norton, 1959).

584
Dean had been the first:
William F. Dean,
General Dean’s Story
(New York: Viking, 1954), 130–131.

585
"red herring": NYT,
8/6/48.

586
"whichever one of you":
Representative F. Edward Hebert, in Special Subcommittee of the U.S. House Un-American Activities Committee (HUAC), "Hearings Regarding Communist Espionage in the U.S. Government,"8/16/48, at http://www.law.umkc.edu/faculty/projects/ftrials/hiss/hiss.html.

587
"
CHAMBERS
: Yes":
HUAC, "Hearings Regarding Communist Espionage,"8/7/48.

588
"fly out and assist":
RNP: L.K. to Richard Nixon, 8/14/48.

589
"the outstanding man":
HUAC, "Hearings Regarding Communist Espionage," 8/16/48.

590
"
not
, however, a ‘lie detector’":
Alger Hiss to J. Parnell Thomas, 8/18/48; in
New York Herald Tribune,
8/20/48. Also in Alger Hiss,
In the Court of Public Opinion
(New York: Knopf, 1957), 420–421, emphasis in original. See also
New York Herald Tribune,
8/17/48; Sam Tanenhaus,
Whittaker Chambers: A Biography
(New York: Random House, 1997), 253–254, 265, 586; Allen Weinstein,
Perjury: The Hiss-Chambers Case
(New York: Knopf, 1978), 21–40.

591
"In the opinion": NYT,
8/22/48. See also
New Yorker,
9/4/48.

592
"82 percent accurate": WP,
8/23/48.

593
In later years Nixon:
Richard M. Nixon,
Six Crises
(Garden City, N.Y.: Doubleday, 1962), 17–18, 29.

594
"I don’t know anything":
NARA/NixonWhiteHouseTapes/545-3: Nixon, 7/24/71.

595
Now he offered: NYT,
3/22/54. But see also
WP,
6/2/54.

596
"security risks": NYT,
3/1/50.

597
"the sexual perverts":
Guy George Gabrielson, quoted in
NYT,
4/19/50.

598
The Kinsey Report:
Alfred Kinsey, Wardell Pomeroy, and Clyde Martin,
Sexual Behavior in the Human Male
(Philadelphia, Pa.: Saunders, [1948], 1949).

599
"Is he?":
Cheever, quoted in Johnson,
Lavender,
53–55.

600
"90 twisted twerps":
Jack Lait and Lee Mortimer,
Washington Confidential
(New York: Crown, 1951), 90.

601
"When the son of the Democrat senator":
Johnson,
Lavender,
140–141.

602
"peculiar lips":
Blevins in NARA/RG59/1953–60/b12/BureauSecurity: C. M. Dulin to Michael J. Ambrose, 4/16/53.

603
"quick test":
[Hoey Hearings], U.S. Senate, Investigation Subcommittee, Committee on Expenditures in the Executive Departments, Executive Sessions,"Report of Proceedings," 7/26/50, 2256.

Other books

Stone Walls by A.M. Madden
Anna's Healing by Vannetta Chapman
Defiant Brides by Nancy Rubin Stuart
A Shiloh Christmas by Phyllis Reynolds Naylor
All for Allie by Julie Bailes
Tree Girl by T. A. Barron
Sherwood by S. E. Roberts
Legend of the Book Keeper by Daniel Blackaby